Dunedin council consider permanent liquor ban

Print

Thu, 09 Feb 2012 6:28p.m.

The council is proposing a year round liquor ban across north Dunedin (file pic)

The council is proposing a year round liquor ban across north Dunedin (file pic)

By Dave Goosselink

The Dunedin City Council is considering a permanent liquor ban in the student suburbs, in a bid to end drunken street parties.

Students would be banned from drinking outside their flats, and on the way into town.

But the students are preparing to fight the plan.

A few quiet drinks at the flat is something most students enjoy, but the council wants to ensure that is where they stay.

It is proposing a year round liquor ban across north Dunedin, to curb what it says are dangerous street parties.

“Some of the public gatherings are such that it is inevitable that sooner or later someone will get either seriously hurt or will die,” says Dunedin Mayor Dave Cull.

He is keen to see the end of infamous "scarfie" scenes like couch burning and mass drinking on the public streets.

But Otago's Student President Logan Edgar is rejecting it as a long term solution.

“Drunken disorderly, that sort of student behaviour has been very much on the decrease over the past year, so it's surprising me that this measure wants to be put in place.”

The city has already seen off the annual toga parade and Undie 500 events, after problems with drunken disorder.

And the university's been buying up and closing down old student pubs like the Gardies and the Bowler.

“It almost seems like a bit of a strategic manoeuvre by the university and the local council to change or adapt the culture or perception of the culture that goes on down here,” says student Devon Latoa.

Those pushing for the liquor ban say it is about cleaning up the reputation of Otago University. But senior students believe it could actually end up killing Otago's unique culture.

“A lot of students do come here for that "Otago" culture. It's slowly becoming more and more defunct,” says fourth year student Alice O'Connell.

Students and the public get to have their say on the plans later this month.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

14 Feb 2012 11:08a.m.

jan.. wrote:

Alex, perhaps you tell us how to managed the adults, the over age should know better to respect drink to enjoy and not the other way round..
Students are young and needs help to ajust their drinking problems where the adult drinkers were once students should think twice about alcohol and the danger ahead and like Steve comment' Good on you Duniden Council. "We want a clean city"..
Alcohol will abuse you if you abuses the alcohol, you got to be the boss and not the alcohol, thank you for your comments guys..


10 Feb 2012 01:26p.m.

Alex wrote:

@Ben, spot on. @James, it's not just students, it's ordinary folk of all ages that breach council imposed liquor bans. Drinking liquor is a victimless crime, and it shouldn't matter which location it is drunk at. The main thing I (and most people) are concerned about are those who contravene the safety of themselves and others due to their actions under the influence. Most folk can have drink anywhere and will cause no disturbances whatsoever to society.

10 Feb 2012 01:01p.m.

Ben wrote:

This liquor ban is ridiculous, all you are doing is challenging students. By fighting against the student culture with bans you are putting kindling to the flame and students will react badly. Why not work with the students to try and change the culture by making social drinking more acceptable rather then binge drinking.

10 Feb 2012 10:24a.m.

James wrote:

"Liquor bans DON'T work!" They work to some degree hell even if people try draw less attention to themselfs while drinking that is a win. You must think students are rich if you think all of them will keep challenging the ban indefinitely.

10 Feb 2012 07:25a.m.

Alex wrote:

@jan. Why just students? What about all adults? The reason is simple, because it's fun. And it will always be deemed fun until the culture changes in ways that will make it become less fun. If the council wants to force people in the student areas to not drink, then it's simply not working. The problem is a few individuals who choose to misbehave, that is what annoys people. Not drinking in the street. People who desire to get drunk will get drunk by other means and having a liquor ban means nothing to a lot of people - has been trialled all over the country and seems to be revenue gathering at best.

10 Feb 2012 12:57a.m.

jan.. wrote:

Why do students need to drink alcohol' why not go fishing or visits the country sites instead of drinking within its territory and annoying the town people..
I think you guys haven't got that brainwave to explore.. University are everywhere in the world, move on guys and exercise your brainwaves, alcohol and tobbaco are not important..

09 Feb 2012 10:15p.m.

Peter wrote:

About time something was done about drunken street disorder in Dunedin. As a former Otago student I take umbrage with claims about "tradition" and "culture". Couch burning and street parties have got totally out of hand and have seriously compromised the reputation of both the university and the city. If students stop going to Otago because they can't wreak havoc then tough. They will be very disappointed to find that disorder isn't tolerated at other campuses around the country. Time to grow up.

09 Feb 2012 08:53p.m.

kelvyn wrote:

The Dunedin City Council is considering a permanent liquor ban in the student suburbs in a bid to end drunken street parties. Students would be banned from drinking outside their flats, and on the way into town. Wow !!! High fives for that one folks..someone has finally figured out drinking alcohol causes drunkeness. This is really breaking new ground. You know I think this may go viral...they have linked alcohol to drunkeness, and I never thought I would live to see the day. Well done Dunedin City Council. Ban public drinking and drunkeness...yes,yes,yes. Hold the thought folks, we can do it.

09 Feb 2012 08:08p.m.

Nick wrote:

Logan Edgar for Mayor

09 Feb 2012 07:58p.m.

Stevie wrote:

Excellent, too many time and money wasting of unresponsible kids. Over consuming alcohol, there is nothing more disgusting than walking past drunk kids or have to step over vomit in the street. Good on you Dunedin Council. We want a clean city.