Anti-Asian fliers a 'publicity stunt' - sociologist

Print

Thu, 12 May 2011 7:43a.m.

The upcoming election would have been a factor in the group’s targeting of Asians, Mr Spoonley says (NZPA)

The upcoming election would have been a factor in the group’s targeting of Asians, Mr Spoonley says (NZPA)

The Right-Wing Resistance group circulating anti-Asian fliers throughout Christchurch is causing anger within the community, but Massey University sociologist Paul Spoonley thinks it’s a publicity stunt.

The group, which was formed two years ago in Christchurch and is led by Kyle Chapman, has sparked concerns that racially motivated violence may occur as a result of the pamphlet drop.

Mr Spoonley, who has been researching the group since its formation two years ago, spoke to Firstline this morning.

The Right-Wing Resistance claims the leaflets are part of a recruitment drive, but Mr Spoonley says the move is “primarily to ensure publicity”.

He says the strategy of circulating anti-Asian fliers in high-population Asian areas is a long-standing one.  

“They’re trying to provoke a reaction… the numbers they’re going to recruit in these areas are going to be very small, if any.”

The upcoming election would have been a factor in the group’s targeting of Asians, Mr Spoonley says.

“We’ve had in past election years quite a campaign against Asians… and given the arrival of Asians, particularly Chinese and Indians, since 2000 it’s an obvious target.

“They’re testing the water, seeing if there is support for an anti-Asian party.”

The Right-Wing Resistance has no history of violence, but Mr Spoonley believes that the police will take a serious view of the group as similar white supremacist groups have caused violence in the past.

When asked if he expected the group to find support in Auckland, Mr Spoonley said the chances are “practically none”.

“In terms of Auckland there is no history of these groups – it’s much more likely to be a South Island thing,” he said.

“They’re talking up a big march, but their marches have been quite small and they’re not likely to get many up here in Auckland.”

Mr Spoonley said that Christchurch had the “dubious honour” of being the home of white supremacy,

“There’s a group of disaffected young white males down there… and there’s a bit of a tradition of white supremacy in Christchurch.”

 
3 News
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

15 May 2011 07:46p.m.

Ai be Yea wrote:

I liked how the interviewer lost all objectivity and started tut tutting with the critic.
The Flier writers were not allowed any studio interview to explain THEMSELVES

and then to top it all off she reveals her real subconscious concerns about Samoans and Tongans creating a lot more trouble than Chinese and not being targetted at all!

Classic!

13 May 2011 02:30p.m.

Ruz wrote:

the flyer was designed to generate media interest and publicity. The aim it seems was to attract more members to his organisation. However the fundamental question is whether the flyer was designed to incite racial hatred or whether it was simply an expression of free speech. My view is that unless the flyer encouraged racial hatred that manifested itself in violence or real harm it must be regarded as free speech. We would be a slippery slope if we crushed ideas and views simply because they do not agree with our own. That is what happens in China. For those immigrants that feel aggrieved by what Chapman and his group says and believes - just ignore them as you know your own worth and contribution.

13 May 2011 09:57a.m.

Boyd wrote:

Like all bullies and cowards they pick on a passive minority group like Asians. Dare they pick on a minority with sharper teeth - say Maori or Polynesians - they would all be crucified before lunch. You would think that instead of handing out flyers they would make better use of themselves by helping rebuild Christchurch where alot of them are from. Priorities I guess...

12 May 2011 11:15p.m.

Boyd wrote:

Its jealousy pure and simple. Its the same deadly sin that started up the Nazi's. In 1930's Germany in the midsts of the Depression the Jews had all the top jobs. So the Germans turned towards some screaming homicidal nutcase with one nut (forget his name) to bend the rules in the Germans favour.
So here we are just coming out of a recession and the Asians supposedly are taking our top jobs. And people like Kyle Chapman are jealous. People say the holocaust will never happen again? Well the jury's still out for me...

12 May 2011 10:25p.m.

A Chinese guy wrote:

I am very disappointed about that, me and my friends donated hundreds dollars to Christchurch and then we get this kind of response from you...it hurts.

12 May 2011 01:03p.m.

KiwiNow wrote:

We donated some money when the earthquake hit Christchurch. All we were thinking was that we are part of the NZ and we wanted to contribute.

12 May 2011 12:34p.m.

Ricardo wrote:

The 'swastika' in Asia faces the opposite way to Hitler's one.

12 May 2011 11:46a.m.

David Jacobs wrote:

For a number of years I have believed in and admired the Asian regimen of saving, spending only when necessary, and not relying on credit.
I believe that this campaign against Asians is spurred by jealousy within the ranks of the have-nots (cannots, and will nots)
I proudly admit that I have a percentage of Chinese blood flowing through my veins, and that my ancestors arrived in New Zealand in 1840, achieving financially and educationally by shear hard work.
If these extremists wish to expound their anti-social views, let them first declare their New Zealand pedigree, otherwise hold their peace and allow others to conduct their lives without being subjected to hatred and prejudice.

12 May 2011 11:40a.m.

Milky wrote:

First off all. These Nationalists aren't Skinheads, they're 'Boneheads' there's a difference between the two - to break it down for you Skinhead culture was formed by Jamaican immigrants sharing their music, life style and fashion with working class British youth and them doing the same back in return. To call yourself a Skinhead and be a right wing White Supremacist is technically and obviously an oxymoron. I've been a Skinhead myself for quite awhile and I'm not even white, look it all up on Google if you have to - the facts, answers and proof are all blatantly there; To us proper Skinheads these R.W.R idiots are what we like to call (and what the rest of the world should call them) 'Boneheads' and the same goes to any wannabe Skinhead who represents Neo Nazism. Secondly the word Aryan comes from Sanskrit which I'm pretty sure is Asian; The Sanskirt speaks of a battle between two classes (eg: upper and lower), Aryan being one of them - this proves that Aryan isn't even a race so these Boneheads are just making fools out of themselves - on top of that they're trying to claim political rights in a country which doesn't even belong to them and they're trying to find support in Auckland - enough said. I'd like to see them try it around West Side, see how these jokers try recruiting 'locals' (free amateur dental care for the lot of them) Anak Timur!

12 May 2011 09:46a.m.

New Zealander wrote:

10 years ago I’ve arrived to NZ, and from day one I’ve been contributing to this country, currently employing 14 New Zealanders whom most of them are white.

What do those so called white supremacist trash do apart of inciting hatred and dividing communities, nothing but setting in their bums all day drinking beer and smell like pigs.


Chinese people are very polite and civilized people. If given the choice to live in ChCh or China, I would pick up China with no hesitation. No one wants to live in a City that full of skin heads who know nothing but racism and fascism. Wake up trash, the world is changing, and if you can’t change your screwed mindset, then you and your kids will be left behind picking trash and completely disconnected from the new emerging world.

NZ isn’t the UK, and everyone in here comes from somewhere except the Maori. So skin heads, why can’t you go back to where your parents originally come from as you have no place in our civilized NZ.

Promise you, you’ll die of hatred as you won’t stop the changes in NZ. GO and get a decent job and live allow others to live.

I’ve friends from all different race and colour, and through them I’ve increased my cultural knowledge and their friendship made me a happy individual.


So trash skin heads, I suggest you try to change your fascist mindset by embracing the new New Zealand, and by trying to have non-skin heads friends – and your life will change to the better.

Peace