3News » Home
Full Story

Brash's cannabis move surprises opponents

36 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Don Brash

Don Brash

video
UPDATED: 8:25AM
Published: Mon, 26 Sep 2011 7:23a.m.

Prime Minister John Key has rejected ACT leader Don Brash's suggestion that marijuana should be decriminalised.

Dr Brash said in a weekend speech the drug was relatively harmless and prohibition was ineffective and expensive.

But Mr Key, whose government runs strong anti-drugs policies, said that wasn't what the public wanted.

"Ask parents if they want their children smoking a joint before going to school," he said on TV One.

"There's no place for drugs in our society. We've got to stand up and say we don't want drugs."

ACT has also strongly opposed drugs in the past and Dr Brash's comment surprised other parties.

He said he was expressing a personal opinion, but it has been taken as an indication ACT could change its policy after the election.

Some have accused ACT of pushing the self-destruct button with the call, however. In addition to Dr Brash's new views, second-in-command John Boscawen is quitting politics.

The Green Party says Dr Brash is making a brave move by supporting the decriminalisation of cannabis.

Greens co-leader Metiria Turei says it shouldn't come as a shock.

"I think people are surprised they're turning it into their dominant election campaign," says Ms Turei, "but that's their decision to do that. The Greens have been consistent on this issue for many years now, because we believe… it's a health issue."

But United Future Leader Peter Dunne, who has admitted smoking cannabis as a student, says the ACT party has finally lost the plot.

"It's just desperation, which has got no sense of coherence to it," says Mr Dunne.

"Policies on the one hand that let you take the law of justice into your own hands, on the other, drugs for all, then your deputy walks away.

"I don't see any consistency in that."

Labour has also attacked Dr Brash's reasoning for shifting his views.

"This is a sort of bizarre statement from Dr Brash, based on some strange notion that he appears to be the only one on the planet who believes that smoking marijuana has no effect on anybody," says Clayton Cosgrove.

"Good god, look at our young people, and look at the mental health issues we have in our prisons."

Political commentator Bryce Edwards told RadioLIVE this morning the party's alienating its support base and appears to be in trouble.

"For the last 15 years, ACT have increasingly gone after the officially conservative voters," says Mr Edwards. "This might actually be quite a problem for the typical ACT voter, and especially in Epsom."

All five of ACT's sitting MPs are bowing out of politics at this year's election.

3 News / RadioLIVE / NZN

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [36]

Brent
03 Oct 2011 8:55p.m.

I know mr brush your comment was just about scoring a few points if it was true you would have my vote but we all know it was a load of crap so you and you idiot mate john banks will just have to score a few more votes of some other idiots that my beleave the that crap its just like old times the lies keep on cumming from you john banks your self and the act party just in case you didn`t under stand no mr brush you didn`t get my vote

Berlin
29 Sep 2011 12:33p.m.

Even though our gangs are very very tame compared to London gangs you just wait another 20 years under the current prohibition. We will see more deaths from disease and violence all in the name of demand. In East London the blacks shoot each other up with mac 10 and tec 9s. Trust me as I lived in a sink estate in Lower Clapton where every death, which was on a daily basis was over drugs. Yes do not get kids into drugs but please educate them. Consenting adults will always use cannabis and no police or government will ever stop that. Brash speaks sense and anyone on this thread saying otherwise lacks a brain. Many prominent figures in politics, health and law and order have called for change. In NZ where a large chunk of the population is spoon-fed lies from the one NZ news paper and three channels that we have. anyone would think we are living in a dictatorship. They said cannabis would make you sleep with a negro and when that did not work they told us that we would grow tits. Now they say it makes you crazy and get into heroin and hard drugs, hahahaha all of this has been debunked by science, yes science. 100 million down the drain every year whilst the ganja plant thrives on. No wonder the Swiss, Dutch and Spanich are more sophisticated than us. NZ is a land of holden driving, wife beating, beer drinking bogans. Wake up sheep, Mr Key is nobody on a world scale. Fight the power and legalise the herb. Most NZders want DRUG LAW REFORM.

nick a
27 Sep 2011 12:59p.m.

Hahahaha so funny....they are using the same lines people used to try and keep the proabition of alcohol" Ask parents if they want their children drinking whiskey before going to school" Cosgrove proves just how small the little bubble he lives in with his "he appears to be the only one on the planet who believes that smoking marijuana has no effect on anybody," comment. @chris you say "..talk about how these people in power try to talk to us as if we are fools, eh??...take a look at merv and ian there are plenty out there.

chris
27 Sep 2011 12:28a.m.

Cameron, please let's not put weed in the same category as other harmful drugs. Remember that cigarettes and alcohol are also drugs, just legal , thats all. And both are far more dangerous to people and society than weed. Yes, scientifically proven so. How can anybody argue against such facts???--

Cameron
26 Sep 2011 10:07p.m.

Nobody in politics wants to look like they're soft on drugs. Hence Key's reaction. But the reality is that if you want to buy some weed, it's not hard to get. So prohibition laws are clearly ineffective. It would be much more effective to regulate it, like alcohol or tobacco. Kids aren't going to smoke pot any more than they would smoke cigarettes and pot is a lot less likely to cause a life-long addiction than tobacco.

chris
26 Sep 2011 9:03p.m.

Hello, i live in the UK, and i can say that jon key talks nonsense and lies. Cannabis has been found to be less harmful to society and people than alcohol and cigarrettes. He likes to say that "drugs have no place in our society, but alcohol and cigarettes ARE drugs"..talk about how these people in power try to talk to us as if we are fools, eh?? ...If Cannabis woukld be legalised, you'd police it like alcohol and cigarettes-so kids would not be sold it, and therefore would not use it like they don't drink alcohol, before going to school. What a pathetic way of trying to make us fearful of innocent old cannabis, eh?? Prisons being full of people with mental problems..??--of course!!----wouldn't you go mad if you were stuck in a dull enclosed space with other nutters??? ---These politicians are the biggest liars about. They deserve to be locked up. It's them and their policies that are the root of this drugs problem, and it's ruining the lives of people who want to relax and explore their own consciousness in their free time after helping society by doing their weeks work. It's not fair play, not at all!! -Cannabis should never have been banned,. It's an outrageous thing to make plants illegal...talk about fearmongering.

Patrick
26 Sep 2011 8:38p.m.

Good for you Brash, everyone is not seeing the big picture, whats funding the gangs in our country? and not only in our but in the world? it's Drugs! weather it's marijuana or harder drugs. Decriminalize it and stop putting money into gangsters pockets.

Merv
26 Sep 2011 4:00p.m.

Not surprising, coming from someone who's admitted to smoking the odd joint or two.

ian
26 Sep 2011 2:43p.m.

Ever heard the squeel of a stuck pig, -- listen to ACT, from now on, as it dies!

Jason
26 Sep 2011 2:40p.m.

About time as well, why do people have the misconception that people who smoke weed are the dregs of society,
I`m 40 never been out of work, my house is mine, and my family are great, I am also T-total
The devestation Alcohol causes, Family abuse, road accidents, our police abused every weekend, the list could go on and on and yet its still legal and for sale on every street corner. unbelievable
WAKE UP KEY you hypocrite, look at the tax your loosing, and the tinney houses are booming again now kronic is banned

Wake up key

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio