Government friendly fire denials 'political' - academic

Print

Mon, 04 Jul 2011 10:38p.m.

New Zealand's SAS troops were due to withdraw from Aghanistan this year

New Zealand's SAS troops were due to withdraw from Aghanistan this year

By Laura Frykberg

The Prime Minister won't rule out that New Zealand's SAS soldiers were shot by friendly fire at a hotel in Afghanistan last week, but says it's unlikely.

John Key has also firmly denied claims the Afghan government has apologised for the incident.

But an academic says our Government might be staying tight-lipped for a different reason.

ABC pictures show an exclusive look at the damage caused to the Intercontinental Hotel in Kabul.

But reports two Kiwi SAS soldiers injured while trying to save it were the victim of friendly fire is rejected by our Government.

“It's not the belief of the New Zealand Defence Force that the injured solider was injured as a result of friendly fire. It was possible but that's not the likely source,” says Key.

But a BBC journalist in Kabul says his sources have confirmed it was friendly fire which injured our troops.

The same journalist also says the Afghani interior ministry apologised to the New Zealand soldiers, but Key says it's not true

The leader of the opposition maintains the Government isn't being honest with the public and should bring the SAS home.

“Our position since 2005 was not to put the SAS back into Afghanistan, and that's been a consistent position, it's not related to this particular event,” says Labour leader Phil Goff.

The Defence Force released a statement this afternoon which says;

“What I can categorically state is that the Defence Force has not received any apology from Afghan authorities.

The SAS are meant to be in mentoring roles to the Afghani police, meaning we don't lead the raids.”

But an academic in defence and security says the Government's position is political.

“We don't want anything that will be used in New Zealand that would put pressure on the Government to rethink the length of time the SAS should remain in Afghanistan,” says Jim Veitch, of Massey University’s Center for Defence and Security Studies.

New Zealand's SAS troops were due to withdraw from Aghanistan this year, along with 10,000 US troops, but the date has been extended until April next year.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

05 Jul 2011 09:45p.m.

Nutz wrote:

All politicains "alter the facts". Not just Key. Better the devil you know. He's done alright man especially in a crappy time like with the recession and all.

05 Jul 2011 07:55p.m.

Dave wrote:

Yeah I remember when John Key firmly denied meeting with the Exclusive Brethern but then the video footage of the meeting came out. Why would anyone believes a word he says? He's a liar.

05 Jul 2011 05:41p.m.

Bob wrote:

don't let the truth get in the way of a good story...

05 Jul 2011 01:57p.m.

Erm... wrote:

I'm not sure an Afghani policeman quoted by a British journalist counts as proof of anything.

05 Jul 2011 07:32a.m.

RolanTheRat wrote:

A source told the reporter right just an excuse to print the story before the true facts are known.And no one has said it was friendly fire they are saying the are investigating how the attackers got into the hotel.