Calls for Voltaren ban following stroke study

Print

Tue, 14 Sep 2010 6:05p.m.

The Ministry of Health says the study simply confirms what is already know about these medicines

The Ministry of Health says the study simply confirms what is already know about these medicines

By Alistair Wilkinson

A New Zealand expert on brain injuries is calling for medications like Voltaren to be banned following a study which shows they significantly increase the chances of suffering a stroke.

Professor Valery Feigin also wants pills like Nurofen made prescription only.

But the Ministry of Health says the study simply confirms what is already know about these medicines.

When Simon welsh was 15 years old he was prescribed Voltaren to ease the pain from shin splints.

“It was almost immediate relief from pain that wouldn't go away,” he says.

But according to a Danish study, the two-week course could have had long term effects.

The study, published in the Journal of the American Heart Association, found that people prescribed a high dosage – 150 milligrams – of anti-inflammatory medication like Voltaren that contain diclofenac were 86 percent more at risk.

That is of particular concern for people with a high risk of stroke.

“This study would suggest you discontinue and go on something that doesn't have this risk profile,” says Mr Feigin.

It's not just diclofenac – the same study found that taking ibuprofen, commonly sold here as Nurofen, at a dosage of more than 1200 milligrams, was linked to a 30 percent increased risk.

“Do you need to be on it? Is there a good alternative? Yes, the study shows there are good alternatives,” Mr Feigin.

Professor Valery Feigin is an expert on strokes, and he thinks it's time to ban medications like Voltaren.

“For the drug like diclofenac I would think this study is the last nail in the coffin for that medication,” he says. “I would seriously not recommend that medication to anybody.”

But the Ministry of Health says:

“The results of this latest study confirm what is already known about these medicines. As with all pain-killers, Medsafe advises using the lowest effective dose for the shortest time possible."

It recommends anyone with concerns should discuss them with their doctor.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

15 Sep 2010 06:49p.m.

Michael Cahill wrote:

Wasnt this comment a contradiction of the news report of tonight where it was implied that those drugs based around naproxen were the drug of concern and not Diclofenac which was suggested as the ddrug of concern during the news broadcast last night (Tuesday).
I could be wrong but!~!!!!

15 Sep 2010 11:20a.m.

Sue Howes wrote:

This report has really scared me , as I have been on 150mg of Voltaren for 17 years now for my arthritis, I have had the occasional break but not for long , I am visiting my Dr to see what I can do now, but is it to late for me

15 Sep 2010 09:53a.m.

Blair McLachlan wrote:

What a terrible peice of reporting. The dose rate you quoted seems enormous - your report soesn't say what period that would be taken over. It also fails to say what the period of risk is following use - whether that is during use, for a period after, or for life. A percentage of increased risk is quoted without ANY information about when one is at risk, for how long... basically so vague as to be scaremongering. Sensationalist junk.