3News » Home
Full Story

Controversial Seaworld trainer sets dolphins free

11 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Marine mammals can grow frustrated with their artificial habitats

Marine mammals can grow frustrated with their artificial habitats

Sat, 03 Apr 2010 12:28p.m.

By Angela Beswick

Disillusioned with the industry, a controversial marine mammal trainer has decided to set his last 17 dolphins free.

Chris Porter trained Tilikum, the orca responsible for the death of his SeaWorld trainer last month, when he was living at Sealand of the Pacific in Canada.

He says it was the death of veteran whale trainer Dawn Brancheau, 40, at SeaWorld in Orlando that prompted the change of heart.

“I have been decided to release the remaining animals back into the wild,” Porter told the Vancouver Sun.

Porter owns a lucrative business, capturing animals in the Solomon Islands and selling them to aquariums. He has sold 83 dolphins around the world over the last nine years.

Ms Brancheau was petting Tilikum after a show when she was pulled into the orca tank by her ponytail and shaken around. The coroner determined her official cause of death was multiple traumatic injuries and drowning. Autopsy results released yesterday ruled her death an accident.

Mr Porter said the incident shook him and proved trainers are unable to cater to the needs of such an intelligent animal. Though he used to believe some animals must be captive educational ambassadors for their species, he is beginning to doubt the value of shows where animals are forced to perform tricks and rewarded with food.

“Are we really educating and providing the best representation for these animals in an aquarium?” asked Mr Porter.

Orca become frustrated with the artificial, sterile environment they are kept in, which bears little resemblance to their natural habitat. Their frustration increases the chance they will lash out, Mr Porter said.

He credits Oscar-winning documentary The Cove, which raised awareness to the bloody capture and slaughter of dolphins in Japan, as another catalyst in his decision to quit.

Mr Porter’s project in the Solomons initially set out to save dolphins, which were being slaughtered by thousands of islanders there who use their teeth as currency.

He told the Vancouver Sun hunters have now been educated to realise there can be much larger value in dolphins.

“When I got [to the Solomons] a dolphin was worth $20,” he says.

“Last year dolphins were worth $140,000.”

The debate around marine mammal captivity has reignited in the wake of last month’s death and Porter’s venture, Free the Pod, is likely to have strong support from animal rights activists and marine biologists opposing their capture.

One of Mr Porter’s former fiercest opponents, Earth Island Institute marine mammal specialist Ric O’Barry, is likely to provide high profile support.

Mr O’Barry trained dolphins for the Flipper television series in the 1960s, before dedicating himself to freeing captive dolphins.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [11]

Lilly
30 Apr 2010 6:43a.m.

I really hope that Tilikum is fine, if you have experiences with pets you need to know that they are sometimes ' playing' or are 'jelous' in a natural way but of course as bigger the animals are as bigger is the risk that something can happen.Such a lot of animals, espacially slome wild kinds are helt only for 'our fun'.So we all should know that something like taht could happen.
I dont think that Tilikum killed her on purpose.
I am very sorry about her, but I am also sorry about all of these animals, and I am sure that menkind can be much more dangerous than animals.Thanks god people like Chris still exist.

Mark
21 Apr 2010 9:11a.m.

Jeanne Youngs comment "this is a step in the right direction for humanity..." has to be replied too. These mammals are not humans people!!!! It has nothing to do with humanity but to do with looking after our environment and species responsibly! I have just returned from enjoying Sea world San Deigo and the wonderful educational facility that they have there, I believe they are doing much more for the protection of the sea species than any of the couch and seat sitters commenting on this blog. They really know their mammals after studying them intensely and in detail and from what they have learned are able to comment informatively and teach us the public as a result. Porters own work in the Solomns has through saving the dolphins made them of much greater value due to their appeal to the public in some of these wonderful Sea parks and educational zoos we have today. If there is no demand from these then unfortunately few people will ever be able to sea these creatures up close and appreciate their beauty. So get real people, a few of these species in captivity to help educate the public is much better than being out of site and mind of the majority.

nicholehastings
20 Apr 2010 8:42a.m.

