Govt: You're not sick, get a job

Print

Sat, 21 Aug 2010 6:00p.m.

Paula Bennett on The Nation

Paula Bennett on The Nation

By Ingrid Hipkiss

Social Development Minister Paula Bennett says thousands collecting sickness and invalid benefits are well enough to work, and their benefits will be halved or cut altogether if they don't look for a job.

Ms Bennett says the Government will introduce compulsory work-testing for invalids and sickness beneficiaries.

Since 1995 the number of New Zealanders who say they're not well enough to work has doubled, and 147,000 people now receive the sickness or invalids benefit.

Ms Bennett this morning told TV3's The Nation that many just aren't that sick, and should get a job.

"Nine thousand people that are on the sickness benefit, the doctor thinks they can work part-time, we at the moment do nothing about."

That's about to change - from May next year if a doctor says you're well enough to work, and you don't, your benefit will be halved.

Still not making an effort? You'll lose the lot.

"We're not saying everyone on day one is going to find a job, but yes you're not going to find one if you're not looking," says Ms Bennett, "so we're asking people to look."

Two thousand, seven hundred of them applied for 150 jobs at a single supermarket last week, proof beneficiaries advocate Sue Bradford says it's the job market that needs fixing, not the welfare system.

"One hundred and sixty thousand officially unemployed - where are all these jobs for the sick, injured and disabled going to come from?" she asks.

And on another controversial topic, Ms Bennett called on iwi leaders to face up to the issue of child abuse.

Official statistics show that more Maori abuse their kids than non-Maori, and Ms Bennett says some Maori mums now accept abuse as the norm.

"I think they have a low sense of value and self-esteem, and quite frankly they're letting some pieces of filth into their lives that are hurting their children," she says.

Ms Bennett signalled new initiatives to tackle Maori child abuse in the coming weeks and more options for welfare reform in the coming months - classic National touch-stone policies.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

09 May 2012 06:44p.m.

Jake wrote:

NO NO THIS IS NOT GOOD!!!!! People on the unemployment benefit are struggling to find jobs as it is do not make it fucking harder for us!! I have being unemployed for over a year and a half and it IS NOT for a lack of trying. I only get 1 interview every 2 weeks and I have experience and training such as NZQA certificates but I always get turned down for jobs. Please Please do not make this any harder for those on unemployment and bloody do something about the lack of jobs instead of bashing us for not having one.

08 Apr 2011 07:51p.m.

anil wrote:

anything as

21 Feb 2011 10:36p.m.

Pauline wrote:

Where are all these jobs coming from....????? I have a son on Invalids benefit and he is in residential care and he only gets $50 personal allowance a week... it cost that much to travel to a job, let alone to buy clothes,go to the GP, get prescriptions, have a life... He has had a small job for a while but he reads at the age of 7 and is in hospital alot..... no employer is going to want to employ someone who has to have time off work to go to hospital.....yes get all the people off the benefit by improving your WINZ systems so there is less fraud but dont make parents of Special Needs adults poorer than they already are because they have to spend every last Cent on their adult disabled children for the rest of their lives. Blanket rules are unfair to those who truely need the support. Sharpen up your WINZ processes... employ staff with nouse and integrity to screen the applicants.

21 Feb 2011 08:01p.m.

Mark wrote:

Good to see the Government taking on abuse in the welfare system. Don't otehr people find it surprising that invalids and sick people seem to be increasing much faster than general population growth!

08 Nov 2010 06:30p.m.

mark wrote:

wow mr key maby the tax payer should look at you getting on an invalids benefit as you seem to be the sick one since you came into power all you have done is totally blackmail the poor and hand to the rich it is you that is sick and i shall celebrate the day of youre death with the biggest smile on my face i hope our country isnot silly enough to put and idiot like yourself in power ever again so i have a 5 month old but i am on the unemployment not the dpb i am trying to get a job and have applied for over 250 sofar with absolutly no success you are a gross man and u need to be told u idiot

19 Oct 2010 10:06a.m.

Obvious wrote:

When will workers realize that their taxes REMAIN THE SAME no matter how many people on benefits there are.

Freed up money always finds some way of being spent.

As a worker, do you really want more competition for finding a job?
That's what will happen if all the invalids/sickness beneficiaries are sent job hunting.

Made redundant and trying to get any job to feed your family?

whoops...snapped up by an invalid who can barely do the job (while making their life hell).

did any one of us vote for this specific change?

If not, we're in a dictatorship.

25 Sep 2010 02:51p.m.

Kathy Allpress wrote:

I am 57yrs of age and I am on the Invalids benfit for live because I have one hand.I work all my life since I was 14 yrs of age.I have over work my right hand.I had a car Accident in DEC 26 1976.Brought up 6 children mostly on my own,and they saying we are not sick who are these people to judge and who made them god anyway.

09 Sep 2010 10:33a.m.

Trev wrote:

It has now become official.
The Ministry of Social Development has released a formal directive telling case managers to target costs harshly.

Sick people are now being denied access to public transport to get arouns on a daily basis if their disability causes them to be unable to walk places.

Medical costs are being denied enmasse, sick people will soon have no where to go but onto the streets.

Dont believe me? write to the Ministry of Social Development.. request under The Offcial Information ACT 1982 for copies of directives issued to case Managers in the last 6 months.

You will find it there.

Well done National for treating sick people like human refuse.

03 Sep 2010 05:25p.m.

David wrote:

Deane is precisely right, disabled people are unemployable because employers won't hire them. Target the employers, rather than the potential employees they continually turn away.

02 Sep 2010 01:38p.m.

Deane wrote:

Indeed it is the wealthy that are the real bludgers. Top 5% pay no tax though LAQC.

Not to mention the recent bailout of SCF.

People on Invalids benefits have to go through a process to get it. First a GP refers the patient to a specialist, who carries out an examination and prognosis. That examination is peer reviewed and impartial.

Each year the patient attends a follow up assessment.

What is lacking in the current situation is the need for occupational therapy, counselling, affective management of the patient’s condition and finally a training system to build up their self esteem.

Majority of people, if not all, on invalids benefit wants to work. The reality is they are on the back foot when employers do not want to employ a sick person.
In having experience in HR, I know full well employers do not want to employ people who are, or were sick as the employers focus is on number of sick days taken, ability of the patient to work under pressure, and other costs.
Workbridge has been in operation for over 20 years and has been finding people with disabilities work, however feedback I have had from them is that there needs to be a willingness of the employer to employ the person in the first place.
The government needs to put in a lot of cash to get a system fully functional to actively turn these people’s lives around rather than throwing them on to the streets.
This will add pressure on the mental health system and emergency housing
It will only worsen the problem.