Auckland Rugby Union launches investigation into semi-final brawl

Print

Sun, 16 Aug 2009 12:00a.m.

The brawl spilled over to the sideline – intensifying as spectators ran onto the field to join in

The brawl spilled over to the sideline – intensifying as spectators ran onto the field to join in

By Kate Lynch

The Auckland Rugby Union says it will find and suspend the instigators of an ugly brawl at an Auckland first XV semi final between Kelston and Auckland Grammar.

While video of the incident suggests Kelston threw the first punch, the school’s principal says racial taunts from drunk Grammar old boys inflamed the situation.

The Union will review footage of the fight, recorded by television cameras and witnessed by All Black Coach Graham Henry.

It was the moment that rugby rivalry turned to violence. As Auckland Grammar scored a last-minute try to seal victory, arch-rivals Kelston vented their frustration and anger.

Fists from both sides continued to fly as the brawl spilled over to the sideline – intensifying as spectators ran onto the field to join in.

The mother of one Auckland Grammar student was caught up in the thick of it.

The fight lasted for five minutes, and lead to one Grammar boy being knocked out.

Auckland Grammar are adamant Kelston started it.

“I think Kelston were a little bit frustrated that they had a player sent off early in the second half, and I think their frustrations spilled over into what was a pretty nasty incident right on fulltime,” says Auckland Grammar Rugby Director Grant Hansen.

“It got really ugly with not only players, but spectators becoming involved.”

The incident was witnessed by 2,500 people, including Graham Henry, a man who has coached First XV’s at both schools, and was principal at Kelston Boys.

“It was disappointing, obviously,” he says.

“It was a major game of secondary school rugby, and it’s disappointing to see that.”

After the brawl, the Kelston coach made his feelings clear to his players.

“You shake hands and you accept responsibility,” he said.

“You take it on the chin and you man up. I don’t want crying, I don’t want tears. You embarrassed yourselves and now you’ve got to stand up and be men.”

Kelston’s principal is standing up for his pupils. He says one of them was hit earlier in the game, and he has heard reports of racial taunts from Grammar Old Boys, who had been drinking before the match.

Grammar says they want justice for their players.

“Several of them are sporting some black eyes and some stitches as a result of punches that were thrown by not only Kelston players, but Kelston spectators,” says Mr Hansen.

“So I’m having to deal with some pretty angry and frustrated parents.”

The Auckland Rugby Union says it is deeply concerned, and has launched an inquiry.

“It’s a blight on the game,” says Andy Dalton of the Auckland Rugby Union.

“There are two very good schools that are affected, and they will be equally appalled at the situation, so we are taking it very seriously indeed.”

Players from both teams will appear in front of the Auckland Judiciary early this week.

Any player found to be bringing the game into disrepute could be stood down, and at worst teams can be banned.

That possibility will be weighing heavily on the minds of the Grammar players, who are due to play in the final against Mt Albert Grammar next weekend.

3 News
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

21 Aug 2009 10:07a.m.

Kiwi_Iwi:p wrote:

People who play sport & spectators(spectator n. person who WATCHES a show, game, incident, etc. )get caught up in the buzz of it all on the field even on the sideline but the real measure is if a team has got enough self discipline to play in a sportmanship like manner before during & after the match! win ,draw or lose!

20 Aug 2009 08:54p.m.

fan wrote:

The latest news shows that the players who lost control of their behavior are having to take responsibility for their behavior. It would be great if the ref, the headmasters the coaches, the school images and the expected conduct of rugby could control individual behavior but as we see they don't. They set standards and this is how they enforce those standards and expected behavior. Good on them, our youth are having to learn the hard way, which is sometimes the best way to learn a lesson.

20 Aug 2009 08:31p.m.

Auckland Grammar All Day! wrote:

It doesnt matter about the ref. i dont think he was from grammar but theres not such thing as a neutral ref anymore. look at the super14!!
Grammars Players shouldnt have been suspended.
Kelstons players, the suspension is too long. its unfair on all the boys. the kelston ones who will miss all of next season. and the Grammar boys who miss the game that is every teams goal from day 1.

