Thu, 19 Nov 2009 8:33a.m.
A proposed $400 million deal between Hanover Finance and Allied Farmers is being panned by Shareholders Association chairman Bruce Sheppard.
Allied Farmers announced yesterday it had signed an agreement with Hanover Finance and its subsidiary United Finance which would see the rural services and finance business company buying the finance assets of Hanover and United.
If approved, Hanover and United investors would receive Allied Farmers ordinary shares issued at market value, and Allied Farmers would acquire the finance assets of Hanover and United.
But Mr Sheppard said the proposal would be great for Allied but extremely bad for Hanover and United investors, The New Zealand Herald reported.
He called on Commerce Minister Simon Power to intervene to halt the transaction.
Appointment of a statutory manager was investors' only hope, Mr Sheppard said.
Under the deal, Hanover secured depositors would be able to exchange their debentures for Allied shares. The ratio would be determined by the volume weighted average price over the five trading days leading up to the deal's completion.
But Mr Sheppard predicted Allied's already-low share price would collapse further from 30c to under 10c, and Hanover investors would get only a fraction of their money back.
"It will be a great deal for Allied. It will effectively fill up their balance sheet with over-valued assets that will generate some cash and restore their solvency.
"It will also be a great deal for (Hanover owners) Eric Watson and Mark Hotchin. They will have all of Hanover's debts taken out of the Hanover balance sheet, thus relieving them of any obligations to put the $20m in."
The $20m in guarantees had been committed by Mr Watson and Mr Hotchin as part of a delayed repayment plan approved by investors in December last year.
Allied Farmers shares yesterday rose 2c to 35c on thin volume.
Brian Gaynor of Milford Asset Management called the proposal "bizarre in many ways" and quite complex, although some parts of it had merits.
"It's extremely hard to work out. It looks attractive in theory because people will be able to trade their shares, assuming the share price doesn't completely collapse," he said.
NZPA