Farmer to Transpower: 'Too little, too late!'

Print

Mon, 25 Jan 2010 4:56p.m. UPDATED AT 8:51pm

Farm owner Steve Meier says he told Transpower years ago to fix the problem which caused today's power outage

Farm owner Steve Meier says he told Transpower years ago to fix the problem which caused today's power outage

By Jerram Watts and 3news.co.nz staff

It has been officially confirmed that power has been fully restored to Auckland and affected areas. Transpower CEO Dr Patrick Strange told 3 News hot water outages will continue to be experienced, possibly as late as tomorrow.

“Too little, too late”.

Disgruntled farmer Steve Meier has slammed Transpower for not dealing with sagging power lines and tall tress on his property that caused today’s power cuts.

The cut to the national grid occurred around 4.30pm today when power lines connected with trees on Mr Meier’s property in Matangi, southeast of Hamilton, sparking a fire.

The cut coincided with Otahuhu Power Station being out of operation for maintenance.

Thousands were affected from Huntly through to Wellsford for hours as Transpower workers attempted to gain access to Mr Meier’s property to fix the damage.

Transpower chief executive Dr Patrick Strange told Campbell Live his staff attempted to access the property to fix the damage, but were barred by Mr Meier.

Around ten police officers attended the scene in order for workers to gain access to fix the problem, Dr Strange said.

It is a relationship that has been strained for some time.

“We’ve been having a hard relationship with Mr Meier, probably the most difficult in the country,” he says.

“We have been trying to get on the land for some months, we’ve been sending in notices saying we need to do tree trimming – he has blocked us.

Dr Strange also said Transpower was in talks with Mr Meier’s solicitor – as late as this afternoon – to get onto the land.

“The solicitor said, ‘I’ve tried, but I can’t help you anymore; I think Mr Meier is out of control.’”

However, an exasperated Mr Meier told Campbell Live the problem is Transpower’s, and it has been going on too long.

“What happened today, after we told them five months ago was going to happen – and only a matter of four weeks ago – that their line was going to ignite our tree.

“They should have pruned the trees 18 months ago, two years ago, three years ago,” he said.

“I told my lawyer to tell the national lines manager that this was an accident waiting to happen.

“They've had years to deal to this, but they would rather see us lose hundreds of thousands of dollars, and walk broken arsed out of our farm.”

When asked if he had a message for Transpower, he was very clear.

“Too little, too late! Why did you not do your sums years ago and see what your incompetence leads to?”

Dr Strange says the incident was “unfortunate”, but Transpower can never guarantee cuts won’t happen.

“But we have been very open and very honest about it,” he told Campbell Live.

“We have a major infrastructure rebuild going on. In the early 2000s upgrades didn’t occur. We’ve got $800 million in the Waikato line, $100 million in Otahuhu - $2 billion worth of projects are going into Auckland – you cannot fix it overnight.”

Auckland Mayor John Banks was critical of Transpower on Campbell Live.

“What we are talking about is institutional arrogance,” he said.

“We have heard a lot of ‘humbug’ and a lot of excuses. How can it happen… that a power failure in Hamilton chops out a big chunk of Auckland and causes so much economic damage and hardship for people?

Mr Banks says he has told Dr Strange for many years now that a disaster was going to happen.

“This is not the end, this is only the beginning. What we have witnessed is a lack of funding by previous governments and a lack of courage by Transpower of organising priorities and getting on with the job.”

Dr Strange says Mr Banks needs to get “more supportive” and that Mr Banks has been “very well briefed” that the supply to Auckland is stretched.

Mr Banks said he wasn’t “politicking” when he was going to stand up “for the good people of [this city].”

The outage caused major problems in Auckland today; traffic lights were affected and the police responded by deploying available staff to major intersections.

Transpower declared a grid emergency, which meant Vector had to implement rolling outages to prevent a longer lasting outage.

Northpower also had to reduce the load on lines, disconnecting some customers temporarily.

Transpower concentrated on retaining power for central services like water, sewage, hospitals and airports.

Twitter users in Newton, West Auckland, Point Chevalier, Morningside and Manurewa said they have not been affected by the cut.

Did the power go out in your area? TXT what happened to 559: TXT "news" then add a space, then your message
 
Replies from TXTers:

"Our power was out this morning for maintenance, now its out again. All our food is going off."

"We have been without power in Mt Eden since about 4.30pm."

"Plenty of power in Stanmore Bay. Transpower must construct additional pylons."

