3News » Home
Full Story

Bethune needs report for his defence - Greens

2 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Pete Bethune

Pete Bethune

Tue, 11 May 2010 5:59a.m.

New Zealander Peter Bethune needs Maritime NZ's report on the collision between his anti-whaling vessel and a Japanese security ship to defend himself in the trial he is facing, the Green Party says.

The Greens are urging the Government to quickly obtain information from Japanese authorities so Maritime NZ can complete its inquiry into the January 6 collision between Mr Bethune's Ady Gil and the Shonan Maru 2 while the Ady Gil was harassing the Japanese whaling fleet in the Southern Ocean.

Prime Minister John Key said yesterday the information was slow in coming and it would be unacceptable for Japan to withhold it.

He said Foreign Minister Murray McCully was working with his Japanese counterpart and would meet Japan's ambassador later this week to try to obtain the information Maritime NZ needs.

The Ady Gil sank after being sliced in two when it collided with the Shonan Maru 2. Both sides have blamed the other for the collision.

In February Mr Bethune, 42, boarded the Shonan Maru 2, hoping to make a citizen's arrest of its captain for allegedly ramming and sinking his ship.

He was arrested when the ship docked in Japan and is now in custody pending a trial on charges of trespass, causing injury, vandalism, carrying a knife and obstructing commercial activities.

The Green Party's oceans spokesman, MP Gareth Hughes, said last night Japan was refusing to co-operate and either had something to hide or was making a deliberate attempt to thwart the course of justice for a New Zealand citizen.

"Pete needs the results of the Maritime NZ investigation for defence in his trial but it seems thus far he has been all but abandoned by the Government," Mr Hughes said.

"If the Government allows the Japanese government to deliberately suppress information that could have a massive bearing on Peter Bethune's trial. It is contributing to a travesty of justice that could see a New Zealand citizen jailed for up to 15 years."

Mr Key said the Government was trying to give Maritime NZ the "greatest ability possible" to understand what took place in the Southern Ocean, and to apportion responsibility for it.

"We need that information, we are requesting it, and taking it up through the appropriate channels," he said.

An investigation by the Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA), released this week, failed to find which party was to blame after the Japanese government refused to co-operate and video footage proved inconclusive.

The report said the crews of both vessels had been warned about the dangers of collision before the whaling season began.

"AMSA also communicated its concerns, including concerns about the durability of the Ady Gil in the event of a collision, directly to the master and crew," the report said.

NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [2]

Samuel
10 Jun 2010 1:58p.m.

Erik, I basically agree with you. (Though the incidents were five weeks apart, not mere days)
It's shameful how little MP Hughes seems to understand the laws in play here. Mr Bethune had no right to board that vessel. There are several laws that prohibit those very actions, in fact. The fact that Hughes and some other lawmakers overlook, is that Bethune was returned to Australia aboard the Steve Irwin and he should have stayed there and gone through proper legal channels. Instead, Bethune had no faith in his government and returned to the SO to take matters into his own hands. Now that that action did not work out so well, he is willing to put his faith in a government investigation on his behalf. Sorry Pete. You have gone down a different path. Your crimes are a seperate issue from the collision investigation. Good luck at your sentencing.

Erik
16 May 2010 9:00a.m.

One might wonder just HOW an incident that took place several days PRIOR to bethunes actions that got him arrested would have ANY bearing on his defense. 1. Bethune boarded a foreign vessel : tresspass 2. Bethune damaged property in his tresspass : damaged netting.. 3. Bethune possessed an illegal weapon under Japanese law : his knife, hidden in his boot. 4. Bethune directed and participated in assaulting others with chemicals that are poisonous, causing injury to some. : Video exists from BOTH showing bethune doing these actions nothing in there about ramming... any legal actions concerning that would have to come from the NZ govt as they were the flag nation. If that comes about, NZ will act with the evidence they have, so far, the AMSA says they cannot pin the blame. My opinion is the MNZ will come to the same conclusion. watson has already stated his has no faith in the legal process, this is the standard rhetoric from those that just cannot believe they are in the wrong. Both Aus and NZ have a great deal of explaining to do, now that this is coming to the courts. How they provided support, haven and moorage to these imbeciles acting contray to all maritime safety laws. Even yet, hughes, brown,and the rest of the green idiots are still calling out for nothing less than war. Be careful what you wish for... you may get it yet.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio