3News » Home
Full Story

Controversial Whangamata marina opens

9 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA

video
Sat, 21 Nov 2009 5:41p.m.
By Adam Hollingworth

After seven years of legal wrangling, Prime Minister John Key finally opened the controversial Whangamata marina.

Opponents are still smarting from the decision, and say the town is still divided.

It has been a war of swinging fortunes for originals like Ross Mercer, who signed up for a berth back in 1992.

"Well worth the wait," says Mr Mercer.

The marina's guiding hand was Mick Kelly, who says most locals were always on board.

"It's going to be a real economic boost, already had an effect on real estate here and its just amazing to see the public walking through here and buzzing, its really good."

But not everyone's happy. Paul Shanks, a surfer and environmentalist, is worried that other recreationalists will be forced out.

"The marina is going to bring income, but what is sacrificed to get the income?" he asks. "Five hundred surfers a year learnt to windsurf in what is now the marina basin, so that income is gone, the ski lane is gone, so the passive recreation in the area, that's gone, the people came to watch the godwits fly in from Russia."

Two notable absentees are the former Environment Minister Chris Carter, whose veto was overturned by the courts and the local iwi who've been against the marina from the inception.

But Mr Key believes changes to the Resource Management Act mean other projects like this will take less time.

Already there are several marina developers queuing up to take advantage of that change.

3 News
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [9]

Mike Gunson
25 May 2010 2:44p.m.

Surfers are reporting dramatic changes to the Whangamata bar's form. the channel is being constantly dredged because of the marina changing it's consent after the court case (now not rock lined) meaning a lot more material being permanently removed from the estuary's sedimentary cycle. The estuary is the shallowest in the North Island with 75% of the water volume leaving the estuary on a low tide. the marina basin' water level is lower than sea level at low tide. And this property development was thoroughly and exhaustively tested through the environment court? Lawyers will always win against science! www.whangamata-marina.co.nz

Mike Gunson
25 May 2010 2:39p.m.

Surfers are reporting dramatic changes to the Whangamata bar's form. the channel is being constantly dredged because of the marina changing it's consent after the court case (now not rock lined) meaning a lot more material being permanently removed from the estuary's sedimentary cycle. The estuary is the shallowest in the North Island with 75% of the water volume leaving the estuary on a low tide. the marina basin' water level is lower than sea level at low tide. And this property development was thoroughly and exhaustively tested through the environment court? Lawyers will always win against science! www.whangamata-marina.co.nz

silver surfer
23 Nov 2009 7:21a.m.

Its better to be a poor man getting properly threaded in the tube than a fat rich man stuck in the eye of a needle.

John Wilson
23 Nov 2009 2:10a.m.

Yes Steve and we will just love surfing the Bar now that bigger boats with bigger wakes are coming to town. It's that crazy psycho back wash that just makes something that was perfect...just a freak show of laughs. But if we wait a bit longer there'll be a clamouring to dredge a decent channel out to the sea....but who'll care by then. Those surfers that sold their souls for a marina berth profit will have settled for a thin one and a days fishing by then.

Steve
22 Nov 2009 2:07p.m.

The Bar is still there. The Bar still has great surf. Some bandwagoners can't see the wave on The Bar for the Green in their blood.

Kerry
22 Nov 2009 1:45p.m.

Whangamata bar was a real treasure, it had an international reputation for producing amazing waves for surfing. It is a real tragedy that just one more piece of our irreplacable New Zealand nature got carved up for just another marina for a few wealthy people to enjoy. I am not against a marina but why destroy something so precious to others in order to get it.

Wayne Mason
22 Nov 2009 12:23p.m.

In the land of democracy it is good to see the majority get some thing they wanted instead of being stopped by a very small majority of wingers.

Andrew Bell
22 Nov 2009 10:52a.m.

Does this world never change? It saddens me that the rich always win out over the ordinary man in the street. Money always gets what it wants in the end! Paul Shanks has fought a brave fight for his turangawaewae and the wave he loves, Whanga Bar. Local iwi have fought a brave fight for their rights to be kaitiaki and their resources of kai moana. But it all means nothing when the rich white man wants a play pen. It would serve them right if Gaia sent a huge storm to wipe out their gin palaces and the irony would be that Whanga Bar would be pumping after the storm. If it hasn't been dredged into extinction.

amber
21 Nov 2009 11:15p.m.

economic boost... yes and the effect on real estate will only push the locals out because they can't afford to rent let alone buy... or pay the rates!1 arrrh another case of the rich getting richer... a community doesn't and can't survive on weekend gin palace blow ins.... wonder how many marina "pies" mr keys has got his fingers in... you'd have to wonder...

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio