Animal cruelty or just harmless fun

Print

Wed, 30 Sep 2009 7:27p.m.

New pub game "Catch a Cray".

New pub game "Catch a Cray".

By Tony Reid

Anyone who has tried to catch a crayfish will know that it is not the easiest of tasks.

First you have got to find them, once you do you are only allowed to snag them by hand, or noose or some other fishing device.

But, all that is changing with a pub game that puts patrons up against crays for just three bucks.

However a couple of animal support groups are not happy about it.

Inside the Albion Bar, “Catcha Cray” is one of their newer attractions.

As the poster promises, you can catch your own live cray, without getting wet and for a fraction of the cost of buying one.

“Catcha Cray” has been in Auckland bars for a few months, it started off with a hiss and a roar, but some bad press has landed its owner Patrick Chandulal in hot water.

“I'm very angry, yeah certainly. Certain organisations, absolutely not true,” Mr Chandulal says.

Those organisations are animal rights group SAFE which has launched an online campaign against a game it says treats crays like soft toys.

Bob Kerridge from the SPCA is not amused either.

“They are a living creature, it's disgusting,” says Mr Kerridge

But this is news to Mr Chandulal, who had a visit from the SPCA back in June when he was fine tuning the game.

Mr Kerridge confirmed for us that one of his inspectors did indeed visit, and he says the advice issued was wrong and maintains Mr Chandulal should have known better.

The Ministry of Fisheries has no specific code for the care of crays so there is no black and white answer as to whether it constitutes animal cruelty.

But SAFE has made up it's mind and is naming and shaming bars which stock the game.

So far, two bars have bowed to pressure.

But Mr Chandulal will not budge, he says his game is a hit, and it is here to stay.

“99 percent of the customers are happy,” he says.


 

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

10 Feb 2010 06:43p.m.

Jarrod wrote:

So many other worse things going on around us and you people choose this one to moan and winge about!
I surpose your not worried about the way livestock and commercially caught fish are caught, kept and handled,(tagging of ears, sheering sheep, catching and processing of commercially caught fish etc.) You people need to get your head out of the sand!!!!! why don't you people take "everything" head on.
I surpose its alright to hunt pigs by chasing them with dogs, then when their to tired to run anymore the dogs hold them by the ears or balls or both until the hunters catch up,by this time normally the ears have been torn off. The hunter then sticks the big with a knife through the heart!!!!
I don't see SAFE or the SPCA shutting down pig hunting, which by yours and most peoples standards is considered very cruel. Or is it not because its a sport?

I hope all you people complaining are Vegetarians!!!!!!!!!!!!

09 Feb 2010 03:41p.m.

Richard wrote:

Again i listen to the foreign accents of those in Bureaucratic or Activist bodies pouring their own views through the media.

What are you going to ban next you dreamers ! fishhooks?

08 Feb 2010 07:31p.m.

Ryan wrote:

These machines disgust me! I just saw an interview of the man who made them on 'close up' and he was very aggressive and blurted abuse such as 'Get a real job' to the SAFE member present. This is obvious animal cruelty and I hope they are banned soon, and new laws about the keeping of animals are put in place. People who play this for entertainment disgust me. If you must, do it with the SOFT TOY machines - where nothing gets harmed, it's the same lame thrill you get from this repetitive game. You can be entertained without abusing animals!!

08 Feb 2010 06:56p.m.

sue wrote:

Why do these morons find this entertaining. Yo be plucked from the water up to 30 times . Disgusting. Yes , they are food , but a quick stress free death is their right. The Albion has one now I hear. That's one bar that has lost my patronage.

08 Oct 2009 12:07p.m.

Micah wrote:

This game is just wrong i don't support this at all crayfish do have feelings as do you so help SAFE stop this NOW! http://safe.org.nz/Campaigns/Stop-the-Catcha-Cray/ Go Safe!

07 Oct 2009 12:46p.m.

Matt T wrote:

It's great to see that bars are listening to their customers and removing these disgusting machines! Complain to the others here: www.safe.org.nz What is wrong with people that they think it's acceptable to treat a live animal like it is a soft toy?

05 Oct 2009 09:15p.m.

shayne wrote:

Rachel's babble aside.
If this game turned up at my local i'd play it.

05 Oct 2009 06:59p.m.

Alex wrote:

How embarrassing it is for us that we allow such barbaric games in modern NZ. Of course the crayfish will feel it. Treating it like an item won't hide the fact that is living, breathing. That is disgusting. Oh, and "Michelle"? Just because we have a sense of moral pride, and we know whats right and whats not does not make us drugged up hippies. I'm sure your opinion would change if YOU were that crayfish.

02 Oct 2009 08:22a.m.

Lewis wrote:

Allowing drunk patrons to torment live animals for money has to be definition of immoral behavior. That this is legal in New Zealand only shows that our animal cruelty laws need reform. I hope that customers at the four bars that still have these machines urge their removal.

02 Oct 2009 08:19a.m.

Bruce wrote:

After reading their website www.catchacray.co.nz my opinion has changed. There doesn't seem to be any cruelty at all. I suggest you should look it the website before you make an opinion. I want one machine in my pub now!