And to all you people who say grammaer started it. YOUR WRONG!!!

The grammar hooker wasnt punished at all. If he did start it, his punishment would of been severe.

GOOD LUCK AUCKLAND GRAMMAR!
DONT LET KELSTON AND THE AUCKLAND RUGBY UNION TRY STOP YOU FROM WINNING ANYMORE.

20 Aug 2009 02:09p.m.

soreLOSERS wrote:

HAAAAAAHAAAAAAAAAA !! GRAMMAR won !! haha

20 Aug 2009 02:34a.m.

Burts wrote:

Hold up! Hold up! "Eva Sax" do you mean the ref was an old Grammar boy? How rude! So Kelston had NO chance to begin with! Then what's the whole point of all this? You got AGS doing a "look at me I'm Sandra Dee" number(yeah turn it up AGS), then you got the ref with a bad hairdo doing a "you cant touch this" number(yeah blow my whistle ref), and then you got the tv3 doing the "Ooop there it is"(who cares about John Campbell, bring in Tevin Campbell or even Glen Campbell). All the while Kelston Boys had NO chance to begin with? This is just beyond crazy! Yall need to get a perrm!

To the "referee"... Up your jumper!
To "Basuso"... Are you serious? Mr Bean is better looking!
To "Auckland Grammar"... All the best for the finals!
To "Kelston Boys"... Be proud that you made it this far!

Signed... Waste.of.tyme.over&outy!

20 Aug 2009 12:07a.m.

christine wrote:

I think Auckland Grammar has to face up to this ugly brawl and start taking responsibility. Boys have to first and foremost be taught to be upright men and winning at any price is not that importnt. Auckland Grammar has changed in the last 10 years it once was a respactable school now it's driven by arrogance and racism, what a shame, face up and take the blame like men, grant hansen should resign.

19 Aug 2009 10:38p.m.

eva sax wrote:

yeah basuso's right
its hard to hear the whistle when your blowing it from the toilet lol..

Its shocking, how can an ex-ags boy ref his old school??
Ive been living in australia for over 12 years(was there for the game though) but i still support me beloved all blacks... im an ex-kelston student me nephews go to ags but im kelston all the way
come on aru what the hell are you guys smoking!!
Is this right????
Did the aru have any prior knowledge of this before they chose him to ref the game???? Can anyone answer these questions??
The aru made a good call by banning the players involved and not the team...
But made a 2007 french forward pass in choosing the ref..
I hope politics is'nt at play here..
Please John Campbell if your ever going to interview the aru on the topic at hand , this is the question to ask!!!!!
KELSTON LOST I KNOW ags were the better team on the day and all the best to them!!

signed....
kelstongate.. brother of wateragate... aka meaurmuli2nyte!!

19 Aug 2009 08:43p.m.

doug wrote:

its only a game

19 Aug 2009 05:51p.m.

fan wrote:

It is good that both schools are having to examine the violence that took place during the match. Rugby is our national game and has become a profession as well as a commodity meaning that players even at school level are role models and held accountable for their actions. Who is to blame is debatable but students at this level need to learn that if they are going to become professionals then discipline is essential. Discipline of the game and of ones own actions. The saddest thing in my opinion is the way in which the crowd added to the stress and set a really poor example for both teams.

19 Aug 2009 12:30p.m.

kurt wrote:

i do think that the brawl was uncalled for but putting that aside a game of rugby will always be a game of rugby and its better they learn the consequences now then to tarnish their carrer in the near future.
as for racial comments, well that shouldn't be an issue these days with the huge number of teams having a blend of ethnic backgrounds.
rugby is the most physical sport on earth,so things like these are bound to happen

there will always be one winner and one loser.

good game though...