Full Story

Dunedin councillor resigns from arts committee over 'black penis'

Tue, 13 Sep 2011 10:31a.m.

Dunedin city councillor Lee Vandervis has “resigned in disgust” from a council arts sub-committee, over a giant, black phallic artwork that has cost ratepayers $50,000 to rent.

Mr Vandervis said yesterday the council’s Art in Public Places subcommittee rubber-stamped a $100,000 spend on artist Rachel Rakena’s 3d video art work 'Haka Peep Show'.

The piece was unveiled in the Octagon on Friday and is in the shape of a deodorant can brand endorsed by the All Blacks. Ms Rakena describes the work as “towering black pou” (pillar or post) with a phallic reference.

Ngai Tahu has spent $80,000 on the art work, with council voting to spending another $50,000 from the Rugby World Cup marketing budget, something Mr Vandervis also opposed.

According to Mr Vandervis the artwork will be returned to Ms Rakena after the duration of the Rugby World Cup.

"We're paying $50,000 to rent a black penis in the Octagon? What's that all about?" he told the Otago Daily Times.

Dunedin Mayor Dave Cull dismissed Mr Vandervis objections.

"Does it matter? ... Cr Vandervis' comment is irrelevant. The work has been part paid for by the Dunedin City Council for the benefit of the region."

Ms Rakena said she did not lay claim to the artwork, unless no-else was interested, in which case she would take it back.

She expected the city council and Ngai Tahu would own the piece,

Art in Public Places chairman Cr Bill Acklin said Mr Vandervis had broken council rules by discussing a sub-committee decision and that such discussions were “100 percent confidential”.

"As far as I am concerned, this art work was funded from the Rugby World Cup budget and is nothing to do with the Art in Public Places subcommittee. Anyone who says otherwise is seriously breaching confidentialities".

3 News

Comments [30]

goblin
15/09/2011 10:57:48 p.m.

In fact we are well educated and cultured in Dunedin. In fact most of Dunedin think this is joke. Dunedin does not want to fund social welfare art anymore. My city is on the verge of bankruptcy. I know Lee Vandervis, he is arrogant and stubborn but one thing he is not is adolescent, he is trying to make sure Dunedin stays solvent. It amazes me how so many people are uneducated when it comes to running a simple budget, I am sure alot of them attend the Venice Biennale.

iz
15/09/2011 11:15:46 a.m.

people in dunedin are so uncultured! rachael rakena represented NZ at the Venice Biennale the most prestigious art biennale in the world! it's about the commodification of haka..... come on people

Steve
14/09/2011 2:56:26 p.m.

Dunedin is struggling to attract more business. Art-bashing articles from uninformed councillors and their media cronies doesn't help. Until the ODT wrote this article, people LOVED this art work. If all you can see is a 'giant penis' in this work, then you are as adolescent as Lee Vandervis. This work is a celebration of haka, as well as a questioning of why it has become so commercial. We need to spend money on culture in order to attract new residents. $50,000 is .025% of the amount spent on the stadium, and it provided work for about 15 people while it was made. Why not go have a look at the amazing 3D movies of NZ's top haka performers which are playing inside of the peepshow, rather than slagging something because the media told you it was bad???

John
14/09/2011 2:18:58 p.m.

I would love to know how this can get so much coverage when there was an amazing sculpture attatched to the Natural History Building in Dunedin that has never been mentioned or photographed since it was put up?

maurice
14/09/2011 12:26:18 p.m.

I find it hard to believe that people cant see this is a direct copy of a Rexona can. It has the button on the top and the indentations on the side, Has Racheal been "inspired" by Rexona, an All Black sponser or did she come up with this idea all by herself? I would like Mr Vandervis to ask if there has been a financial contribution from Rexona.

art lover
14/09/2011 11:36:38 a.m.

I dont undertstand why the media havent covered the great stories that the artwork shares. Have you seen the website? www.hakapeepshow.co.nz, this is awesome! I saw heaps of people in the octagon in the weekend enjoying the pou haka, outside of rugby contexts. This work makes great connections to the RWC without bowing to rugby culture. Keep it up!

helene
14/09/2011 9:35:48 a.m.

I think it's a clever idea, and as far as I can tell, well executed, but one glimpse of it on facebook was more than enough!

Lee
14/09/2011 12:19:22 a.m.

Put the "black penis" down with the teeth and they can rot together!

Lee
14/09/2011 12:15:33 a.m.

When i think about the families that are struggling I baulk at the thought of $50,000 spent on renting Art, whatever it is

Dodger
13/09/2011 9:40:47 p.m.

It would look better with the artist sitting at the top!

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here

Name:

Email:

(Won't be published)

Comment:

Recent Matches

Social