Bridge swing death: McWhannell gets community service

Print

Thu, 29 Jul 2010 10:49a.m.

Catherine Petersfell about 20 metres on to rocks below the Ballance Bridge

Catherine Petersfell about 20 metres on to rocks below the Ballance Bridge

By James Murray

Alastair McWhannell, the man convicted of manslaughter after Catherine Peters died using his bridge swing, has been sentenced to 400 hours of community service.

He has also been ordered to pay $10,000 to Ms Peters' family for emotional damage.

McWhannell was found guilty of manslaughter at Palmerston North High Court in June after it was ruled that the rope attached to Ms Peters' was not secured to the bridge and was too long.

At the time the crown alleged that McWhannell was distracted by a woman, who he had met on the internet, that was supposed to do the jump after Ms Peters.

Catherine Peters, an 18-year-old first-year veterinary student, plunged about 20 metres on to rocks below the Ballance Bridge, near Woodville, while on a university trip being run by Crag Adventures on March 7.

McWhannell, 47, remained expressionless throughout the sentencing, and did not make eye contact with Ms Peters' family as they read victim impact statements to the court.

Ms Peters' father, Bosco Peters, said his daughter's death was like "having a wing ripped off a plane while we were flying".

"Sometimes it feels totally unreal, other times it feels like the only reality...Catherine's death is my own personal trial."

He said he lived with the nightmare that her death was preventable, but that the family had never been given any acknowledgement of fault.

Ms Peters' mother, Helen Peters, spoke through tears as she told the court that she treasured every moment with her daughter.

"There should have been so many more moments," she said looking directly at McWhannell.

"There is no way to share the loneliness in my heart without her."

Mrs Peters said it was unbearable that her daughter's death should have arisen from "such gross negligence" when they were such a safe family.

She said McWhannell’s failure to offer any apology and failure to show any early admission of guilt showed he had no true remorse.

Her brother Jonathan said his sister would have lived to 100.

"She should have been able to live but she was thrown off a bridge by Alastair McWhannell."

3 News/NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

29 Oct 2011 08:06p.m.

jake mcleay wrote:

as someone who sets up bridgeswings for a weekend hobbie i know all too well that retaining full concentration while setting up and going through safety checks before each jump is key. every time i let a mate jump it nearly does my head in. im trained and know my gear well but things do go wrong, especially once one is used to the setup and checks, one can become overconfident and overlook things especially if distracted while going through checks. i really feel for both the Peters family and Alastair McWhannell. iv done the ballance bridge a few times and it is a harsh reminder that safety is paramount.

30 Jul 2010 09:01p.m.

Jasmine wrote:

Shame on all of you - he is a man too, he has to live with this for the rest of his life! Thats a life sentence in itself! How can you all put him down like that - did you all complain that no one person was convicted or sent to prison over the rafting accident through the sir ed trust??

We all hope Catherine is in peace now and her family can move on obviously she will never be forgotten.

29 Jul 2010 02:06p.m.

Philip wrote:

I feel so sick! I completely agree KP! Where is the justice for murder.....negligence is still murder in this case! The entire justice system in NZ needs revision....it's unfathomable that he is getting away with this! Shame on him for not apologizing and the judge for the soft sentencing!!! I'm sincerely sorry for the family of Catherine Peters....may she rest in peace!

29 Jul 2010 01:25p.m.

KP wrote:

Negligence resulting in death vs. community service - not exactly an eye for an eye is it? Where is the justice in that.

29 Jul 2010 01:06p.m.

Helen1 wrote:

God rest her soul so young and so tragic. Now they will all pay for her tragic absense while the ferryman collects. Go on towards the living- people- and bless you all.