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

27 Jan 2010 10:41p.m.

Chris wrote:

It won't be long before this country is widely regarded as a banana republic. Its bad enough that a single landowner can hold the power supply of our largest city to ransome, but now we have to put up with farmers whinging about compensation!? Surely the price they paid for their land would have reflected the fact that there were pylons on it. And if they already owned the land when the pylons were built, then they should have made a more compelling case for compensation at the time. Demanding money years after the event makes them no better than the likes of Hone Harawera, bleating about what society owes them, and not once pausing to think about the big picture.

27 Jan 2010 04:03p.m.

robbie wrote:

Good on ya steve meier!listen to them crying about losing power..thats not your fault..they will try to shift blame on the farmers though..transpower are a joke

26 Jan 2010 08:40p.m.

Joyce Taylor wrote:

How many would like strangers wandering on their property and destroying trees. He did not ask for the power lines to be put there. It is purely a transpower problem, and they are just bullies.

26 Jan 2010 06:56p.m.

Peter wrote:

The people who are calling Steve Meier are completely ignorant. He is a farmer which is probably one of the most stressful jobs one can have. Also HE did not put those pylons there. He tried to solve the problem by getting the people(Transpower)who DID put them there to fix the problem. He didn't put the pylons under the trees. I'm sure he doesn't have the time and the resources to fix the problem himself. All it would have taken was transpower to fix the problem 6 mouths ago and this whole inconvenience wouldn't of happened.

26 Jan 2010 03:24p.m.

gary wrote:

these farmers are paid to have the power lines/pillars on their property. question:- do the trees belong to transpower or the property owner? as for john banks does he actually think before he speaks!

26 Jan 2010 12:41p.m.

Pauline wrote:

I thought it was rediculous that John Banks mounted a personnal attack on Dr Strange from Transpower rather than confront the statement that he should be more supporitive and take Transpowers phone calls. John Banks not only had his facts wrong but proceeded to make things personnel, rather than stick to the facts (discussion) in hand. I beleive he has made a complete fool of himself in public by doing this.

26 Jan 2010 12:06p.m.

Jason Fry wrote:

why didn't Meier trim the trees himself if he was so aware of the problem, he looks like he could do with the fire wood...

26 Jan 2010 11:54a.m.

Tony wrote:

The Farmer is an idiot, cut the power to his property and see how he feels about that.

John Banks - a waste of space, where is the leadership that a Mayor of a Super City should provide - blame everyone else and play dumb when he knows exactly what is going on!

26 Jan 2010 09:37a.m.

Craig wrote:

Transpower dropping the ball once again. What makes me laugh is that Auckland is suposed to be the massive super city and the way of the future that all the rest of the country is supposed to look up to and yet the rest of the country's power generation systems are keeping it from caos. little do people know there is only two major power generation sites in Auckland area and the rest of them (major) either on the Waikato river,new plymouth or transferred from stations in the south island. island

26 Jan 2010 09:36a.m.

Ghost in the System wrote:

Once again, ill-informed commentary and ignorance rules the day.

Firstly, Meier is trying to make this all about him - wanting TV crews present everytime Transpower try to do work - refusing entry at every possible opportunity (Easement or no easement).

Secondly - Transpower are trying to upgrade infrastructure that is between 40 - 60 years old. Governments of all colours have neglected this infrastructure for decades.

Thirdly - John Banks' rhetoric and hubris add nothing and solve nothing. He was a Cabinet Minister during the 90's - where was his concern then when he had an ability to influence Government spending priorities? So typical of John Banks to bury his head in the sand and then come out yelling and screaming in order to score political points...and you people wanted this guy as your Mayor?!?!

Fourthly - For most of the nineties and naughties (i.e. 2001, 2002...) Transpower engaged in a softly softly approach vis-a-vis land access, so as to mitigate the worse effects on private property rights (under the old CEO who was suitably named Ralph Craven); but now you have a CEO who ain't gonna take that BS anymore.

Fifthly - thinks about this: the current grid was effectively built between the 1950's and 1960's under the auspices of the Public Works Act, which meant that the Government could do ANYTHING it liked. So construction took - give or take - 15 to 20 years. Now, try doing that today, with dozens of different councils each with a different interpreation of existing use rights, pylon, transmission, etc and different rules about what an organisation like Transpower has to do in order to get consent...then add in factors like building consents, earthwork consents, private property access to name but a few and everyone seems to think that this can all be fixed overnight.

As I said at the start, ill-informed commentary rules the day in internet land.