It's sad that these captive animals have a difficult time assimilating back into their natural environment but the fact of the matter is they never should have been removed from it in the first place. It's awful that death may be the ultimate outcome but death occurs in nature everyday. The lesson to be learned from the ones that do die is don't do it in the first place. People think just because they can they should. Where did this sense of entitlement and ownership come from??? It's sickening to me. People ought to let nature be and just learn to appreciate it.

Flora
20 Apr 2010 12:48a.m.

Kudos to Chris Porter for instantly reversing his karma! Bravo!

susan Ibarra
09 Apr 2010 2:54p.m.

We have to do this!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Jen
06 Apr 2010 4:01a.m.

So really? You think that these dolphins will go back to their happy selves? What pod would take them? It's akin to a prisoner of 25 years showing up on someone's doorstep and telling them that they have been in prison and now they are going to live with you. But wait, they have no skills because they were born in captivity and they don't know how to hunt. Get real people! You can't just release these captive animals back into the wild because they won't be accepted by the animals that are naturally wild. "Hey, I'm your crazy uncle Tilikum from like 30 years ago...." "So, and like eww, you don't even talk in the correct calls and clicks. Like totally get lost." Keiko died a year after and was not part of a pod after he was released. And for the most part the US does not capture whales or large animals anymore. The last one that I know of was the whale sharks for GA Aquarium. Asia does not allow their capture anymore.

vanessa
06 Apr 2010 12:24a.m.

No where does it say how long these dolphins have been in captivity. Studies have been done, and there has only been 1 instance where dolphins were put back into the ocean and survived and actually became part of a pod! Those dolphins had minimal contact with humans, were not touched or played with, and kept their senses the same as dolphins in the wild. If you take a dolphin who has been in captivity and put it into the ocean, it will not recognize humans as people who can hurt them, will not speak the same language as other dolphins in the area (every pod speaks a different language)& 3) if left alone, will not have the ability to adapt on its own. If these people are going to put the dolphins back in the ocean, they need to make sure they successfully transition which I highly doubt they will be able to. After the 1st Free Willy movie came out, people were so obsessed with freeing captive whales that they finally freed the dolphin who played Willy into the ocean. It ended up starving and not assimilating back into the pod, where died alone, without any friends, of starvation. What do people not get? No, I do not think it is right to take a dolphin from the ocean and put it into captivity, but it is also ethically wrong to take a dolphin who has learned to trust humans and doesnt know how to hunt for its own food anymore, and stick it back in the ocean away from its original pod where it will NOT be able to speak to any dolphin again. You cannot do that! Not only will it not have a pod to be social with, but dolphin predators (such as sharks) target dolphins that are all alone and dont have other dolphins to protect them. Plus a lot of dolphins in the wild rely on one another in feeding techniques. It is a lot easier for a pod to chase fish into a ball & then each take turns feeding that it is for 1 dolphin to chase a fish around. This just makes me sick! I really hope I can keep up with this story to see whether or not these poor dolphins survive this happening.

v
04 Apr 2010 4:39p.m.

Greenpeace are on a mission of civil disobedience, pity these dolphins might end up on the dinner table.

Katherine Grechen
04 Apr 2010 1:02p.m.

This is wonderful news; a step in the right direction. Please, please help in any way that you can to set Tilikum free. They took a healthy, intelligent, sexually mature mammal cruelly out of its natural habitat and life and put him in a box. He is kept, for the most part, in isolation except when he is performing stupid tricks or being used for breeding. When did the US outlaw whaling? Isn't capturing free live whales still considered whaling? Orcas, in their natural habitat, live 70 years - this poor soul has spent the last 25 in prison, and he will live cruelly for a while longer and then die prematurely in a tank. I wonder how that must be to watch for the Sea World employees? Are the mammals euthanized or do they just linger? This practice of stealing sea mammals should be considered inhumane and illegal.

Jeanne Young
03 Apr 2010 6:49p.m.

I am so incredibly happy to hear this news. Good for you Chris Porter! I am so very proud of you:) Now THIS is a step in the right direction for humanity...

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio