3News » Home
Full Story

ETS passes through urgency and under controversy

7 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Nick Smith was in bullish form as he pushed through the ETS bill

Nick Smith was in bullish form as he pushed through the ETS bill

video
Wed, 25 Nov 2009 6:34p.m.
By Sia Aston
 
It’s been controversial, it's been complicated and now it's law. The Government's Emissions Trading Scheme passed just minutes ago and comes into effect on January 1.

Watch Sia Aston live outside Parliament shortly after the bill was passed.

The debate in Parliament today was about the emissions trading scheme, but MPs spent much of the session trading insults.

“The genial incompentence of Gerry Brownlee and his house management or has Nick Smith finally blown a gasket.”

That one was Labour MP Phil Twyford’s, but he was not alone.

The man behind the legislaton, Nick Smith, immune to all attacks, had a few insults of his own.

“He's an embarrassment to his electorate, he's an embarrassment to himself,” he said of an Opposition MP.

But it was not all insults, there were also further attacks on National's deal to give five wealthy iwi free use of Crown land for profit in return for Maori Party support for the bill.

The deal is considered compensation for iwi who planned to re-litigate treaty settlements.

“A very slipperly deal, a deal that has never been put under scrutiny, a deal that opens a whole can of worms around the whole treaty debate,” said Mr Cosgrove.

And Labour’s Shane Jones went further.

“Using grievance as a crutch, deepening the grievance mentality that keeps that party alive,” he said of the deal.

Rodney Hide was not happy with the decision either.

“Any settlement can be re-opened and re-litigated if the Government ever makes a decision that might somehow put a cost on an iwi that's done a settlement.”

The Maori Party remained in the hot seat after reports emerged of a last-minute revolt within the party's council for leaders to pull support for the bill.

“Listen to your members who are meeting as we speak, who have called meetings to say to the Maori Party, 'do not do this to Maori voters',” said Labour MP Chris Hipkins.

It is true some elements are unhappy, but rumours of pulling support totally were wrong.

“The Maori Party will stay with their stand and on that there is no discussion on the part of the national council,” said Maori Party MP Te Ururoa Flavell.

And Maori Party leader Pita Sharples was standing firm.

“The point is we made a commitment, and that's our integrity on the line and we'll stand by that.”

So, New Zealand will have a new Emissions Trading Scheme and National says it will cost households $3 a week.

You can expect electricity, food and petrol prices to rise from January next year too. Consumers will feel the effects immediately, but costs to polluting industries will be phased in over time.

The Maori Party insists its deal with the Government has produced an Emissions Trading Scheme that will benefit everyone.

3 News
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [7]

Johnmillan
16 Jun 2010 12:24p.m.

There are 6 postings ahead of mine,and I agree what each one has said,Yes it is true that both National and Maori party are going to ruin NZ for good,the influx of those leaving NZ in the past 18 months show that they will spend a happier life overseas,But it is getting scary as one hundred Kiwis leave 200 foreigners are arriving.I hate having to go any where now,as you have to meet a foreigner behind the counter,they cant even say good morning or even thank you when you go to leave.They look at you as if you are there too rob them.Some shops you enter they have some one following you every where,as they dont even have trust in the elderly folk of New Zealand.Do we need to live in a country that have so many Indians running our corporate businesses,those who come from slum areas,I have been there,and it is a real eye opener,and after day and a half I got out of it,I wonder how long before New Zealand will start looking the same way.

Ed
26 Nov 2009 7:11a.m.

Key and his whole caucus are two-faced scum. They have sold out NZ people to a bunch of crooks and fraudsters.
I did not vote for them to give us increased cost of living, less freedom and continued racist spending and policy.

Glenn
26 Nov 2009 6:39a.m.

Now the poor will get poorer and rich will get even richer, so much for good ol NZ, it's going down the gurgler.

andrew johnson
25 Nov 2009 8:35p.m.

i often wonder how long it takes someone to lose touch with real people when they enter Parliament. judging by the Maori Partys support of this bill it takes about the time you manage to get your snout in the trough. My partner is a social worker and youd be amazed at how many people go through a Christchurch winter with no heating. these are not druggies , alkies or other stereotypes these are just elderly people who live in fear of the next power bill. maori party youre a disgrace

Wgtn
25 Nov 2009 7:50p.m.

Politicians have been corrupt for longer than I have been alive.. unfortunately though this government is the most corrupt I have ever seen.

Key slaps rodney and other Mp's with a wet tea towel for stealing tax payer money to fund their holidays.

Smith introduces sexual abuse criteria that allow ACC to make Post traumatic stress sufferers undertake psychiatric evaluations on a monthly basis if ACC feels like it.

Smith increases levies and then blames that on blowouts within ACC like sensitive claims when it doesnt even come out of the same account.

Education Minister cuts funding for special schools.
Education Minister refuses to fund specialist care for struggling students and students with behavioural issues.

Paula Bennett breaches the privacy act and names beneficiaries like she is above the law, then she and key take credit for falling unemployment even though the economy is improving.

However Smith is an arse, he has no empathy, no understanding and doesnt give a crap that he isnt representing the views of the people.

Resign Dr Smith, before you get kicked out... reminds me so much of ruth richardson in personality and looks.

jackle
25 Nov 2009 7:42p.m.

What a load of crap this ETS is, if the consumer didn't foot the bill the emitters would of just passed on the costs, global warming is a crock of sh*t, Y2K, Bird flu, SARS and then Pig flu never generated the panic scientists wanted so they come up with this crap, greenies are still driving, flying, and enjoying electricity the hypocrites bring on the eternal summer i say, none of its is gonna be the cataclysmic doomsday they are predicting, and if it is its time to reduce the earths population anyway the way AIDS was meant to remember those predictions.....

Bill
25 Nov 2009 6:58p.m.

Scam Scam Scam, put into law by corrupt politicians aided and abetted by a Corrupt Maori Party. Goodbye key and your cronies, 3 years will be enough of you, in fact it will cost New Zealanders big time. But I guess you can have a few drinks with your rich prick mates tonight.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio