3News » Home
Full Story

Goff wants to take a bite out of GST increase

14 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Phil Goff wants to amend National's proposed GST increase

Phil Goff wants to amend National's proposed GST increase

video
Mon, 10 May 2010 5:39p.m.

By Duncan Garner

Labour leader Phil Goff is suggesting his party may reverse the Government's planned GST increase in next week's budget – but only on basic food items.

The Prime Minister says Labour is confused about what it stands for and is at "sixes and sevens".

Labour's Phil Goff took his MPs on a tour of a brewery in Nelson – but he didn't touch a drop.

It's been a year of sobering poll results and on Wednesday he will attempt to get Labour on track with a policy speech.

The focus: the economy and the Government's planned GST increase to 15 percent.

He says a Labour Government may reverse the GST increase on basic food items like fruit and vegetables but keep it on fatty foods, like greasy takeaways.

"A lot of people have put forward a case sometimes on the basis of nutrition to say 'why not exempt, for example, fresh fruit and vegetables?' - that's something we'll look at," he says.

Mr Goff says reversing National's planned increase on daily grocery items needs to be considered seriously.

"In opposition, you're bound to look at all of the options, challenge your assumptions and then come out with a decision that is based on the pros and cons of arguments, one way or the other," he says.

Mr Goff's possible compromise is modelled on Australia – where fatty foods include GST – the fruit and vegies don't.

But John Key says it's a disastrous position.

"History shows you it is extremely difficult to take GST off food and to actually deliver a system that is not overly bureaucratic and, therefore, very expensive to run," he says.

In Australia, experts said the exemptions wrought havoc in the business community – compliance costs were up as business struggled to define what should be taxed and what shouldn't.

Mr Goff's Wednesday speech is also expected to outline changes in the party's monetary policy and on income tax.

The speech is important for Mr Goff – it's about showing Labour has moved on and is willing to change.

But Mr Goff's biggest problem is whether anyone is listening.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [14]

Chris
12 May 2010 3:19p.m.

Yes - we have a generation of young with the attitutude of 'what are my entilements, not, what are my responsibilities' which the new UK Tory PM reflected on. They have major inner city crime with knifeings, inner city blight with violent drugged up street kid gangs where the police have no go zones. Where the UK goes - NZ follows.
This attitiude in the UK and NZ can be firmly laid at the feet of a form of socialism with the 'I want it now' and 'If its not mine I will take it' mantra. We have a generation of bullet proof kids with instant gratification and antisocial attitudes. The education system has not helped with this as young people now are educated with the 'I have rights' philosohy.. The antisocial atitudes is seen clearly in NZ with their behaviour towards authority and society.
NZ society ain't what is used to be - and thats sad.

Lightseed
11 May 2010 7:08p.m.

the crime we have today can't be blamed on those currently in government, these problems have taken a long manifesting, and it is going to take a long time to get to the roots of these problems and fix the direction this country is heading down. It's going to take future governments and the present government to tackle.

Dan
11 May 2010 3:10p.m.

Better to skip over to big brother across the tasman then face the headaches created by Nats. Nothing is going well for the common man.

Craig
11 May 2010 1:57p.m.

Ha ! I see the latest polling has Phil dipping even lower - I think he is under the margin of error ! - he has to go but on the other hand he is doing the Nats. a favour by staying as they will romp home again which is good as 3 years is too short a time to get the country going again after 10 years of decline.

Public debt?
11 May 2010 11:54a.m.

Im confused over this issue about National blaming Labour for NZ public debt. Labour says that in 2008 crown debt was 0% was 5% at election time due to GFC. Now debt is around 29%.

Max
11 May 2010 10:54a.m.

I'll have to agree with Pete on this one. Crime rates have gone up, unemployment rate had dropped right down with Labour, (check statistics) there is a lot of white collar crime, Drug dependancy is not the governments fault. There will be more family breakdowns etc, as more family's are struggling to live and earn a decent wage. Studies suggest this adds more stress on relationships. However Labour introduced working for families to combat this, and also child poverty. The problem here is that wage growth hasn't been this low in about nine years and GST mean -$. Rents gone up, prices of houses have gone up substantially, power prices(which Key promised to bring down), basically everything. Oh I believe power prices will be raising again soon. Im not convinced this is the proper intelligent way to run and support NZ. But trying to keep an open mind.

Sam
11 May 2010 10:34a.m.

Maybe Keys alittle slow thinking .25 cent rise in wages will catch OZ

Pete
10 May 2010 11:27p.m.

John or Karen or whatever you wish to chose to post under.

National has yet to prove itself on crime.. with multiple deaths last week, multiple a few weeks before that... whats National going to day when the next lot of statistics come out... oh we need more time?.

You forget about white colar crime John, you forget about those rich thieves with the fancy lawyers and the crooked accountants.

There is crime in all sectors of society... the higher you are up the ladder.. the better you are at hiding it.

P use has risen worldwide, but then you are a moron you blame the labour party when all countries have been trying to fight it and are failing.

Shall we see how well National does where other tory governments have failed?.

Seriously you are a stupid bigot that goes through life blaming the underclass for anything and everything.. not acknowledging that you just have better accountants and lawyers which means you never get to appear as a prison statistic... but probably should.

Wee done for the petty bigotry, well done for forgetting that there are companies breaking the law all the time, rich people funding drug rings.

Put it all on the lower and middle classes because it makes your petty and arrogant little mind feel better.

Grow up and get a life you over priveledged ass.

John
10 May 2010 10:38p.m.

'Pete' he is prime minister U are not - who's got the brains ? 'Fair wages under labour' ha ! - they stuffed this country big time both socially and financialy. We slid dow the OECD countries from 14th. to 26th. place when they were in power. What 'grew' under labour was gangs, 'P' use, family breakdowns, more welfare abuse, crime and a whole generation of young with an antisocial attitude. Thats why thet got dumped you moron. Really this debate is pointless the Nats. are in power and there is nothing U can do about except moan - which the left is good at. Cheers.

johnmillan
10 May 2010 10:30p.m.

John I realy like reading your stories,but too me you write a lot of CRAP,John Key is polling high!if you had a brain you would know they poll the areas of sitting members of the party that is in power,polls dont mean S all,another thing you say you have lived and worked in the USA,also Australia for many years,I think you are the sort that if you added those years up you would be in your 100 age bracket.Bolger tried the big act like Key is doing and he went crashing after his first term in power.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio