Ady Gil captain attempts arrest on whalers
Mon, 15 Feb 2010 5:49p.m.
By Samantha Hayes
New Zealander Pete Bethune has boarded a Japanese whaling ship under cover of darkness and attempted to arrest the captain for the attempted murder of the Ady Gil crew.
He also presented the captain with a bill of $4.3 million for the destruction of his vessel.
Anti whaling campaigners from the Sea shepherd called it “mission impossible”.
Captain Paul Watson, of the Sea Shepherd Steve Irvin, says the mission was “extremely dangerous”.
“He took a jet ski in the dead of night and boarded a vessel moving at 15 knots through the water - a vessel surrounded by spikes and nets,” he says.
Mr Bethune was on board the Shonan Maru 2 for 90 minutes before he attempted a citizen's arrest of the captain, for what he calls the attempted murder of his crew when their vessels collided.
Mr Bethune's Ady Gil later sank, and today he also presented a bill for $4.3 million to replace it.
Mr Watson says the mission intended to highlight the hypocrisy surrounding the law.
“What we're trying to do here is to send a message to the New Zealand Government to represent the interest of a New Zealand captain and a New Zealand vessel,” he says.
“Because I can tell you right now that if we had had sunk a Japanese vessel we would now be under arrest by the Australian navy.”
Mr Bethune was in contact with the Steve Irwin but his radio has been confiscated.Now he wants to be delivered to New Zealand.
Steve Irwin’s first officer Locky MacLean says the Japanese vessel should return Mr Bethune home.
“There is a loose maritime law that if you sink someone's vessel you’re obliged to give them safe passage home,” he says.
The Japanese have called the boarding illegal. They say it's just not practical for the two ships to pull alongside each other to return Mr Bethune – and he may be taken to Japan.
* Copy of full letter presented to Japanese captain
To: The Captain of the Shonan Maru
From: Pete Bethune – Captain of Ady Gil
Opinions from Maritime experts agree that in the ramming of the Ady Gil, which occurred on 6th January 2010, that you were responsible for the event.
Below is their opinion:
1. You approached from my port side, so I had right of way
2. You were the overtaking vessel so you had an obligation to keep well clear of me
3. Your water canons impeded yours and our view leading up to the ramming, which may have exacerbated the situation
4. You fired LRADs at us, adding to the general state of confusion
5. You turned hard to starboard at the last moment, deliberately ramming my vessel and endangering my crew.
6. The Ady Gil sank as a result of your actions in ramming it.
I am here to arrest you. I am requesting that you transfer now to the Steve Irwin, where we will take you into custody, and we will deliver you to the Maritime Safety Authority and the New Zealand Police once we reach Wellington (New Zealand).
If you refuse to be arrested, then I am requesting that you deliver me to Wellington (New Zealand). Having sunk my vessel, and with our issuing of a mayday call, you have an obligation under maritime law to provide me with safe passage back to land.
I will refuse to be handed over to any Sea Shepherd vessel. I will also refuse to be handed over to any New Zealand or Australian Coastguard, Customs or Naval vessel. I will only leave the Shonan Maru when you transfer with me to the Steve Irwin, or when we arrive on land, be it New Zealand or Australia.
I am enclosing an invoice for US$3m, representing the new replacement cost of the Ady Gil. You are responsible for the collision and as such, you are also responsible for paying for its replacement.
I commit to you that while I am on your vessel, that I will not impede or disrupt your crew and their activities.
I believe strongly that Japan should cease whaling in the Southern Ocean Whale sanctuary. You have no right to go taking these whales, which are over 12,000km
from the shores of Japan.
To argue it is part of your culture does not make it right. Sudan still practices circumcision of women, and they argue it is part of their culture, but that doesn’t make it right.
The way the whales are killed is barbaric. Most western people, and probably most Japanese people, would be appalled if they witnessed the tortured death of a whale as it slowly bleeds out on the end of an explosive harpoon.
Society gradually changes what it perceives as acceptable. Slavery for example was once considered acceptable. Thankfully society changed its view on this. Similarly, whaling was once considered acceptable, but no more.
I am just an ordinary man with a wife and two kids, who is prepared to make a stand against something that I believe is wrong.
