3News » Home
Full Story

Cubicle farming opposed by PM and Fonterra

7 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
The Prime Minister and Fonterra both come out against the move this morning

The Prime Minister and Fonterra both come out against the move this morning

video
Tue, 08 Dec 2009 12:48p.m.

By Brook Sabin

Opposition is mounting against corporate dairy companies who plan to house nearly 20,000 cows under cover in the Mackenzie Country.

The Prime Minister and Fonterra have this morning both come out against the move.

But Abe Deworde, the operator of a similar farm in Invercargill, is defending the system.

He says he has been housing 500 cattle in the cubicle stables for four seasons, and has seen great improvements.

“It has increased our production, our production per hectare and efficiency, because we can milk these cows longer per year,” he says.

Consent applications have been lodged for farms similar to Mr Deworde’s, but on a much bigger scale.

The three applications are for nearly 18,000 cows, which would be housed in cubicle stables 24 hours per day, for eight months of the year.

The plan has brought top level concern, with John Key disapproving of the proposal.

“I think the image implications for New Zealand are not good,” he says.

This morning Fonterra, who collects nearly 70 million litres of milk per day from farms, also come out in opposition.

Tim Deane, milk supply manager for Fonterra, says the plans for the Mackenzie Basin could undermine its international reputation for free range farming.

“It's perception more than anything else, the type of intensive fed-lot stall-based farming that's being proposed doesn't sit well with the perception of New Zealand’s pasture-based farming system,” he says.

Mr Key says while he is concerned, he is “limited” in what he can do stop the plans.

The Minister of Agriculture, David Carter, wasn't available for comment this morning, but a spokesman said the Minister does have reservations and has requested more information from MAF.

3 News
 

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [7]

RMareshallUK
16 Dec 2009 3:24a.m.

Come on New Zealand, don't be seduced by the bland assurances of factory farmers. To deprive ruminant animals of the sun, and rain and GRASS for two thirds of the year simply goes against nature. How on earth can an individual cow's welare be adequately assessed and implemented in such a morass of animals? This is the measure by which all livestock farming practices should be judged.

Add to this the amount of methane and slurry produced, plus the tourist image of your lovely country, and the answer is no, no, no.

RMareshallUK
16 Dec 2009 3:23a.m.

Come on New Zealand, don't be seduced by the bland assurances of factory farmers. To deprive ruminant animals of the sun, and rain and GRASS for two thirds of the year simply goes against nature. How on earth can an individual cow's welare be adequately assessed and implemented in such a morass of animals? This is the measure by which all livestock farming practices should be judged.

Add to this the amount of methane and slurry produced, plus the tourist image of your lovely country, and the answer is no, no, no.

Rebecca
11 Dec 2009 11:28a.m.

All this comes down to is greed! Shame on you human race, like it couldn't get any worse for animals!

Bea Elliott
08 Dec 2009 7:22p.m.

In a short time we will cover the earth with manure lagoons, factory farms and slaughterhouses. Please world... choose sense! Choose compassion - Go Vegan!

label it
08 Dec 2009 6:50p.m.

Well I hope they start labelling which products come from factory farms or I'll just have to cut out all beef and dairy.

Noel
08 Dec 2009 6:49p.m.

I agree with Katrina. If NZ has an image for free range farming, why hasn't that practice extended to pigs and hens? Surely that would enhance our image further. Quality is more important than quantity as the wine industry has proven in the export sector. I hope by law, cubicle farming will have to be labelled on the packaging so the consumer can leave it on the shelves.

katrina
08 Dec 2009 4:26p.m.

I thought we were trying to get away from this type of practice with the hens and pigs. Maybe we should lock up the farmers in a pen and see how they like it. The cows are producing more milk cos they can not move and therefore not burning up the calories

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio