• Full Story

Australia suspends live cattle trade to Indonesia

Print

Wed, 08 Jun 2011 1:05p.m.

Live Australian cattle account for up to 40 percent of Indonesia's beef consumption (Reuters)

Live Australian cattle account for up to 40 percent of Indonesia's beef consumption (Reuters)

Australia has suspended its AUS$330 million a year live cattle trade with Indonesia after gruesome televised images exposed slaughterhouse practices there.

The ban will last until proper treatment of the animals has been assured, said Agriculture Minister Joe Ludwig, who signed the trade ban on Wednesday. The government had temporarily suspended exports to 11 slaughterhouses after the footage aired nationally last week.

"I want to work with both the industry and the Indonesian government through my department to ensure that we can do this as quickly as possible," he told Australian Broadcasting Corp. radio. "The suspension is there for up to six months to allow time for this to occur".

Cattle sales agent Tim McHugh said the suspension would have a huge economic impact on cattle ranches across northern Australia, where there are no export meat slaughterhouses.

"This is criminal to think that people can manipulate markets the way they have using emotive issues," McHugh told Australian Broadcasting Corp. radio Wednesday.

"The reality is that it shouldn't be our responsibility with regard to foreign countries buying our product and what they do with it once it's in their hands," he added.

ABC television on May 30 broadcast footage from Indonesian slaughterhouses that showed steers being whipped and taking minutes to die after their throats were slit repeatedly. Australian slaughterhouses stun the animals first.

The government responded the following day by halting trade with slaughterhouses that featured in the documentary, as Foreign Minister Kevin Rudd assured colleagues that trade suspensions with individual slaughterhouses would not harm Australia's "strong and robust relationship" with Indonesia.

Live Australian cattle account for up to 40 percent of Indonesia's beef consumption, while Indonesia buys 60 percent of Australia's live cattle exports.

About 770 slaughterhouses operate in Indonesia and only five use the stun-gun method, according to Lyn White, campaign director of the animal welfare group Animals Australia, which filmed the footage.

Indonesia's methods of slaughtering animals are based on Islamic teachings, For Riwantoro, a senior official at Indonesia's Ministry of Agriculture, told The Associated Press last week.

"We have to protect consumers by ensuring they consume not only healthy and clean meat, but most important, it must be halal," Riwantoro said.

He said without Australian cattle, Indonesia would rely more on local cattle or would look for imports from other countries.

Prime Minster Julia Gillard was quoted in The Sydney Morning Herald saying Australia would work with Indonesians and the cattle industry to bring about changes in the slaughterhouses.

Key lawmakers and Animals Australia and the Australian Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, better known as the RSPCA, had sought the ban on cruelty grounds. The animal welfare groups cooperated with Australian Broadcasting Corp. to produce the television footage aired nationally.

AP

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

09 Jun 2011 03:35p.m.

Ruth wrote:

A wise man said "The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated."(Ghandi). Shame shame Hugh ... your comments show what kind of man you really are. Fortunately, not all Australians are like you!

09 Jun 2011 03:56a.m.

Barbara wrote:

Yeah Hugh how dare we allow stuff like decency and humane treatment of animals to stand in the way of a good bit of animal torture and a big fat pay packet! You represent every thing that is bad about this filthy industry! How do you sleep at night knowing what you do for a living! Oh that's right people only have trouble sleeping when they have a conscience so I suppose you sleep soundly!

09 Jun 2011 12:52a.m.

Anne Stevens wrote:

We are right behind you Animals Australia
I have been trying to send my written thoughts to the farming organisations, pastoral companies, live animal export companies and guess what? They all have their email addresses blocked. Now that couldn't be because of bad comments and home truths flooding in could it?? Learn from this you greedy bastards and don't ever again be a part of what has been a huge cover-up for decades - abhorrent sadistic cruelty to innocent animals. No mercy for you!!

09 Jun 2011 12:30a.m.

Gav wrote:

As a son of a farmer I can tell you him, and not me would ever wash our hands of our cattle. I mean you raise them and yeah you sell them for slaughter but they are your bread and butter, we wouldnt palm them off to slaughter and say, well too bad, not our problem if someone wants to kick them about. Its just about doing the right thing, you have to have pride in what you do and do it all right. I would be more than angry if my export manager was selling our stock knowing about the conditions in the abattoirs, and from what I can read, they bloody well knew about it all. Pretty damn bad. Really it was a matter of time before something cracked. Shame for the farmers who are working hard and trying to do the right thing by their families.

09 Jun 2011 12:29a.m.

Suzanne wrote:

The real criminals are the Australian government, exporters and the farmers who feed their greed. If New Zealand were to send live cattle to Indonesia they would be as culpable as the Australians. Pastoralists and exporters have grown fat and greedy on the back of the immeasurable suffering of Australian animals ruthlessly and callously shipped to savages who torture them to death. The 'livestock industry' will suffer for this as the Australian community treats t with all the contempt it deserves.

08 Jun 2011 11:58p.m.

Carol wrote:

The comments by Cattle sales agent Tim McHugh demonstrates exactly why we cannot trust the livestock industry. It is clear that McHugh is driven by the dollar and fails to comprehend the most basic of rules: responsibility, compassion, respect, and decency because otherwise why would he make such offensive and stupid narrowminded statements. Thank goodness he isnt part of my family. Further, Australia claims that by being in Indonesia they lift the standards. Well if what we saw on 4 Corners is anything to go by, the standards must have been simply unbelievable. The premise upon which McHugh makes his grandstand is I might add emotive, but purports that Australias presence isnt really to lift stds but to make money..because it isnt up to another country to tell the buyer how to treat the animals they have bought. Looks like he may have a point. Australia did nothing to lift standards- they knew about the cruelty in 2000, shoved in some boxes which exacerates the suffering and turned away. And now we see Indonesia trying to blackmail AU saying they will souce cattle from NZ. Makes me think AU have been squirming all the way to the bank. Theyknew what was happening and took little to no action because they didnt want to upset Indonesia. Too bloody bad. Australia is might upset and the greedy exporters and pastorilists will now pay thei price for their lack of decency, their greed, their selfishness and bastardry.