Goff: Bring back Shane Jones

Print

Thu, 14 Oct 2010 3:58p.m.

Labour MP Shane Jones was trapped in the mine - but it's time for Goff to pull him out

Labour MP Shane Jones was trapped in the mine - but it's time for Goff to pull him out

By Patrick Gower

Watching the miners in Chile, I can't help but think of the Labour MPs - stuck down a dark hole, with an incredible effort needed to get them out.

It’s leader Phil Goff's job to get them out - now he's finished burying Chris Carter.

And one man who needs a lifeline is Shane Jones.

This call is never going to resonate as much as "Bring Back Buck". But someone has to say it - Goff should "Bring Back Shane Jones".

Jones has hardly been seen since he was snapped spending taxpayer cash on blue movies. That was a shocker.

But he's on the way back: expect to see him seek Labour's nomination to stand in Tamaki Makarau against Maori Party co-leader Pita Sharples.

There's always been talk he'd go for George Hawkins' plum Manurewa seat. But nominations for that close on Friday - Jones' name won't be there. He'll keep his carpet-baggers parachute stuffed in the cupboard.

Goff's having a reshuffle of the Labour caucus soon - it needs it.

And he needs to give Jones a meaningful role.

I'd say Maori Affairs. Put him head-to head with the Maori Party, in the House, and on the streets of Tamaki Makarau with Sharples. Jones won't win, but it'll give him street-cred if he takes him on. Jones will be parachuting in there too, but because it’s not a safe seat, it doesn't matter so much.

Jones is a lot like the brilliant rugby player in your school team who didn't turn up for training so the coach dropped him to the bench.

Put someone who tries harder on. That works OK for a week or two - but not if you're losing the game like Labour is.

You need to get the best guy back on the park.

The best thing for Goff is that the ‘blue movie’ controversy has finished off Jones' leadership hopes - he's not a risk.

So bring him back. Bring Jones out of the hole and let him help get some of Labour's other miners out.

And just like the brilliant player who didn't want to train, you need to keep him busy, with a decent job.

Jones has the credibility and knowledge to take the Maori Party on over issues like the Foreshore and Seabed.

The National-Maori Party "solution" is looking increasingly like a mess from all sides.

I went out and had a look at how it might work on the ground at Shipwreck Bay in Northland.

It's a red-button issue Goff had a crack at it in his infamous "Nationhood" speech. He went too early, got panned by the media. Then the liberals like Andrew Little and Grant Robertson got all anxious - and Goff ended up chickening out.

Jones has the ability to criticise both sides of the foreshore debate. I've seen him say Maori are getting too much and aren't getting enough in the past fortnight. Some might say that's a flip-flop. Others will say its clever, because its reflects how nobody's happy with the "solution".

Some in Labour just want the foreshore to go away. But If Labour don't get in on it - then Winston Peters will make all the mileage.

Jones doesn't need to be bumped up the rankings. Just give the guy a job, massage his ego a bit.

He's one of the sharpest guys in Parliament, he's funny, and he carries the trait that so many politicians crave - he's normal.

It would be good for Labour and Goff for him to have some prominence.

And this is a two-way street. Jones' big problem is he's lazy. This is his last chance. He needs to make something of this, or just be known as "blue movie man".

Like with any reshuffle, politics will get in the way. Even if Goff wanted to make Jones Maori Affairs spokesman, what does he do with Parekura Horomia? You need to keep Horomia sweet - without him on board you may lose Ikaroa-Rawhiti. They need to find a way round this.

And what other miners should Goff save first?

Kelvin Davis: like Jones, he's normal. He can connect with real people. He's got a story to tell. He did well in the real world as principal of Kaitaia Intermediate. He's got a story to tell. I give him the title of "possible future leader".

David Parker: Ambitious, and on-to-it. Needs to be given greater responsibilities.

Grant Robertson: promoted already, doing well. As Tertiary Education spokesman, has clearly given up on "free education", which he spent the best years of his life pursuing. What a waste of youth - but it shows he's got the pragmatism to get ahead in politics.

Jacinda Ardern: Set to become heroine of urban liberals. Will be high-profile in the so-called "Battle of the Babes" in Auckland Central against Nikki Kaye.

