Airport flu scare slammed as 'over-reaction'

Print

Mon, 13 Feb 2012 6:05p.m.

The holdup was because 60 Japanese students on board had flu-like symptoms

The holdup was because 60 Japanese students on board had flu-like symptoms

By Amanda Gillies

Air New Zealand passengers at Auckland International Airport were left furious and frustrated as a few sniffles on board became a full-scale health drama.

Ambulances were called, hospitals placed on standby, and the flight was effectively quarantined.

It was, in the words of one health official, an “over-reaction”.

Three hours after her daughter landed, Rhonda Borgas was finally reunited with her daughter Lauren.

“We just got told once we landed that we were probably going to go into quarantine and we sat on the tarmac for what - almost one and a half hours - without any information. It was really terrible. We didn't get any water, nothing. We were just sweating to death.”

The holdup was because 60 Japanese students on board had flu-like symptoms. Some had coughed through the night.

“It was a bit of a shambles to be honest,” says passenger David Turner.

“The captain kept coming on the radio and saying ‘we are sorry we don't know where the ambulance is. For some reason the air bridge isn't docking and no one is coming on’. The information was pretty poor.”

Eventually, fully-kitted out medical staff boarded the plane to test the 17-year-old’s. Ambulances waited nearby, Auckland hospitals were put on standby.

Around 11am passengers finally disembarked but only as far as a holding room.

“That was probably the worse thing - for a while a lot of the students were sitting in the room with us,” says Mr Turner. “And I said ‘I’m not comfortable being in the same room as these students’. And they said ‘you have already been on the plane with them for 10 hours. What are you worried about’.”

Mr Turner missed his flight to Wellington.

All the students and their teachers had been vaccinated in November - and were finally cleared by health officials.

Let's Homestay, the Tauranga company hosting the students, says the response was over-the-top.

“There are a couple with a few sniffles [but] they have just come from a winter in Japan - it's kind of expected,” says Stuart Cundy from Let's Homestay. “It has been exaggerated a bit. There were other passengers on the plane coughing and spluttering.”

Dr Richard Hoskins from Auckland Regional Public Health says the response was an “over-reaction”.

“Yes in hindsight you would classify this as an over-reaction, but we had a large group of people travelling into the country that we were notified of in good time, and we had to take it seriously until we knew it wasn't a significant new illness for New Zealand.”

It did give the students something to write home about.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

14 Feb 2012 02:43p.m.

renee neumann wrote:

i dont think this was an over reaction as i dont think most people and places are carefull enough with these sorts of things thats how we get these viruses and sicknesses in our country!i think they did a great job!!!and should not hesitate to do it again if in doubt its better to be safe than sorry!!!well done air nz!!!

14 Feb 2012 12:10p.m.

Jeremy wrote:

I wouldn't call it an over-reaction, rather this is the appropriate reaction to an event such as this. It was however a poorly managed reaction.

14 Feb 2012 12:09a.m.

Katrina wrote:

I agree Mark

13 Feb 2012 11:49p.m.

Erm... wrote:

This is a classic example of what happens when little people have a little power. A MASSIVE over reaction. Do these people not communicate?? They've made the country seem silly in the eyes of potential tourists.

13 Feb 2012 08:44p.m.

Mark Wgtn wrote:

It appears to have been very poorly handled, and passengers were uncomfortably inconvenienced but I'd rather have an over-reaction early in such an event than a "too little too late" response later on. (As so often seems to happen in a crisis.)