3News » Home
Full Story

Catholic church reacts to controversial billboard

3 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
The billboard has been erected outside St Matthew in the City in central Auckland

The billboard has been erected outside St Matthew in the City in central Auckland

video
Thu, 17 Dec 2009 12:45p.m.

By Brook Sabin

The Catholic Church and family groups are outraged by a billboard, which was put up this morning by a church in central Auckland.

St Matthew in the City has been known for its controversial campaigns, but some say this year’s sexual theme has gone too far.

The story goes that about 2000 years ago in Bethlehem, the Virgin Mary had just given birth to Jesus. But just whether God’s sperm was actually involved has been widely debated.

Present day in central Auckland, a billboard playing on that has just been put up, the implication of which needs to explanation.

“That’s just playing on those who think about God as being a. male, and b. impregnating Mary in a very literal kind of way,” says Archdeacon Glynn Cardy.

Revd. Cardy says the point is not to offend, but promote conversation.

“I think that most Christians have a sense that the conception of Jesus was a special act, and how that came about – whether Joseph was the dad or some other party was the father – who knows.”

The catholic church says it knows exactly who was responsible, and is outraged.

“It really is not raising significant discussion,” says spokeswoman Lindsay Freer. “I think it’s bringing the Christian message of Jesus into some kind of derision.”

The billboard, designed by M & C Sattchi, was not the only concept – an earlier design was rejected because it was “too much in your face”, according to Revd. Cardy.

“They had a neon sperm coming down, and joy to the world.”

The campaign follows news of a very different campaign last week, in which an atheist group raised $20,000 to run messages on New Zealand busses which read; ‘There is probably no God, now stop worrying and enjoy life’.

But whichever way you look at this one, it is set to provoke debate about what the ‘essence of God’ really is.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [3]

skarabrae
02 Mar 2010 10:47a.m.

What is happening to some christian churches.How is it that one minute we are told to believe in the bible and the next told," who knows if its true?".You discredit one part of the bible you discredit all.You can't say the bible is true accept the part of christ's birth.That kind of conversation i would not like to get into,"why?".I believe it to be true,and if i or anyone-else believes it then so be it as the book goes.These are the days when most will discredit the sayins of that book,its been predicted ,i rest my case.
And in response to the comment made about the Catholic Church,judge not lest ye be judge.Wheres the mercy,the compassion the forgiveness etc.Think before you speak,because im sure that same thing is happening in your own church you just don't know about yet.Be sure your sins will find you out.Have a little respect for others religious beliefs,cos from where im sitting i see a certain group of people representing a certain character.To believe or not to believe that is the question.Choose ye this day whom ye will serve.

Mandy
17 Dec 2009 4:47p.m.

I find it creepy that people think there is 1) something unacceptable about a child (JC) being born naturally (ie with egg and sperm; and 2) something especially pure about a woman who is a virgin and a mother. These notions are very offensive to women. None of our mothers are virgins; does that make them somehow defiled? Why do we persist in allowing this mysogynistic clap-trap to occupy an inch of our thinking time.

Ania
17 Dec 2009 1:11p.m.

Good One St Matthews. The catholic church needs to be more concerned with its own affairs, over 2000 years it doesn't have a very good track record.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - What changes would you make to MMP?
The Govt and lobby groups are urging people to have their say on
Comments (9)