Greens criticise China bid for Crafar Farms

Print

Thu, 25 Mar 2010 10:48a.m.

Chinese company Natural Dairy Holdings says it has agreed to buy $1.5 billion worth of New Zealand’s farms (file pic)

Chinese company Natural Dairy Holdings says it has agreed to buy $1.5 billion worth of New Zealand’s farms (file pic)

By Chris Whitworth

The Green Party is urging the Government to tighten “incredibly weak” foreign investment laws in New Zealand, after revelations of a Chinese company’s bid for farming assets worth $1.5 billion.  

The China Jin Hui Mining Corporation – recently renamed Natural Dairy Holdings Ltd - told the Hong Kong stock exchange yesterday that it had entered negotiations to buy $1.5 billion worth of New Zealand’s farms, livestock and milk production facilities.

The deal includes 22 farms that were owned by the Crafar family. The group of farms were placed in receivership last year after run ins with the law over dirty farming practices.  

Green Party co-leader Russel Norman says Natural Dairy’s proposal highlights the ease in which foreign companies can obtain mass amounts of New Zealand’s assets.  

“I think it is a clear demonstration of why we need to tighten up the foreign investment laws in New Zeeland – which are incredibly weak, much, much weaker than most countries on the planet,” he says. 

Labour is urging the Government to carefully consider the deal under a microscope before agreeing, but it already appears the purchase is in its final stages.

KordaMentha receiver, Michael Stiassny, says a rubber stamp from the Overseas Investment Office is virtually all that's required for the sale to go through.

“If the OIO says yes and we can finalise this agreement then this will happen,” he says.

Natural Dairy aims to export dairy products back to China, including infant formula and long-life milk.

Federated Farmers Dairy Chairman Lachlan McKenzie says the takeover will inevitably lead to a huge drop in New Zealand's income and standard of living.

“How are we going to sustain a first world living standard – our strategic assets is high calibre food and fibre production – the farmers in China are peasants,” he says.

The Chinese-based company told the Hong Kong stock exchange that the deal would be paid for in cash and through the issue of convertible bonds.

But business commentator Bernard Hickey is bringing into question the character of a key person involved in the deal.

Mr Hickey says May Wang, one of the main business people involved, owes hundreds of thousands to creditors after the failure of her property and hotel company, Dynasty Group.

“She’s already lost money for investors here in New Zealand and has a bunch of creditors on her tail,” he says.

“She is also likely to face charges from the company’s office next week in the district court.”

3 News

Watch this morning's interview with Fonterra’s chief executive Andrew Ferrier, as he talks to ASB Business about the Natural Dairy Holdings’ bid.

Listen to Bernard Hickey's full interview with Marcus Lush on RadioLIVE

 

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

26 Mar 2010 01:09a.m.

Rick wrote:

I can hardly believe it.

For once I actually agree with the Green party!

25 Mar 2010 08:26p.m.

Proud Kiwi wrote:

I as a Proud NewZealander think our country IS being systematically sold in more ways than we ordinary non-suspecting, over trusting kiwis will ever get to know.The likes of Winston Peters, who was a thorn, were equally systematically eased out of the Parliament so these vested interests could have a feild, sorry, FARM day!

25 Mar 2010 04:50p.m.

Lightseed wrote:

actually Michael you do know what is being put into Chinese food because it is tested and made sure that it meets the NZ standards if it is sold in NZ. I wonder if you hold up your same standards to NZ products, there have been quite a few foods and products that are NZ Made that have been recalled.

25 Mar 2010 04:30p.m.

Michael wrote:

I hope the Chinese don't get the frams I don't trust the Chinese at all you don't know what thay are puting in food so I DO NOT BUY ANY THING THAT IS MADE IN CHINA you don't know what in it.

25 Mar 2010 03:43p.m.

Jim wrote:

Neville
It is people like us who buy Chinese products due to our Leftist Govt making it un-economical for NZ businesses to compete. Look on the back of the next toy or clothing you willing buy for its maker and don't blame the Chinese!!!

25 Mar 2010 01:59p.m.

Neville wrote:

Why does TV3 ask for comments and when received not post them? Is it that TV3 does not want anything negative said about corrupt Chinese business practices or criminal contamination of food products?

25 Mar 2010 01:48p.m.

phil wrote:

There is something smelly about this company. Ten bucks says the deal will go nowhere...

25 Mar 2010 12:55p.m.

Fred wrote:

NZ govt & the OIO should look into this foreign investment carefully...quick money now could later affect NZ's dairy future. Do we trust this foreign investor to abide by our laws & food safety standards after what happened to the milk industry in China??? Do we in NZ trust the milk products that they will produce?? They are only using NZ's "safe & green" image so that they can sell to the Chinese market as people there no longer trust their own producers....wasn't it not long ago that some 'individuals' were buying baby formula in bulk from supermarkets to resell online to Chinese parents. This investor just has more money so going for bigger volume!!!!

25 Mar 2010 12:44p.m.

Neville wrote:

Chinese controlled dairy farms here in NZ? - You have got to be kidding. I can't think of a better and more certain way of buggering up our clean green image. Will the rest of the world remain interested in buying Fontera's products in the future. The corrupt Chinese have already deliberately stuffed Fontera in China. The Chinese are still lacing their milk products with chemicals. Admittedly they have shot some of the buggers to appease the world press but it's a practice that is clearly endemic and is still going on. That's not something we want to even contemplate happening here. If the Government can't see a major risk in all this then they need to speak to our major trading partners. Forget about a free trade deal with the Yanks. If the Fish and Game guys thought they had problems - boy, you ain't seen nothing yet! What the hell's wrong with this country? It's bad enough having sold our banking sector to the Aussies. Do we really want to stand around and watch our primary production sector assets get sold off as well by idiots that should know better.

25 Mar 2010 11:57a.m.

kathy wrote:

We did make a Free Trade deal with China, so what's the problem? Do we expect them to Tango on their own? So, now they show their hand(s) - we did invite them, did we not?? It was to be the great deal for NZ so, why have we hit the decks? Strange game..