3News » Home
Full Story

First signs of tax shake-up revealed in budget

4 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Property taxes, along with GST and personal taxes, are under the spotlight

Property taxes, along with GST and personal taxes, are under the spotlight

video
Thu, 21 Jan 2010 12:14p.m.

By Jennifer Colwill

The first signs of a shake-up to the tax system are likely to be revealed in May's budget after a high-powered tax working group delivered a review of the system.

GST, personal tax rates and property tax are all under the spotlight, and the experts agree a fairer system is needed.

The suggestions from the tax working group are aimed at producing a fairer, more efficient tax system.

One economist says if land taxes and GST increases happen, the wealthy won't be able to hide their income.

“They tend to be very efficient taxes and that is both fair, but its also efficient in terms of putting New Zealand on a sustainable footing for the next 10 years,” says Cameron Bagrie, ANZ national chief economist.

Real estate is also on the hit list with suggestions of a new tax on residential rental properties.

“It should drive a transparency around the real rent cost and the real rent paid as a yield,” says Alistair Helm of Realestate.co.nz.

“That's all hidden at the moment in the ability for people to try and deduct as much as possible and pay as little tax as possible.”

GST could rise to 15 percent and one tax expert agrees this would make things fairer.

John Rowe says when the income tax system is set up, it can include compensation for the increase to GST.

“It's generally accepted that those higher income earners proportionately pay more in GST, so if you compensate the lower income earners by bringing down the tax rates as well they'll have more money in their pockets to offset any increase in GST,” he says.

Labour leader Phil Goff says any changes to the tax system need to help the average hardworking kiwi.

He also says loopholes need addressing.

“If you've got half of the people earning the big money in this country paying a lower tax rate than the average hard-working New Zealander, there's something wrong with the system,” he says.

“That's got to be fixed.”

The Government says it will carefully consider all the recommendations.

3 News

Comments [4]

roxanne
23 Jan 2010 10:45a.m.

Well I hate GST but the one thing it does have going for it is that the rich cannot avoid it, they consume nice new kitchens, cars, furniture etc and they pay the tax. Mind you they can book it up to their company but that loophole needs closing too. So does the family trusts set up to avoid taxes and let's face it most of our MPs will have such trusts. That nice Mr English was not living in his house but one owned by his trust and was therefore entitled to taxpayer assistance. They are in the trough and somehow we need to get them to pass fair laws that will actually have a detrimental financial effect on themselves! I do agree that something needs to be done as NZ cannot afford the present system.

Dan
22 Jan 2010 10:32a.m.

LOL! Nice one "Smart As". There are several solutions to this conundrum but the fact is are the politicians really wanting to make changes for the positive for the common man? Here we see the highest income earners tax bracket to be lowered, which is themselves and their mates in big businesses but where does that leave us all?

Smart As
21 Jan 2010 5:11p.m.

Nice Dan, so obviously one and one make two and the govt only want to confuse poeple by shifting taxes around like the sickness/Invalids benefits. Why won't they simple drop GST off basic foods and at same time that would save on health. GST on unneeded goods could be increased to 20%. Then there'd be no need for tax breaks and any surpluses could be used on NZ dept. Dr Spock told me this on round about but we never got a ticket because we were flying?

Dan
21 Jan 2010 2:50p.m.

Bollocks! Snap Shot:

1) GST increase will compound strain on common man to pay more for all purchases. Where is the money?
2)Tax rebates or change in personal tax structure will just about make life a bit easier for families who are straining on the budget. Increasing GST will bring back the strain so where is the benefit for the common man?
3) Tax on real estate is a different matter and needs to be addressed seperately.
4) Already increases in ACC levy, Insurance costs, water, electricity,telephone/internet charges are in place. How will the govt. offset these increases for common man who has had no salary increases for nearly 2 years?

This rejig is not going to work if the GST is increased.

Simple math logic states increase on every purchase and reduction on personal tax slab leads to an equilibrium status quo situation. Hence in short this entire exercise is a moot point.

Post a comment

Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:


3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - An earthquake measuring 7.1 on the Richter scale struck Christchurch this morning
Comments (143)

Chch earthquake - tell us your story

An earthquake measuring 7.1 on the Richter scale rocked Christchurch this morning. Have you been affected by the quake - we would love to hear your st...