Goff and spy argue over Israeli investigation

Print

Thu, 04 Aug 2011 6:05p.m.

Also in the papers was a report prepared by the SIS

Also in the papers was a report prepared by the SIS

By Rebecca Wright

The leader of the opposition, Phil Goff, has locked horns with New Zealand's top spy Warren Tucker.

The two men are at odds over what was discussed at a briefing over the Israeli spy allegations.

During the Israeli spy controversy last month, Labour leader Phil Goff criticised Tucker, the SIS boss, for not briefing him on the SIS investigation.

Today Tucker struck back, releasing file notes of his meeting with Goff to blogger Cameron Slater which show the pair met on March 14th and the third item on the agenda was the investigation into Israeli nationals in Christchurch. So 3 News asked Goff if the topic of Israel came up.

“I don't believe that it did, if that had come up I would have remembered,” he says.

Also in the papers was a report prepared by the SIS on the investigation into Israeli nationals in Christchurch. On it, Tucker made a handwritten note.

Goff says he doesn't have any notes from the meeting but that he'll be taking a third party into any further briefings.

The Prime Minister is standing by his top spy.

Neither Goff or Tucker come out looking clean in this exchange. Someone is either not telling the full story or has had serious memory failure.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

05 Aug 2011 09:51p.m.

heather wrote:

well im sure you no about nothing about the spy business rebecca . so why are you qualified to even do this story in the first place , what an insult to our intellegence .

05 Aug 2011 11:52a.m.

Tai wrote:

Looks like corruption in New Zealand already. sounds like american politics where documents are being falsified and the leader (Key) stating them as facts. I doubt someone in politics who has a history with Israel would forgot something so important. Money is power this is a prime example of that.

05 Aug 2011 11:25a.m.

Rick wrote:

Go to the "OPAL FILES" site,which has been posted for some years,...I know a particular section of this recounting to be factual,as I was involved...It is said that this site was posted by an American Security Service operative...the Ideal continues...same players,same tactics..Phil,I feel for you...tell it like it is,don`t let this go unresolved...the truth must be demonstrated,we must know who is realy moulding our country...

05 Aug 2011 11:00a.m.

Clarke wrote:

I'm sorry mouthguard you dont get to speak about abuse when you have spent the last two days calling people socialists because they give a shit about others, or accuse them of being beneficiaries because their opinions differ to yours. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black lol ex-military men are a waste of space arent they mouthguard... you are fighting your own extinction and lack of love. And from what I know about Cameron Slater he has serious mental health issues, and a sever lack of impulse control... great dog to have at your front door... ones thats a complete loon.

05 Aug 2011 10:50a.m.

Sam wrote:

This is the same national party old scam "jobs for the boys "that Jenny Shipley employeed poeple with the "Fake CV's" OMG how could it not be rigtwing coffee club

05 Aug 2011 10:37a.m.

katrina wrote:

Why should Goff have to be informed on anything, he is not the ruling party he is opposition. If he wants any information he should have to go digging.

05 Aug 2011 10:20a.m.

Ricardo wrote:

Great, just what we need. A guy who wants to be PM debating national security issues in a newspaper. Goff is such a twit.

05 Aug 2011 08:27a.m.

Mouthguard wrote:

The claws are out when their Great Leader is threatened! Anyone who doesn't share your political bias is a lunatic Clarke (which current polls put at about 77% of the population)and Kim once again descends into abuse, this time about a man's appearance, as if that has anything to do with his ability. I particularly love Clarke's conspiracy theory. Priceless. Do you really think Key spends ANY time these days worried about Goff? lol, why would he? Goff's family will vote for him, add Kim and Clarke and that's it (who only are so pro-Labour because mummy and daddy were).Guess what guys, we live in a democracy (which is why you folks can spout your rhetoric here on a daily basis) with laws. One of the upshots of that is the official information is available if you access it correctly. Goff is looking like a child on this one, moments away from a tantrum. Hardly statesmanlike behaviour. The SIS treat Goff like he is. Irrelevant.

05 Aug 2011 06:16a.m.

Glenn wrote:

Kim, I would say that the sis boss is a National supporter and perhaps was looking at it being a chance to make Goff look bad? Just a thought but a possibility.

04 Aug 2011 10:44p.m.

Pete wrote:

The SIS released the documents to Whaleoil under the official information act. Though the question does remain why they refused to release them to Fairfax media days before...