3News » Home
Full Story

Homeopathic remedies ‘over-priced water’ - skeptics

32 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
The remedies are created by heavily diluting products from the plant, animal and mineral worlds

The remedies are created by heavily diluting products from the plant, animal and mineral worlds

video
Sat, 30 Jan 2010 6:13p.m.

By Juanita Copeland

The New Zealand Skeptics Society has launched an attack on the natural medicine practice of homeopathy.

As part of an international protest, the group staged a mass overdose – designed to prove the remedies are just over-priced water.

“This stuff is so diluted it’s the equivalent of putting a pinch of sugar into the Atlantic Ocean, giving it a darn good stir and staying ‘the Atlantic Ocean is thereby sweeter’,” says NZ Skeptics spokeswoman Vicki Hyde.

The remedies are created by heavily diluting products from the plant, animal and mineral worlds.

Homeopaths like Jill Wilby say despite the dilution there are still active ingredients.

“Research at the moment is saying there is an electro-magnetic component that is the active ingredient,” she says.

Skeptics claim any benefits have nothing to do with the remedies.

“We know the human body has a great capacity to heal itself – the homeopaths are right about that,” says Ms Hyde.

“However it will heal itself regardless of weather you take a homeopathic solution or plain water – they’re the same thing.”

Ms Wilby says the protest will not have any physical affect on the sceptics because they are not taking the remedies as they are designed to be taken.

“When we take a client’s case we give them a single remedy and monitor that – we don’t do a mass overdoes, and we don’t do lost of different remedies at once.”

Former homeopathy skeptic Megan Kennedy claims the remedies fixed her daughter’s range of complaints from insomnia to chronic headaches.

“Keep believing what you want to believe, but for us it has worked and I totally believe in [homeopathy] now.”

While Ms Kennedy is convinced, the sceptics involved in today’s protest don’t.

None of them claim to feel any different after their overdose.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [32]

Judy
05 Feb 2010 4:30p.m.

Homeopathy has repeatedly cured myself and my children of both acute and long-standing symptoms. I rely on my practitioner who(after four years full-time study) has been seeing patients for over twenty years and carefuly selects the medicine that we need by both observing us and questioning us at length. Each medicine must be precribed for the individual symptoms and that is when Homeopathy really shines-when in the hands of an experienced practitioner. I suggest that the skeptics "get a life" and stop interfering with the rights of New Zealanders to seek help where they choose. Perhaps as a first step they could visit one of the many Doctors who practise Homeopathy as this may allay their fears and prejudices.

Rachel
05 Feb 2010 11:25a.m.

Do any of the sceptics out there have a chronic health condition or something going on with them that they would prefer not to have to deal with? Wouldn't a good experiment be for one of them to go to a homeopath, take the treatment - and see whether it works or not?? Rather than taking doses for no reason whatsoever? The sceptic could go along and tell themselves 'it won't work, it won't work' - and see whether it still does?

Angela Hair
05 Feb 2010 10:43a.m.

The test for homeopathy is in the results and nowhere better to see this than in the 1918 influenza epidemic. In Oct 1918 Dr H.A.Roberts (USA) was sent on transport ship with 2000 men. On the way over the influenza epidemic started with 81 cases. All recovered. This ship was the only one in convoy of 9 to have this record. “I was the only homeopathic surgeon on those 9 ships. One ship…which carried 4000 troops, lost 31 on the way over.” Dr McCann (USA) treated 1000 cases of influenza and reported no losses. “ I want no credit given to me for these results. It is only another undeniable testimony of the efficacy of homeopathic drugs carefully administered” he writes. These quotes and other real life experiences of healing with homeopathy can we found on the New Zealand Council of Homeopaths website. www.homeopathy.co.nz Extraordinary results can be achieved through homeopathic treatment. Try it.

Richard
03 Feb 2010 6:57p.m.

I love how the homeopaths shift the goalposts - now it only works if you use it as it's 'designed to be taken' whereas, before the protest, they use to warn against overdosing.

Craig Young
01 Feb 2010 3:50p.m.

I agree with the Skeptics. I'd far rather trust evidence-based medicine to something that is only anecdotal and may be attributable to other causes in cases where it has, apparently, 'worked.'

Phil
01 Feb 2010 11:47a.m.

Glen, I was addressing several points in previous posts. If you read them you will understand.

Sentinel
01 Feb 2010 9:15a.m.

"le" If they didn't know anything about Homeopathy, why would they be confident that an "overdose" is safe? Users don't know anything about it - that's why they "believe" in it. If there arn't any side effects (like in taking an overdose) there is no effect either - it's H2O.... WATER!

le
31 Jan 2010 10:46p.m.

The protest group just looked like a bunch of idiots who obviously don't know much about homeopathy! It's a shame, their loss really.

Simon Gemmill
31 Jan 2010 10:33p.m.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy Read and enjoy. :)

Fraser Jones
31 Jan 2010 9:19p.m.

Why are people so offended when lab tests confirm there's nothing other than water in homeopathy? Why is exposing rip off artists bad? Wikipedia supports the Skeptics: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy The people that argue: so what if it's fake, if it makes you feel better may also believe that it doesn't matter if the spaceship lands on Mars, as long as you believe it did! :) Go NZ Skeptics.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion