Australia must lift ban on NZ apples - WTO

Print

Tue, 30 Nov 2010 6:34p.m.

Australia banned New Zealand apples in 1921

Australia banned New Zealand apples in 1921

By Political Editor Duncan Garner

New Zealand has finally won its battle to export Kiwi apples to Australia, after a 90-year fight.

Prime Minister John Key says Australia must immediately drop its ban and let our apples in.

But growers remain concerned Australia will play games and make it tricky.

The World Trade referee, the WTO, has ruled Australia’s ban on New Zealand apples is unscientific and breaks the rules.

“The last season has been disastrous. The opportunity to go into another market is welcome and it is so close,” says Nelson apple grower Richard Easton.

“I do believe Aussies will be chomping their way through New Zealand apples before long,” Mr Key said.

Australia banned New Zealand apples in 1921, believing them to carry the pest Fibrelight.

New Zealand argued that was rubbish and the WTO ruled in favour in August.

Australia appealed and a 148-page ruling confirms New Zealand apples won.

The Australian government says it accepts the decision, but wants now to look at what risks importing our apples might pose.

“I’m sure the Aussies will word a protocol that does make it difficult,” Mr Easton said.

As Trade Minister Phil Goff pushed the WTO action, he says the Australians now have no option.

“There’s a risk they could hold this up still further,” he said.

“[But] the decision has been made. They just need to get on and implement it.”

It will take a year before New Zealand apples will be exported – which should be worth at least $30 million to Kiwi growers.

Mr Key says he expects in the spirit of the ANZAC relationship, Australia won’t play any more games and will let our apples in.

He says, if he detects any problems, he will raise it with Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard when she visits New Zealand in February.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

23 Jun 2011 08:24p.m.

Alyn Roule wrote:

The question remains, will the WTO guarrantee the Australian Gov, Growers and citizens the fireblight is NOT in ANY apple to come from NZ to OZ at ANY Time. ???
PLUS -- Has fireblight now started to destroy NZ pears ???

05 Dec 2010 08:58a.m.

Tim wrote:

The Aussies will find another excuse so I wouldn't hold my breath. It is well known that the risk of fireblight being imported on apples was nonexistant, nevermind that fireblight is already present in Australia anyway.

01 Dec 2010 11:07a.m.

Sallina wrote:

I generally buy fruit and veges that are grown in Australia because I trust and support our farmers. However, I have had the fortune of eating Kiwi Apples when I was in Auckland for a month and I LOVE EM!! Better than our apples (just quietly). Most of our apples taste like they've been stored away for a year before hitting the shelves. I will continue to support Aussie farmers but cant wait for Kiwi apples to be available here. I for one will be buying!