Both sides of Hobbit debate hit the streets

Print

Wed, 20 Oct 2010 10:39p.m.

Sir Richard Taylor with other protesters

Sir Richard Taylor with other protesters

By Liz Puranam and 3news.co.nz staff / NZPA

There has been fury and frustration on the streets of Wellington tonight.

Head of Weta Workshop, Sir Richard Taylor, says the future of the Hobbit films - and the $700 million that comes with them - are in peril because of the "actions of a very limited few".

He is referring to the New Zealand Actors Equity union, who are calling for a boycott of the films as they hold out for better conditions and a collective agreement.

The workers say the standoff between the unions and The Hobbit director Sir Peter Jackson is going to cost them their jobs and their livelihoods.

3 News has spoken to technicians working on The Hobbit who said that New Zealand is on the verge of losing the opportunity to film the movis in New Zealand. These sources, who wish to remain anonymous, say that the Australian union MEAA - the Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance - have made a well-governed situation unreasonable and unworkable for investors.

Workers on Wellington streets chanted 'Keep the Hobbit!', desperate to keep film's production in New Zealand. But is it too late?

And if the production of the movie has been moved offshore, who is to blame?

"It will be because Warner Bros have decided they can make more money elsewhere," says Council of Trade Unions president Helen Kelly.

"That's bullshit. Bullshit!"

The CTU, along with Actors Equity, have maintained they're unhappy with the working conditions for actors and the contracts on offer.

But some actors say they're with Sir Peter, and resent an Australian union - headed by a man called Simon Whipp - speaking for them.

"Peter didn't ask for help from Australia when he came to make films in New Zealand," says Jed Brophy. "We make great films in New Zealand with New Zealanders, so why should we get unions over there to tell us what our working conditions should be?"

Fifteen hundred workers, including directors, technicians and crew who also support Sir Peter, met at his Miramar Studios at 5pm for an emergency meeting this evening.

By 7pm, they were storming the Actors Equity meeting in the city.
"Stop the insanity that we're experiencing at the moment in New Zealand," says Weta's Sir Richard Taylor.

"I have no idea whether we can stop [the film going overseas], but we would feel very poor about ourselves if we didn't make an effort."

The two Hobbit films, a prequel to the Lord of the Rings trilogy, are expected to cost about $US500 million (NZ$669m) to make, the most expensive ever, and will be filmed in 3-D.

Workers on the film say they have everything to lose. They've driven the actors out of the Actors Equity meeting.

Sir Richard said that when the actors cancelled the meeting the technicians instead chose to march through the streets of Wellington, ending up at the cenotaph near Parliament.

"Everyone gathered felt that they had done their part in assuring the New Zealand film industry that they care passionately about seeing the Hobbit made in New Zealand and that the industry as a whole should be left as it is for the successful and ongoing future of film making in New Zealand.

"We have had a pledge from the Government that they are focused on helping us," says Sir Richard.

"They do understand our concerns and they are going to do all they can to assist us in stopping the madness that has proceeded over the last few weeks."

3 News / NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

26 Oct 2010 07:24p.m.

bryan wrote:

So the government and tourism industry have joined forces to make actors accept whatever inferior offer is made in case they miss the oppportunity of making vast money at their expense

24 Oct 2010 02:31p.m.

molly wrote:

Zena (Lucy Lawless) and Paikea (Whale Rider Castle-Hughes) were by your side with anything to do with the Enviroment....but as soon as it's something that affects their livelihood, their silence is deafening...they know you don't bite the hand that feeds you..didn't they tell you that Robyn, Jennifer!!! Helen where were the Unions during LOTR's?, as soon as itbecame successful, you could smell money and you want your share....and eveyone else that's anti...it's WARNERS money, no-one tells you how to spend yours, why do you feel you can tell them how to spendtheirs? bludgers, the lot of you, you want something off someone else, for nothing....and you Union lot call that scabbing.

23 Oct 2010 06:36p.m.

Andrew wrote:

Sounds like Helen Kelly's got a bit of a "tall poppy" attitude towards Jackson and Warner Bros. Jackson's a creative artist and a businessman and Warners are a company. Businesses need to make money in order to sustain what they do. It's not like something like that is news. That's just how it is when you're in business. Kelly's union members need to make money to sustain their lifestyle just as much as the next person whatever their job is. The big picture is that there's a big film studio willing to spend big bucks to have The Hobbit made here in NZ and now that Jackson's proven himself in spades as a top filmmaker, they trust that he's gonna do an amazing job and with that goes the positive ripple effect to NZ as a whole. Warners were going to give NZ actors a share of the profits before the boycott happened and now they've probably messed that one up cos I think the profits would've been quite substantial but on it goes. Go Peter!!!

23 Oct 2010 03:03p.m.

Andrew wrote:

Helen Kelly's statement about Peter Jackson wanting to take the film offshore because of making bigger money is bullsh**! There's more Kiwi pride in him than her. Watching him on Campbell Live, he was clearly distressed at the possibility of the film being taken overseas. He's set up his movie business here in NZ, he's helped create countless jobs for people, and he's inspired younger kiwi filmmakers to achieve their dreams. He's paid his dues and if he's making a bit of money off it, good on him. He didn't get his money winning Lotto. He worked hard for it and anyone who works hard for it deserves everything good they get. According to those in the know, Jackson's workers are treated very well personally and professionally. I hope things get resolved soon to a good outcome and I know there's a multitude of arguments over this issue but just let Jackson and his crew get on with making the damn film. Go Peter!

22 Oct 2010 10:03p.m.

David Gillies wrote:

Given that 99.9995% of the world's population are not shrieking Kiwi poofters, and we'll all get to see the movie anyway, this is no big deal. But when did you get so silly, New Zealanders? Running up the beach at ANZAC cove under shellfire is one thing, but losing the thick end of a billion bucks because you're too chuckle-headed to yield an inch? That's just silly. Buh-bye.

22 Oct 2010 11:14a.m.

Justin wrote:

Gee, actor's screwing over the techies so that they can pull in three times the amount that everyone else makes, instead of merely double? Who would have thought it.

22 Oct 2010 04:33a.m.

Ertdfg wrote:

What, like they can go elsewhere. Name one other place in the world with outdoor grass, hills, and people who are less obnoxious than union management... ... Oh wait, I forgot about Anywhere else. Yep, time to move the movie filming Anywhere else. Good work union; jobs are for people who don't have union representatives to drive the work away I guess. How much do you have to pay to avoid being in a union?

22 Oct 2010 04:26a.m.

RuthenianCowboy wrote:

"It will be because Warner Bros have decided they can make more money elsewhere."

That's called CAPITALISM, you petulant marxist.

22 Oct 2010 03:30a.m.

vaughan wrote:

If your dumb enough to say that you may as well leave too.

22 Oct 2010 03:17a.m.

EvilCapitalist wrote:

Unions are pure evil that exist not for the workers they claim to represent but only their leaders wealth and power. Unions are a cancer that are destroying the world and should be eradicated wherever they exist. They had their usefulness once, but that was way far back in the last century. "Look for the Union label", then buy something else or take your business elsewhere.