• Full Story

Family Court review 'frightening' - lawyer

Print

Wed, 20 Apr 2011 10:44a.m.

Simon Power (NZPA)

Simon Power (NZPA)

By 3news.co.nz staff / NZPA

Lawyers fear a review of the Family Court system could see "frightening" changes to essential services and access to the court.

Justice Minister Simon Power yesteday released the terms of reference for the review, expected to be available for public consultation in September.

In addition to considering ways to encourage people to resolve problems outside court, the review will look at the state's role in the court, the purpose and functions of the court, and the role of lawyers, mediators, psychologists and social workers in the court.

Mr Power says the increasing cost of running the system needs to be reigned in.

"The review will look at how a piecemeal approach to family law reform has impacted on the efficiency of the court, as well as ensuring it is sustainable, cost effective, and responsive to the needs to those who use it and the taxpayers who pay for it," Mr Power said.

Family Court expenditure increased from $83.9 million in July 2005 to $137.1 million, with legal aid and family-related services among the significant drivers of costs.

Care of children applications, which account for more than 40 percent of the court's direct operating costs, increased from $40.5 million in 2005/06 to $52.3 million in 2008/09.

But lawyer Judith Surgenor says the types of cases Mr Power has used to argue his point are rare.

"It's tragic the minister is holding up those sorts of cases as the norm, not the exception," she told the New Zealand Herald.

"They're frightening reforms, really. People come to family court under massive stress, sometimes after years of violence. There are a number of supports and they are needed.

"To slash and burn something you don't understand isn't particularly wise or fair."

Family law expert Caroline Hannan agrees, telling the Herald:

"People have to be able to access the court if they are unable to resolve things themselves.

"There are some cases where there is no clear cut answer."

Mr Power disagrees that cutting funding will endanger children.

"There's little evidence to show that the increase in spending has led to improved outcomes, particularly for children."

3 News / NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

20 Apr 2011 11:09a.m.

dr shirley abdul wrote:

come on nz get rid of these mugs, they have wrecked everything they touch. not one sector of our society is happy with this gov't. even the dairy industry is on tenderhooks sinse the gov't announced it was looking to change the industry . please don't touch the one thing that is working. this gov't are scarey, hundreds of bills passed and many are a real mess. incompetence is national with a capital N.

20 Apr 2011 10:55a.m.

Fred wrote:

Lawyers need to understand that continual abuse of the court system by them is what has caused the massive increase in court costs. Unfortunately though, I do agree that the Minister is unlikely to make any changes which will improve the system.