3News » Home
Full Story

Govt announces overhaul of child support system

11 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Two billion dollars is owed by liable parents and Revenue Minister Peter Dunne says the current system isn't working

Two billion dollars is owed by liable parents and Revenue Minister Peter Dunne says the current system isn't working

video
Thu, 02 Sep 2010 6:09p.m.

By Dan Parker

The Government has announced plans for an overhaul of the child support system; its main aim is to reduce $2 billion of debt owed by parents.

As a solo father Allan Harvey has first hand experience of what he describes as inequalities in the child support system.

Mr Harvey is also the national president of the Union of Fathers and excited about proposed changes.

“Well we are very pleased to see there's some thing on paper from Mr Dunne, because there have been promises for a long time,” Mr Harvey says. “So it really good to see there are recommendations and options to consider.”

Two billion dollars is owed by liable parents and Revenue Minister Peter Dunne says the current system isn't working.

“It's 20 years old, social conditions have changed. I think in some areas it's unfair, in some areas it is inflexible but it also simply doesn't take account of the times,” Mr Dunne says.

So this is his proposal:

  • Improving the tracking of runaway parents, here and abroad
  • Enforcing mandatory deductions from salaries and wages for outstanding payments
  • Relaxing financial penalties as an incentive to pay overdue payments - $1.4 billion of the $2 billion owed is made up by penalties

Mr Dunne says the way payments are calculated also needs to be adjusted; it is currently based on the number of nights a child spends with each parent.

“The question we are posing and want to look at is whether that is in effect too inflexible,” he says. “Whether there are many other factors that should be taken into account such as pre-school, after school care and various other types of care and attention.”

He also wants to see both parents' incomes considered when future payments are devised.

When the child support system was introduced in 1991 around 30 percent of custodial parents were in the work force; that figure is now sits at over 50 percent.

Submissions close at the end of October.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [11]

Mark
14 Feb 2011 6:45p.m.

The IRD is a law in its self, yes i am a father who went to court and got custody of my two sons.
It cost me tens of thousands of dollars and much more,many police raids on my home where my children were, as their mother called the police every day telling the police that i was a drug dealer.
I had interpoll investigating me , the works, but in the end i got custody of my boys and there was no everdence ever produce to prove my ex was telling the truth in court.
The judge was about to throw my ex and her friend in prison for making false claims in court and under oath.
Any way to cut a long story short, i never claimed child support, but my youngest son went for a weekend stay at his mums, and never returned, why his mum bribed him with play stations and tv , stereo systems etc, but only could have them if he stayed with her.
I approched the law and tried to get my son back but no they could not help me even when i had a court order which stated i had full custody of my boys, the IRD hit me with child support payments within two days, i told them to go to hell as i was the custodian of my son thru the courts , they said that they dont care what the court states, that its a matter where the child is???
Yes i had to pay, my son came back to me after 6 months and i returned the favour on my ex, and called the IRD to get child support,, it took a few weeks as the IRD wanted proof that my son was at home with me, now it only took my ex 1 day to get the IRD onto me, why does it take the IRD weeks and require proof that my son is with me before they accept he is and give me child support???
Any how just got a letter from the IRD and they want $4,000.00 off me as my assesment was wrong when my ex was getting child support??
These guys are dept collecters for the government and thats it we can not win, and the children suffer because of their blunders.

Joker
05 Sep 2010 2:55p.m.

If this is about paving the way for income-splitting that benefits the rich, I wouldn't call that fair. Less money should mean more support. Many NZ families live in poverty, this support would impact the wider community greatly, resulting in happier and healthier little kiwis. I do feel the system does need amends. Shared arrangements needs to be tweaked to make it equally fair and getting someone earning $500 week to pay $150 in child support, is just not right at all. Dropping the penalties is a good move. the father should help at least to pay half the childcare expenses.

Sandi
04 Sep 2010 9:49a.m.