Phil Twyford: I don't think Goff likes him much. But he's worked hard on the super city and made it an issue.

Carmel Sepuloni: New Pasifika face. Tough.

Stuart Nash: Working hard, financially literate.

David Shearer: Goff's mate. He helped Goff out big-time in Mt Albert. A lifetime in battlezones: now he's in Parliament with the Science portfolio. I'm constantly surprised that every time I see him that he's actually awake. Give him more to do.

Labour's locked in a hole that's covered over at 32%. Fresh faces will help them get out of it.

And who'll be the last out of the hole?

Chris Carter said there's 17 MP's who discussed getting rid of Goff with him.

I'm sure there was: even if it was just off-hand remarks. What that shows is that it’s an unhappy ship down in Labour's hole.

They'll be 17 slightly red and worried faces at Labour's Party conference this weekend.

The same faces will be starting to lobby for the reshuffle.

There's a bit of room being made for the reshuffle with Winnie Laban, Lynne Pillay, George Hawkins, Pete Hodgson, and Chris Carter leaving.

But even so, when someone goes up, others must go down. There'll be more uhappy people in the hole.

I expect the reshuffle to be in December - so the losers have the Summer to get over it.

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

27 Oct 2010 03:52p.m.

managirl wrote:

Shane Jones - good, solid decision maker.There is none that can touch him in the Hive and when he swings his verbal taiaha,there's none to matcch him. He is a threat to both Maori and Non-Maori parties and they know it. Maori party (other than John)are Key's trusted brown faces. On the other hand, Cunliffe is the 'white' Shane Jones in terms of brains,vision and political astuteness.Don't dismiss this man!!

19 Oct 2010 12:33p.m.

martyt wrote:

Patrick good yarn mate keep up the good work i enjoy your stuff i've said it before you are an average to middling journo and that's about all we can hope for in this country

18 Oct 2010 10:40p.m.

Mike Rollo wrote:

Patrick you would look better on Radio, sorry to say but all my mates say the same, try keeping your hands in your pockets for a start, it detracts from the commentary you are trying to bring across

18 Oct 2010 12:42a.m.

Laura wrote:

I agree with Laurie - Shane Jones definitely is intelligent, articulate and real. It also helps that he has a slightly washed English accent, resulting in what he has to say having a domineering effect on those listening. Some other points: If David Parker advances, can he please upgrade his wardrobe. He constantly looks like he's swimming in a woollen suit hand-me-down from his father. Is it too much to ask that he dresses to this century? It will probably give him a bit more confidence also, not having to push past the 'past' to get his voice heard. Also, bring on Chris Hipkins. He's overlooked when he ought not to be. Great speaker, and very natural.

16 Oct 2010 08:23p.m.

Adrian wrote:

Goff is not a Prime Minister nor is he a magician. Labour will only win if they side hevily with the Maori Party policies then again the Prime Minister role will have to be sacrificed to Tariana; what a break through that will be. If Obama can do it for black americans so can Tariana for female representation and Maori. Nice work Tariana your hard work and fortitude is note worthy of an admirable leader.

15 Oct 2010 11:37p.m.

laurie wrote:

Right on - bring back Shane, he's intelligent, articulate and real.

15 Oct 2010 10:18p.m.

steven wrote:

you can spot a media whore a mile away cant you pat ?.have you worked it out yet ? the mainstream media is part of the problem , no freedom of the press they are brought and paid for people .

14 Oct 2010 06:59p.m.

artherboy wrote:

Labour needs to replace Cunliffe with Parker.
They need someone with grunt to take on Health.
I agree Patrick, they need to bring some fresh faces forward.
Who will George Hawkins choose as his successor in Manurewa?

14 Oct 2010 04:22p.m.

arnold wrote:

Get a grip on reality Gower. Jones is a layabout, who spent our money watching porn. If he was serious, he'd work hard to get a seat. For once I agree with you about Kelvin Davis, a intermediate school teacher has infinite more real-life experience than say JK - who was a commercial success in an international market.

Patrick Gower's Entries

Finance Minister Bill English delivers the 2012 Budget (Photo: Jared Mason)

OPINION: English taxes the smokers but leaves the boozers

The path to that wafer-thin surplus in 2014/15 will be paved by taxing the life out of smokers.

Comments (4)

Key is looking quite up-for-it and motivated at the moment - I've heard him say on a number of occasions recently that he wants to "get stuff done" (pic: file/Victoria Evans)

Key still holds all the cards

The typewriters have been telling their interviewers that all the sideshows are wearing the PM down - in my experience, the typewriter is often wrong.

Comments (13)

John Key has been telling everyone how much he likes the local nasi goreng

Key's love of nasi goreng shows why he likes Crafar sale

John Key wolfs down a big feed of nasi goreng – and washes it down with some Southland sheep milk.

Comments (17)

McCully hacker now says he's Kiwi

The McCully hacker, self-described Russian 'Yuri Petrov', is now claiming he's just a normal old Kiwi bloke.

Comments (1)

Who is the Russian who hacked McCully's emails?

So who is the McCully hacker?

What I can say is about how I came into contact with the hacker - it was through Twitter.

Comments (2)

"Key and Joyce are sick of people who say 'you can't' when it comes to projects that generate economic growth."

SkyCity pokies deal should be a conscience vote

The odds against a conscience vote are the same as those against someone beating a pokie machine - the machine always wins.

Comments (16)

Gower: David Shearer had a shocker with his response on the ‘Nick Smith political favours scandal’.

Shearer's shocker on Nick Smith scandal

It has to be said: David Shearer had a shocker with his response on the ‘Nick Smith political favours scandal’.

Comments (13)

Lesley Longstone

Sex offender teacher: Bureaucratic heads must roll

Public sector heads must roll, argues 3 News political reporter Patrick Gower.

Comments (9)

Politics 2011 was "bloody exciting"

Patrick Gower's bloody exciting end of year blog

Politics bores the hell out of most punters, says Patrick Gower, so he'll sum it up for you in a few short words.

Comments (3)

Phil Goff and Winston Peters

Goff should rule out Winston – right now

Peters has left Goff stranded up the aisle. Shame! Goff should have ditched Peters first – and long ago.

Comments (12)

Don Brash says marijuana should be decriminalised

Banks will roll Brash as ACT leader, it's inevitable - blog

It seems inevitable John Banks will take out Don Brash as the leader of the ACT party.

Comments (13)

Key says without the urgent law change, "criminals will walk free" - this is essentially blackmail

Labour must harden up and reject police spy-video law change

Goff needs to look in the mirror and say to himself: I am not going to cave into the petty politics of John Key on this one.

Comments (15)

Peter Dunne called his spin-doctors into action after reading one of Patrick's blogs

‘I’m not dirty!’ – Dunne. ‘Yes you are!’ - Gower

Peter Dunne's spin brigade has tried on a full-frontal filthy denial of his dirty deal in Ohariu with John Key/National.

Comments (19)

Electorate deals are dirtier than AC/DC after a particularly long and sweaty tour

Dirty electorate political deals, done dirt cheap - blog

It's election year - there are dirty deals all over the shop and they are taking genuine choice away from voters.

Comments (21)

ACT voters might be wondering if getting rid of Hide was such a good idea

The ACT Party looks pretty much stuffed

The rebranded ACT Party looks like a couple of old blokes on life support.

Comments (30)

Key badly wants a piece of what's going on in India

Key turns pirate-hunter to nab Indian deal

John Key the deal-maker has thrown the possibility of a NZ warship chasing Somali pirates into the mix of the India Free Trade deal.

Comments (11)

Bishop Brian Tamaki

Destiny Church and politics: All about money and votes - blog

All I could think when I saw the Maori politicians getting blessed by Brian Tamaki was "who is using who here"?

Comments (26)

IRB Chief Executive Mike Miller is just too chummy with Frank Bainimarama's regime

Old Farts at IRB have lost the plot over Fiji

Here's a question for International Rugby Board - what part of "Military Dictatorship" don't you understand?

Comments (39)

Patrick Gower is a 3 News Political Reporter based in Wellington.

Here he offers his commentary on New Zealand politics from his front-row seat in the Press Gallery.

He has been a journalist for ten years, going as far as Afghanistan to get his stories, and was previously a political and investigative reporter for the New Zealand Herald

Subscribe to this blog by email