Hillary was 'insensitive about Everest' - photographer
Wed, 13 Jun 2012 9:47p.m.
An American photographer who has spent over 40 years working in Nepal has accused Western climbers including Sir Edmund Hillary of being insensitive to the old traditions of the mountain.
Jeff Botz, 64, a professional photographer from New Jersey, is supporting a campaign, long backed by China, for Mt Everest to be known by its traditional names of Sagarmatha in Nepalese or Chomolungma to the Tibetans, and to be treated as a sacred place.
"I've never really had much respect for him (Hillary)," Botz said.
"After he climbed the mountain - being the first person (to do so) - he was quoted as saying `we knocked the bastard off'.
"This is the same attitude that people have now. It's not like they're not having too much reverence for this mountain."
Botz said the old tradition of the world's highest peak (8,848m) being a spiritual pilgrimage is almost lost.
"This truly is a place of sacred significance."
Botz began photographing the Himalayan mountain range in 1973 and has been a frequent visitor since with a major photographic exhibit now open in Kathmandu.
He is highly critical of Western interpretations and understanding of the mountain dating back to Sir Edmund, who together with Nepalese Sherpa Tenzing Norgay, became the first to summit Everest in May 1953.
Hillary's apparent first words to lifelong friend George Lowe on returning from Everest's summit were: "Well George, we knocked the bastard off."
Botz says Hillary's attitude is symptomatic of attitudes of many of the 3,000 climbers who have reached the summit since then and the 20,000 visitors who travel to the base camps each year.
Climbing Everest was big business and it "desensitised people" who paid $US30,000-$US100,000.
"They had really large tents where people played ping pong and they had tents where they had internet connections 24 hours a day and movie tents. Their involvement in the mountains is really minimal."
Many were not fully fit to make the climb relying heavily on the Sherpa guides for support and oxygen, Botz said.
Post a Comment
Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide
(Won't be published)
14/06/2012 1:37:39 a.m.
david joblin wrote:
I would like to think that Jeff has been misqoted. Hillary's comment was a sportman's reaction to a gigantic accomplishment. His involvement with the Himalayan people subsequent to climbing Everest far outweighs anything that Jeff will ever accomplish. Hillary also spoke out against the commercialism of modern day Everest climbs. The two men actually have a lot in common hence my feeling that there has been a misquote somewhere.
13/06/2012 11:09:04 p.m.
Sounds like this dude has spent to much time on the miuntain.
13/06/2012 10:42:15 p.m.
What a load of tripe, as a Kiwi I think Sir Ed has always been over rated
yea he climed the mountain but had a sherper carry his bags. Colin Meads gets my vote for top of the heap Kiwi.
A crew member of a cruise ship who was seriously injured abo...
Tonight comes the Budget announcement you didn't hear yester...
The Police Commissioner Peter Marshall has threatened to dis...
There's been solid support from students here for the tough ...
Copyright © 2013 MediaWorks TV. All Rights Reserved.