3News » Home
Full Story

Greymouth Mayor supports sealing Pike River

5 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
The temperature is down now at the Pike River mine but at times it has been hotter than a crematorium (NZPA)

The temperature is down now at the Pike River mine but at times it has been hotter than a crematorium (NZPA)

video
Fri, 14 Jan 2011 6:29p.m.
By Jeff Hampton

Kathy Lintott lost her nephew Riki Keane in the Pike River Mine explosion. The family wants his body back and had pinned their hopes on a comment Prime Minister John Key made to relatives being bussed to the mine.

“He got on the bus and told us that whatever it costs, whatever it took, he promised he'd bring the boys home to their families,” she said

But Mr Key remembers it differently, and says the time has come for the mine to be sealed.

“I never promised anyone that I could get the bodies out. What I did promise is that we could do everything we can to get those bodies out and at the end of the day I believe that the Government has done that and the police have - they have my one hundred percent support"

The families are desperate for the recovery to continue and spokesman Bernie Monk says it is time the mine's receivers fronted up.

“They’ve got money there, they've got a mine that's worth money, I'm sure they've got insurance policies and they're just sitting back letting the Government do everything,” he says.

Mr Monk says the families were bewildered and taken aback by the police announcing their withdrawal from the recovery last evening, and Colin Smith, a lawyer offering advice to the families, agrees.

“It seems to me this decision has not been based on the current information because here we are in the last 2 days having some significant success, to the point that the mine is basically stable,” says Mr Smith.

The temperature is down now but at times the mine has been hotter than a crematorium. Greymouth Mayor Tony Kokshoorn is going along with the Prime Minister’s decision.

“At the end of the day we have to accept we can't get these bodies out and our men are lying up there for the foreseeable future,” he says.

3 News sampled opinion on the streets of Greymouth about the police decision and while most of the 20 people spoken to said the police had done their best, three felt strongly that they should carry on with the recovery effort.

3 News
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [5]

Mark Cummins
17 Jan 2011 12:24p.m.

Kim, thank you for your question about the CAFSCO mine fire fighting foam. It has been developed over a period of about twenty years in the USA. We have extinguished 8 mine fires. It has a complete government report published about our successful fire extinguishment of the Pinnacle mine fire, where we were called after an attempt to use the GAG had failed to inert the mine (same as Pike River mine). http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/mining/pubs/pdfs/tuone.pdf

After the water based foam has extinguished the fire, it simply soaks into the coal seam and evaporates away with no damage or even residue to clean up. In fact we can add bio-remediation microbes that are designed for emergency response organizations to use to clean up toxic by-products of coal combustion. The US Navy uses our foam to apply the latest warfare decon agents, the Michigan Agriculture Division has purchased our foam generators to control the H5N1 Avian Virus. This foam has been proven for many years for many special applications. It should have been used on this fire. I hope this is useful information and answers your question. Thanks again, Mark Cummins

Kim
16 Jan 2011 9:41p.m.

@Mark
I have had a look at the CAFSCO website and find it hard to believe you had no response to an offer of help.
I'm just curious though, How is the foam removed after the fire is out? And will this destroy any evidence that might be in the mine?

Mark Cummins
16 Jan 2011 5:10p.m.

This fire was especially depressing for us at CAFSCO Fire Control, USA. We felt a duty to help with such a tragic event, we offered free of charge to help them with a foam injection project but we could not get any response from the management. We have been involved with two previous coal mine fires where they chose to use the GAG jet engine to try to dilute the gases, to extinguish fires that had proceeded into the coal seams where the gas can't reach coal that is burning under a collapsed roof, and with ashes and subsidence conditions covering the burning coal. We were hoping they would accept our offer of showing them how to use their own manpower and equipment to create compressed fire fighting foam and how to use high pressure injection through the bore holes to fill the voids with wet soaking foam. The dense water based foam can seal the combustion area with a fire proof smothering foam mass. And at least cover the fallen miners bodies with the thermal protective blanket of foam to prolong the recovery time. They will now have serious environmental problems for many years. Sealing the mine is a bad choice. Now that it is no longer a recovery operation, We can offer to extinguish the fire with our own crews and equipment, but it will cost dearly after sealing it and it becomes a deep seated seam fire.

Ruth
16 Jan 2011 9:51a.m.

Mmm something is not right here Mr Kokshoorn was SO determined to get the bodies out - sooo determined to get answers, it seems to be that he just "rolled over" ... more to this story one feels...

Kim
15 Jan 2011 8:53a.m.

I wonder when Tony Kokshoorn will get the callup for Nationals back benches.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - One year after the Christchurch quake: Share your story
It is a year today since Christchurch's deadly February 22 quake.
Comments (20)