• Full Story

European Muslims criticise veil ban plans

Print

Mon, 17 May 2010 10:56a.m.

Salma, French national living in Belgium who chooses to wear niqab after converting to Islam (Reuters)

Salma, French national living in Belgium who chooses to wear niqab after converting to Islam (Reuters)

By Veronika Oleksyn

Muslims who attended a conference in Austria's capital criticised European countries for considering the possibility of banning face-covering veils, saying it is counterproductive and regressive.

Veil bans are being considered in Belgium and France, and lawmakers in other European countries have also raised the issue.

The roughly 100 imams and Muslim religious advisers from 40 countries participating in the meeting in Vienna agreed that Islam doesn't make it a requirement for women to wear face veils and saw little need to discuss it because of consensus on the matter, said Carla Amina Baghajati, a spokeswoman for the Islamic Religious Authority in Austria, which hosted the meeting.

"Nevertheless, we are critical that it comes to a ban," Baghajati said. "Why? Because it's counterproductive." She was among about 30 women taking part in the meeting.

An extensive draft resolution presented at the end of the two-day conference called for programs to promote the education of Muslim girls and women and said every mosque should have a female contact person for women's issues.

It also expressed concern about a Swiss referendum late last year to ban the construction of new minarets and stressed that the practicing of Islam encompasses the respect of people from other religions or who hold different world views.

"Muslims don't want to be seen as a problem but rather as part of the solution for modern challenges," the document said.

The laws proposing bans on face-covering veils give the impression there is a need to restrict Muslims because there is "something dangerous" about them and that they don't respect women's rights and need to be taught, Baghajati said. This, she added, brings up the divisive "we" and "them" notion that Muslims in Europe are trying to overcome.

A discussion within the Muslim community has helped keep the number of women dressing this way in Europe to a minimum, she said.

"This inner-Muslim discussion helps that we have very, very (few) women wearing these kind of clothes."

Famile Fatma Arslan, a Dutch lawyer and fellow conference participant, warned that the bans, if approved, could backfire.

"By creating a ban, you're not being preventive but you're being regressive," she said. "If you raise children and say 'this is something you shouldn't do,' my kid, or my kids, or my nephews are doing it."

Instead, Arslan added, the focus should be more on the empowerment and education of Muslim women.

AP

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

22 May 2010 03:55p.m.

Brick wrote:

We should ban tattoos. They are offensive to me and I feel intimidated when a tattooed person addresses me. I am having my rights ignored when I have to deal with someone with them.
I also feel they are inappropriate in a workplace and should be covered up. I should also be able to not hire a person with tattoos as they are unsightly and I lose customers who might find them offensive too.

18 May 2010 03:37p.m.

David wrote:

@ Ricardo, if it were for identification there would be no need for a ban of 'relgious' head gear including tubins or yamaka. The incorrect assumption of 'if I cant see your face your a criminal' is degenerating into the generality of 'if you are diferent to the majority then you are a criminal'. Again I refer to France where young women banned from wearing a head scarf as a symbol of relgous difference, nothing to do with identifcation al all.

17 May 2010 01:08p.m.

Ricardo wrote:

Very simply it's to allow ready identification of ALL citizens. Anyone covered head to foot is able to commit any crime, regardless of beliefs, so must be readily indentifiable. If Muslims don't like it, don't live in Europe, simple. Europeans are (rightly so) VERY concerned about the terrorist element, which sadly seems to be largely sourced from the group who complain about these bans the most. If Muslims want to be seen as different and proactive good citizens then they must work too to weed out the extremist elements within.