3News » Home
Full Story

Diabetic woman dies after "missed opportunities for intervention"

5 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Maureen Pineki, 68, died in Auckland City Hospital's intensive care unit from a critically low level of glucose in her blood

Maureen Pineki, 68, died in Auckland City Hospital's intensive care unit from a critically low level of glucose in her blood

Tue, 17 Nov 2009 7:29a.m.
The Auckland District Health Board has cleared Labtests of any direct responsibility for the death of a 68-year-old diabetic woman.
 
Maureen Pineki died after health providers missed valuable opportunities to treat her, an investigation has found.

Mrs Pineki died in Auckland City Hospital's intensive care unit on September 12 from a critically low level of glucose in her blood – hypoglycaemia, according to an Auckland District Health Board report obtained by the New Zealand Herald.

On the information provided there appeared to be a number of missed opportunities for intervention to reduce Mrs (Pineki's) insulin dose," the report said.

Auckland's new medical laboratory provider Labtests was criticised in the report, along with the medical centre which ordered blood tests, and an ambulance crew who treated Mrs Pineki.
 
The report said Mrs Pineki's call to her GP's clinic was handled by a nurse but her concerns were not passed on to the doctor.

The nurse ordered a home-visit blood test but did not make any special note of Mrs Pineki's reported hypoglycaemia, which resulted in the tests being treated as "routine".

The results were found to be critically abnormal, but a delay in processing meant it was unclear if this was real, or caused by natural breakdown in the blood sample.

Labtests should have urgently contacted the medical centre, the report said.

On receiving the Labtests fax, which probably "downplayed" his interpretation of the results, Mrs Pineki's GP tried once to phone her, but got no answer.

That morning, an ambulance crew was called after Mrs Pineki fell.

They gave oral glucose, without determining her history of hypoglycaemia, "which would have indicated transport to hospital was required".

Labtests said the report's authors had told the organisation its handling of the tests did not directly lead to Mrs Pineki's death.

However, her family told the paper they were not satisfied with the report and were planning to consult a lawyer about her treatment.
 
The report has cleared Labtests of any direct blame but says the company - along with St John Ambulance and the doctor's clinic - could make service improvements.

3 News/NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [5]

Dan
17 Nov 2009 5:24p.m.

What difference does that make who initiated the change. It was allowed to go through during National Govt. tenure as I recall correctly that Labtests were supposed to be in place quite a while back but the court case was holding them back.

I think the judiciary and the Govt. have both let us down. Its not going to make any difference to these politicians if a number of people die before they realize they cocked up majorly.

Yes indeed Ricardo, Labtests management should be brought up on criminal charges for negligence causing death.

Ricardo
17 Nov 2009 2:43p.m.

Its not directly National's fault - Labour brought this stupidity upon us....however National has been in power long enough to realise it isnt working and should rescind all deals and have the management up on criminal negligence charges.

Jackie
17 Nov 2009 12:59p.m.

I think Dan you will find that this contract and the cut-price deal was done under the previous government not the National govt. However, having said that all governments are just as ineffectual as each other, most politicians are in it for either the glory or what they can milk the system for at our cost... if they're not lining their pockets they're lining that of their cronies! This time they should do the right thing and admit defeat and had the contract back to Medlab. For our health's sake.

Dan
17 Nov 2009 11:50a.m.

Can we see this report which proves that Labtests was not at fault? After all this is a public related matter and we want to know whether we can trust our health care service provider? I went for a blood test to DML despite the fact that I would have to become a private patient and pay for it, as I would not risk my life with these idiots at Labtests.

Dan
17 Nov 2009 11:47a.m.

BS. Labtests is supposed to be the diagnostic testing facility for this country but they have proven that they are a failure. The DHB's and the Govt. Minister for Health don't want to face public wrath that they screwed up by changing the contract from DML. Hence the NZ govt. is responsible for letting the tax payers and public at large down massively. I for one think interim elections are needed as this National Govt. stinks.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - What changes would you make to MMP?
The Govt and lobby groups are urging people to have their say on
Comments (15)