Chinese tourist alleges Hamilton police brutality

Print

Thu, 09 Feb 2012 10:24p.m.

Naiju Li, centre, sits with relatives she came from China to visit

Naiju Li, centre, sits with relatives she came from China to visit

By Jenny Suo

An investigation has begun into a Chinese tourist's allegations of police brutality.

The woman claims she was tackled to the ground in Hamilton, suffering a gash to her face and a dislocated elbow.

But Waikato police deny the officers involved used excessive force when they arrested her.

Naiju Li says she does not understand how her holiday turned into such a nightmare.

The 56-year-old travelled from China to Hamilton to visit her niece.

Now she is recovering from a dislocated arm and an injury to her left cheek.

“I still don’t know why the police were so brutal; he was such a big police officer, he could have handcuffed me easily,” she says.

Last Wednesday Li drove to Countdown Hamilton to do some shopping when she returned to find her car gone.

Li then spotted a tow truck in the car park.

Knowing no English she said she used hand gestures to communicate with the driver and then sat in the truck so she could be taken to her car. Instead the police were called.

Win Van der Velde of the Waikato police says the woman was hanging onto a tow truck.

“The truck has a vehicle that did not belong to her hooked up to it, and when we asked her to desist she resisted in doing so.”

Li says she was cooperating with police but when she realised they did not understand her gestures she headed back towards the supermarket to sit down.

She says it was then that police charged at her.

“I screamed, my head was down. I couldn’t do anything with my hands to gesture anymore because they had my hands, and then my head went down,” she says.

Police say Li resisted her arrest.

Police say in the attempt to restrain her she tried to bite the officers and in doing so they had to take appropriate action to restrain her.

Li is now facing charges of disorderly behaviour and resisting arrest

She is is making a police complaint and while police are refuting claims of misuse of force, they are investigating the matter

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

22 Feb 2012 04:53a.m.

Katherine wrote:

It happened to me also and on the same day. The 7th of Feb. My SHoulder was dislocated...face and body bruised. Reason? Because I had just been tortured by handcuffs too tight..and I didn't want them back on. I'm prob the same size as that tourist, and had I had three males 'helping'. I haven't even done a self defence course. After being cuffed I was then dragged while limp. my handcuffed arms pulled so far behind my back that r)shoulder was pulled out and I used my bruised face to try and keep up so it wasn't pulled further. If I was that lady's age my ligaments would have pulled bits of bone away from my shoulder and sternum, and prob ribs. I certainly could not try and bite while being in this position. Even if she did try and bite....it is not justified. Nurses deal with confused and disorderly even biting patients and we perform care with compassion and limited restraint. Even small bruises are not acceptable.The tourist has a degree but is retired and elderly. I have a degree, but I'm not retired and not elderly. I want to speak up for her, because I've basically thrown away my career to explore police corruption and bruality first hand. This cop was a clasic liar.It was witnessed and is probably on cctv footage. My injuries were viewed by many, and documented by medical staff. I never said anything. Why not? Because I'm aware that cctv footage can easily be attained for the purpose of police defence only... I asked for footage of police "mishap' a few months ago and my life became very miserable. THe IPCA just say that it's ok. ly.It discusts me that the police spokes person said this force on the lady was 'ok'. WHere's the remorse? The pain and fear,bills,ruined holiday..loss or reputation.I know first hand! Did you notice that a man died during arrest two days later? That is two days after this lady and I were disabled 'accordingly and rightfully' huh?!??

17 Feb 2012 12:07p.m.

Jaaaaaaaaaa wrote:

There's really no need to argue at this stage. Everyone could have difference point of view on this, while at this stage conclusions can only be drawn by speculations. It could be an Asian lady biting the police coz her car was missing, or the police abusing his power. And please leave the racial topic out of the discussion. No matter what happened exactly, this Asian lady does not represent her country, and the police officer obviously doesn't represent the entire police force either. Even when the final conclusion is drawn, it can still be an isolated incidence. Jump to conclusion at this stage does not help to solve the problem. Keep your personal suspicions to yourselves, and wait for the official outcome of the investigation.

17 Feb 2012 12:01p.m.

J wrote:

There's really no need to argue at this stage. Everyone could have difference point of view on this, while at this stage conclusions can only be drawn by speculations. It could be an Asian lady biting the police coz her car was missing, or the police abusing his power. And please leave the racial topic out of the discussion. No matter what happened exactly, this Asian lady does not represent her country, and the police officer obviously doesn't represent the entire police force either. Even when the final conclusion is drawn, it can still be an isolated incidence. So please do not jump to the conclusion for now, keep your suspicions to yourselves, and wait for the official outcome of the investigation.

15 Feb 2012 02:17p.m.

Ihwp wrote:

there are a lot of very kind kiwis in this country. but i have to say the number of racist kiwis is growing, especially among younger generation. i feel very sorry for the lady and ashamed of the policeman.

13 Feb 2012 02:53a.m.

ishan wrote:

the question that goes through my mind is, what could a 56 year old vulnerable asian lady do to get tackled? cleary, the officer is either a ruthless racist or lacs in common sense.

11 Feb 2012 08:51a.m.

wan wrote:

This is outrages! an old lady tourist was beaten like this by a New Zealand police. Whats the difference between NZ police and Chinese police? Very unprofessionally handled! Things like this really make me lose confident on our police force.

10 Feb 2012 10:54a.m.

AJ wrote:

The evidence of brutality is under this woman's bandaging. Exactly what threat did she pose that warranted being tackled and dislocating her elbow?? If I were attacked by someone who I thought was being unreasonable then I too would have a go at that person, even if they were a police officer. IMO that is not resisting arrest, it is self defence. The police force are not above the law and should be accountable for their actions. The officer who tackled this woman and dislocated her elbow should face a charge of injuring with intent and/or common assault. Sounds like yet another case of a copper on a power trip.

@Bluey : you are an idiot. End of discussion.

10 Feb 2012 10:19a.m.

cherie wrote:

@ gosh What a stupid thing to say. It is just like anyone traveling anywhere in the world. All signs are basically the same and most counties have dual languages on them. Didnt know you needed English to drive a car? Look at this woman. How an earth the police can justify that force is beyond me. Maybe they thought it wouldnt be a problem as they know there are so many fearful Kiwis who dont like Asians so its not a problem!!

10 Feb 2012 09:35a.m.

Shelly wrote:

I wonder what would happen if I went to China and tried to bite a police officer over there? I don't think I would be heard from for a while! Sounds like the police tried to calm her down for some time, including getting one of her relatives on the phone to translate for her. If you try to bite police, you get taken to the ground and rightly so. Disgusting behaviour from a visitor to our country.

10 Feb 2012 08:48a.m.

AT wrote:

Bluey, being a typical bi-cultural Kiwi's like yourself who supposedly is happy to coexist does not mean that you have to be VICTIMISED in NZ. Instead, you should stand up for other poorly treated victims like this poor lady(tourist) not proficient in English. Most NZers will surely agree that whatever the misunderstandings, the Police Officers should be helpful to clear any doubts rather than breaking the poor perhaps obviously angry lady's arm....