That is why I came to Antarctica to try and stop you, and that is why I am here on your vessel today.
Captain – Ady Gil
Post a Comment
Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide
(Won't be published)
19/02/2010 7:19:37 p.m.
Benjamin Carl Robinson wrote:
I think the Japanese should pay the bill and give him safe passage home. I like most Japanese yet the whalers are pretty rough with people so I do not care much for their actions taking whales they say is for research.(Food markets in Japan etc.)
19/02/2010 12:24:34 a.m.
What a loser. I have to agree, it's his own fault his boat was sunk. How can you hold someone else responsible when you go up against a boat bigger than yours and then lose? I'm tired of all these groups, be they green peace, sea shepherd, etc. If you ask me, they should be labeled as terrorist organizations and put in jail when they trespass or attack other vessels. What happens to people who illegally board ships around somalia? If they are caught they face jail time and best case, they are shot.
17/02/2010 7:27:10 p.m.
the anti-whaling campaign that the SS endorses is deliberate misinterpretation and a completely hypocritical view of the world. Why is it we designate some animals completely okay to slaughter and consume, then go into convulsions when a whale is eaten?
I honestly hope that the Japanese whalers stiffen their resistance to the SS's antics and try this idiot captain.
17/02/2010 5:40:12 p.m.
pete had every right to go onto the whaling ship. atleast he is trying to do something in this world.good on him. i wouldnt call the protesters hippies. there doing there job and saving the whales. if people like you dont care than you obviously dont have a heart thats all i can say! pete is no attention seeker. i know him very well and id say he better than all you!
17/02/2010 3:03:34 a.m.
This idiot should seriously think that rather than being a poor jobless, better to get a proper job. Why didn't he donate Mil$ to poor and starbed people rather than dumping into deep ocean?
16/02/2010 9:56:03 a.m.
Davin Dunthorne wrote:
LOOK . its quite obvious that these whale murders are NOT science. WHY would you NEED to KILL 680 whales a YEAR in the NAME of Science. what makes this SERIAL KILLING of whales any different from any serial killing of humans. you WOULDNT kill 680 humans a year for research would we ???? hmm maybe the argument of the japanese is "we need to kill that many a year" . BULLOCKS ! if any one looks hard enough there will be a different way. These so called HIPPIES, have my entire support for its people like them who protect these creatures that are are beautiful and unique just like every other living thing in this world that people seem intent on destroying with complete ignorance to even doing so.. so open you eyes and LOOK
15/02/2010 8:25:11 p.m.
this guy bethune is an attention seeker, pure and simple.
Mate, get a real job. You have already done enough damage - especially to some poor South American fisherman ran down by your stupid rich boy 'adventuring' not long ago. I wonder how that poor man's family are faring?
15/02/2010 7:41:08 p.m.
Get real Bethune. I hope they throw you in the brig. Your as much to blame for the loss of your boat as anyone as you shouldnt have been there doing what you were doing under maritime law.I would love to know how much Sea Shepherd has made out of this, it would be quite surprising.
15/02/2010 7:09:20 p.m.
“There is a loose maritime law that if you sink someone's vessel you’re obliged to give them safe passage home,"
Really? But Bethune had already been picked up by Bob Barker which later stopped by at a port, and after that he accompanied the rest of the Sea Shepherd team VOLUNTARILY. He also boarded the Japanese ship of his own accord.
"The Japanese have called the boarding illegal"
If you're sailing on the high seas and you wake up one morning to find someone on another ship has entered your bridge, wouldn't that be considered illegal?
15/02/2010 6:43:42 p.m.
haha these fools were stupid enough to gamble a 4.6 mil ship, and loss. now they want a refund? what a joke. get a real job you hippies
Hopes dimmed for talks aimed at ending the Afghan war when an angry President Ha...
The numbers of refugees and those displaced by conflict within their own nation ...
The royals' office has released some of the expectant couple's plans, although m...
Appealing for a new citizen activism in the free world, President Barack Obama h...
Scattered street demonstrations popped up around Brazil, continuing protests aga...
Copyright © 2013 MediaWorks TV. All Rights Reserved.