• Full Story

Auckland University rejects calls to sack academic

Print

Mon, 05 Sep 2011 1:20p.m.

The Maori studies department head caused a stir on Sunday

The Maori studies department head caused a stir on Sunday

Auckland University is rejecting calls for it to sack academic Margaret Mutu over her call for "white" immigration to New Zealand to be limited.

The Maori studies department head caused a stir on Sunday when she called for a restriction on the number of white migrants from South Africa, England and the United States as they brought "an attitude of white supremacy" with them.

It led outspoken Ngapuhi elder David Rankin to call for Auckland Universityto sack her, but Auckland University vice-chancellor Professor Stuart McCutcheon says an academic's right to free speech is important.

"The vice-chancellor understands the concerns raised ... but believes very strongly in the right of academics to comment on issues in which they have expertise, even when those comments may be controversial," a statement from the university says.

Prof McCutcheon says the Education Act protects the right of academics to state controversial or unpopular opinions within the law.

"That is an important right in a free society," he said.

Prof Mutu was responding to a Labour Department report which says Maori are the most likely ethnic group to express anti-immigrant views.

Mr Rankin, who labelled Prof Mutu as a "champagne radical", says Auckland University is scared of her but they need to look at her position again.

"Margaret is an archetype bigot. She's constantly attacking white New Zealand," he told Newstalk ZB.

NZN

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

22 Sep 2011 12:42a.m.

Amazed wrote:

People right here in America are having a FIT about immigration (legal and illegal) and try to keep certain people out of the country and not just because of financial reasons; NOBODY wants to call that racism. The sad part is they're trying to hold on to a land that was never THEIRS to begin with! But we like to forget that little part of history don't we! The whites in America and Australia and Africa and South America (the entire world) have systematically gone into someone else's home, eaten their food, slept in the rightful owner's bed and stuck around for hundreds of years. Afterwards, they go to the rightful homeowner and say "We're sorry; let's be friends". If it were your home, how would you feel?! The arrogance. I guess poor, victimized "white New Zealand" is learning what it feels like to be attacked. The only people who are mad with the comment are the ones who know its true.

07 Sep 2011 05:29p.m.

Carlos wrote:

That means that they support maori racism.

06 Sep 2011 10:29p.m.

G wrote:

NZ citizenship is worthless, doesn't matter if you grew up here, if your parents or great-grandparents lived here and if you would only ever call NZ home. You will always get people like Margaret Mutu who say you don't belong, that you aren't a kiwi. Sack her, there's plenty of others who could take her place and who deserve her privileged position at the university!

06 Sep 2011 11:28a.m.

Steve wrote:

A Hone supporter?

06 Sep 2011 02:50a.m.

sad and disappointed wrote:

I agree with the right to free speech, but I would interested to know on what basis she feels that we immigrants bring an attitude as "white supremacy" with us. Her sentiments are at least deserving of either elaborating on, based on the facts, or failing that, some sort of reprimand for bringing the reputation of Auckland University into disrepute. Furthermore, Professor McCutcheon's response may have inadvertently created an impression that Auckland University condones her views, and surely Margaret Mutu would have been aware that her words would create controversy. It has certainly gone some of the way to confirming a feeling I had when I was a postgraduate student at Auckland; where as a white person, I was made to feel at times like an outsider. It saddens me hugely to be tarred with "the white supremacist brush", and it only confirms my feeling that I really was better off continuing my studies elsewhere in the world, and at a better ranked university for that matter.

05 Sep 2011 08:27p.m.

Craigil wrote:

Let me see, The Labour Dept says maoris are most racist (and you can ask any Asian visitor )... So Mutu does a wonderful service to demonstrate the reports conclusion.
Yep, some groups express the most base emotions without any impulse control or gratefulness . Thanks Margaret Muti.

05 Sep 2011 07:41p.m.

E. Knock wrote:

So if you say we dont need any (more) "Burgundy" people coming in , then Im a bad guy, but she says this and the HUMAN RIGHTS ACT isnt brought out for a conviction in COURT?
Affirmative Action Nation "Aotearoha" Sux!

05 Sep 2011 07:28p.m.

Wrong way up? wrote:

I'm English, educated at Nga Tapuwae College, Mangere. Perhaps it's more about where Maori "feel" they are in comparission.
I would prefer to see Maori as leaders of a smarter new world, than what Margaret Mutu's immigration plan would do to our country.

05 Sep 2011 06:20p.m.

kelvyn wrote:

We can do without racist comments from this poisonous little person. She certainly should not be allowed to spread her toxic and racist views within the University.

05 Sep 2011 03:50p.m.

John wrote:

She is a sad lady with a big chip on her shoulder.