• Full Story

Govt guesswork not good enough - Labour

Print

Fri, 17 Feb 2012 10:14a.m.

Finance Minister Bill English (file)

Finance Minister Bill English (file)

Government guesswork on its budget forecasts shows it hasn't got its act together, Labour says.

Finance Minister Bill English on Thursday admitted a Treasury prediction that the partial sale of four state-owned power companies would raise $6 billion was "not even our best guess, it's just a guess".

The $6bn is midway between previous forecasts of between $5bn and $7bn and Mr English says Treasury had to pick a figure.

Labour's finance spokesman, David Parker, says that's not good enough.

"The whole thing is looking a bit ropey," he said on Friday.

"The numbers are all over the place, there have been three separate valuations."

Green Party co-leader Russel Norman says guesswork isn't the way to run the country's finances.

"They went into the election saying the figures were reasonably accurate and now they're saying it's guesswork."

Revenue Minister Peter Dunne says some previous predictions were more specific than they needed to be.

"But that's not my problem - I don't make them."

Prime Minister John Key is shrugging it off.

"Equity markets have been strong in the last few years despite global weakness, we're committed to the mixed ownership model," he said.

NZN

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

21 Feb 2012 01:04p.m.

smithy wrote:

I guess thats what you get when you put a farmer in charge of our economy.

17 Feb 2012 01:15p.m.

Ricardo wrote:

And labour sold how many billions of state assets? Give me a break. Labour couldn't be bright with 3000 volts up them!

17 Feb 2012 11:25a.m.

Chris wrote:

Revenue Minister Peter Dunne says some previous predictions were more specific than they needed to be. "But that's not my problem - I don't make them." That is Peter Dunne in a nutshell - all care and no responsibility! When are people going to wake up and kick out this mercenary?

17 Feb 2012 10:55a.m.

Ernst wrote:

So Labour think that they could predict the future of equity markets acurately? I don't think so looking at the collective lack of expertise that Labour can muster. English and Key have experience in this area name one labour MP with any.

17 Feb 2012 10:52a.m.

cherie wrote:

Yes the govt should make up numbers like Labour did while in power shouldnt it? They can only give a rough guess. How can they be bang on? Nit picking from desperate oppersition. The govt is being honest when it says it is not exactly sure.