Finally, separation and divorce are hard on all parties. Mom and Dad have it rough but it trickles down and on the kids. Not fair...even less fair is that divorce court is set up to be adversarial. Child support is also set up to be adversarial. Usually the mother has custody and the father has to give upwards of half his earnings. It's time for someone who can make good changes, changes that reflect both parents responsibility to the children. Take divorce out of the court system (adversarial) and put it into mediation. Hold both parents responsible for 50% of the cost of raising their children. Hold both parents responsible for all decisions regarding the best interests of the children. Hold both parents to a higher standard. They HAVE to get past the hurts of the failed marriage and remember to be friendly and caring towards the other parent so the children don't suffer the anxiety of conflicting parental emotions. Divorce should require post-divorce counselling to teach the parents how to get along and move forward as positive role models. Remove the money issues (make it 50/50) and most people can move forward happier.

Andrea
03 Sep 2010 10:25a.m.

The Children's Commissioner has today stated that children should be consulted over changes to Child Support payments. The world is going crazy when someone in this position makes a statement like this. Children should be allowed to be children. Stop dragging them into the mad life of an adult before they are ready for it. On the same day it is being proposed that the legal age of having to answer for crime should be 18. No wonder kids have no direction and are answerable to nobody. Too much power has been given to children and until this is reversed we are on a course to complete mayhem.

Solomon
03 Sep 2010 3:59a.m.

So Ratz...You must be Very Supportive of this bill then...It would do your Daughter a Great Justice as it intends to compare the Two parties income and capacity to contribute.

It will Certainly take nothing from your Daughter...and it is not about not enforcing things but doing it with consideration to those on both sides of the Coin.

And as can be clearly seen in the posts here...that you seem to miss.

Not ALL Men are BAr-Stewards. Women can be such too.

geno
02 Sep 2010 10:19p.m.

During my divorce a woman told me that I don't have a chance in divorce in court. She stated that because I'm a father I have no rights. Father's and legislaters, The women want equal rights where is ours. When a father walks into a divorce court room he should not be look down on and treated like a criminal. How can our sons and daughters be civil if there isn't a consistant act of fairness. we often get treated like animals, get diciplined when angry, a get over it when things are bad, and be happy with little rewards (visits every other weekend!). These laws make us fathers and our children suffer. How does that justify building a future for our children when this is what they get to look forward to!

Martin Ellis
02 Sep 2010 10:12p.m.

Well done TV3. Your sound bite on night news says... catching up with fathers running away owing child support. Typical poor reporting. This is the type of steriotypical comment from reporters who havn't a clue what the complex child support issue is about. That type of comment is both obsolete and sensationalist. You might as well be saying that all mothers a good cooks and do knitting. Because both statement are as about as current and relevant. Not exactly award wining journalism is it. Besides the minister of Revenue is obviosly concerened about the ability to actually retreive some payments... perhaps if the IRD wasn't so tough on parents more payments would have been paid in full. Maybe some revenue is better than none. Most of the outstanding amount is penalties.. no doubt compounded rediculously. Thanks TV3 for dumping on dads who had to make the best of being torn apart by IRD just because a relationship broke down.

Dave
02 Sep 2010 8:48p.m.

i think the idea of checking the custodial parents income when working out payments is a great idea, what if the custodial parent is earning $500k a year and the person making the payments is struggling to make payments after paying rent, food, petrol, bills, support wife at home etc.
Im all for the payments coming directly from your work income to enforce payment, but more factors need to be considered when working out liability

Tigerseye
02 Sep 2010 7:47p.m.

At long last! Once this has been sorted out the visitation rights need to be looked at.

Dean
02 Sep 2010 7:26p.m.

I think the review dosn't go far enough. Men I know including myself have had to draw down a part time second job pay secondary tax to make ends meet that leaves very little and then child support payments are adjusted upwards from thier main income. Part time work should be exempt from child support payments.
I have a mate who caught his wife having an affair, he left the home left the furniture just had his clothes the woman got custody he had nothing IRD hit him with child support of $1200 per month how did he survive, he didnt

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio