Daycares may be harming child development

Print

Sat, 28 May 2011 6:41p.m.

Some children are expected to spend around 10,000 hours in daycare

Some children are expected to spend around 10,000 hours in daycare

By Charlotte Shipman

The most important thing for a parent and child to spend together is time.

“I am really frankly concerned about babies who are got up out of their cots at 6 in the morning, to be at their child care at 7.30, and not picked up again til 5.30 or 6 at night, I don't think that's a desirable way for a small infant to be living,” says Dame Lesley Max.

But it's a reality for many families. Some children are expected to spend around 10,000 hours in daycare before they're five.

Dame Lesley Max says it's well established, children are more at risk of developing aggressive and challenging behaviour if they spend long hours in early childhood care.

“Many children in that circumstance lack a sense of safety and security and life seems to them a bit of a battle ground. And they have to be the dominant one, or the one that suffers,” she says.

The chief executive of the Early Childhood Council doesn't believe there is an increase in aggression in young children.

“I think what we are seeing is perhaps a little bit more attention on the issue than we may have before, and I don't think that should be confused with some sort of massive increase and a whole bunch of little toddlers running around with gang patches beating people up,” says Peter Reynolds.

Mr Reynolds says many aggressive children are not involved with early childhood centres and if they were their parents would have better access to help.

Mrs Max says there's no magic equation, but maintains a balanced approach to both early childhood centres and parental care leads to a balanced child.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments

31 May 2011 03:27a.m.

Athena wrote:

My 2 1/2 year old has never been in daycare and has a lot of aggressive behavior. The only other child he has to play w/ on a regular basis is his older brother who is about to be 8. I think daycare would be good for him to have interaction w/ kids his age. Not all day, just for a few hours a day. We go to the park but I think he needs more than that and to learn independence. I just don't have the money for childcare costs.

30 May 2011 10:21p.m.

Rach wrote:

Remember when you were at school, how long a school day felt? That was only 9am to 3pm and we were school children. These little babies, toddlers and preschoolers are at daycare centres all day. How are they supposed to know how to have loving relationships if they are denied a loving relationship with parents in their first 5 years of life?

29 May 2011 01:53p.m.

Carolyn wrote:

Yeah, someone making sense!!! It's when the children get to be teenagers that they simply do not know who they are if they have been left in childcare centres from an early age. How can they? Their only real bonding is with their peers, and yes the strongest wins, hence the low self- esteem and lack of self-confidence to take risks or not have any boundaries at all. The more clever kids later become very adept at classroom politics and, from my experience, are not the ones often who are obviously getting into trouble, but they sure can cause it. I believe Mr Reynolds is wrong and doesn't want to know. The teachers at childcare centres are still only doing their job which finishes at whatever time each day and then they may leave and never see the children again. But, there's always a down-side for these parents so ready to put their children into daycare and that maybe that if you institutionalise your children early, then they will institutionalise you early (the saying I learnt when I was home-schooling my son. Personally, I feel incredibly sorry for these children holed up in daycare centres all day, every day like prisoners. You know, there is a huge downing of mothers, but as Desmond Morris said in his book "intimate Behaviour" a child doesn't just love it's mother because she FEEDS it, a child loves her for "who she is."

29 May 2011 04:21a.m.

Max wrote:

We have a far bigger bullying problem in schools then we had 20+ years ago that for sure.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)