3News » Home

How does Japan view the issue of whaling?

A mock whale meat tin in London A mock whale meat tin in London
Fri, 28 May 2010 1:30p.m.

Opinion by Melissa Davies

I was offered the chance to eat whale this evening. 

It’s not an opportunity I was excited to receive, but contrary to common perception, nor is it an opportunity that many Japanese would accept.

An English reporter based here in Tokyo told me there is very little coverage of whaling stories, and therefore the Japanese do not understand the extent to which it exists and the conservation issues that arise. 

While a lack of coverage certainly seems to be true, I find the latter hard to accept. 

I have not spoken to a single Japanese person who has said they’re not concerned about the conservation of Whales. Their concern though, is equally about the conservation of culture. 

One woman told me that the consumption of whale meat in Japan originated post World War II as a necessary protein source. Now, it is mostly only eaten by the older generation who were brought up on it.

You will not find whale meat in the supermarket aisles next to the milk and bread. If you want to find whale meat in Japan you have to go searching.

The protesters outside the Pete Bethune trial carried banners with slogans saying Japanese food customs must be protected from the West.  

The relatively small but vocal group have an efficient protesting regime. They turned up at 8am as the public (but I imagine more importantly to them – the media) were arriving at court. 

They had a captive audience for the two hours until the trial began, but as soon as the cameras were gone so too were the protesters.  

They are protesters protesting about another man’s protest. 

However, it is not simply the act of protest that the Japanese condemn in the matter of Pete Bethune.

Several people have told me their concern is over the manner in which Sea Shepherd work. They think it is too aggressive.

Sea Shepherd on the other hand says Bethune’s actions have led to a successful reduction in the number of whales caught this season. The whalers fell short of their quota by 428 whales.

In 1986 Japan agreed to a global moratorium to abandon commercial whaling but it still hunts under a research programme agreement. The whales are then sold on the commercial market.

The owner of a restaurant that serves whale meat told me they never have any issue with lack of supply.

He says they serve 40 different whale meat dishes and use all parts of the whale,

from the brain to the tail.  

I was offered the chance to eat whale this evening.. but I declined that offer.

 

3 News reporter Melissa Davis travels throughout Europe and the UK covering key news events.

 

This blog offers an insight into the stories playing out in front of her camera.

 

Follow Melissa Davies on Twitter

Comments [12]

Dan
02 Jun 2010 09:56p.m.

Katrina it is also a matter of principle not to talk when you're no better morally than the person you judge. That makes you a hypocrite. We slaughter mammals too and pigs are in fact very intelligent too. As for conservation, the population of Antarctic Minke Whales is in excess of 600,000. Japan kills just over 500 a year. Conservation is not an issue and even if it were it is not a moral issue. Who cares if something becomes extinct? We only care because we don't get to see that particular animal anymore.

annie
31 May 2010 04:15p.m.

The article is wrong about not finding it in the supermarket - it's there, especially out of the main centre city Tokyo supermarkets. Looks like meat, tastes like fish.

Kaitiaki
31 May 2010 11:01a.m.

david jim brian and co

Offer them kina's (sea urchins) instead, I have, and bugger me they eat them too!!!!!!Nothings sacred in the sea anymore. As Kaitiaki my job is to make sure they dont take them all. KIA KAHA KIA MANA. (BE STRONG, STAND UP FOR WHAT YOU BELIEVE IN)

How about your granma! Little Red Riding HOOD.

Bug
28 May 2010 05:54p.m.

Culture? Please! They learnt the modern hunting style, using tools and techniques imported from Norway, and now do so, many thousands of miles from where their ancestors hunted, for Nationwide distribution (as opposed to localized fishing villages).

AnimuX
28 May 2010 05:31p.m.

The anti-Bethune protesters mentioned in this article are of the conservative Tokyo citizens’ group Shuken Kaifuku wo Mezasu Kai (The Society to Seek Restoration of Sovereignty). They're also known for denying Japan's war crimes concerning "comfort women" (like holocaust deniers they've called it lies of western anti-Japanese groups). They've also conducted general anti-foreigner protests, supported whaling, attempted to block "The Cove" from being shown in Japan and have openly approved of domestic violence against women. Just google this group and learn about the kind of people that do support whaling in Japan.

cyril
28 May 2010 04:10p.m.

You can be concerned about the conservation of whales and still eat them. you dont have to have a total moratoreaum on something to comserve the species they just need to be sustainably harvested.

John
28 May 2010 03:23p.m.

Perhaps it's worse to abandon your principles?

LB
28 May 2010 03:22p.m.

Brian,
Nah, Japanese tend to be very flexible when it comes to offering food to foreigners because they understand we may not be used to it. I worked at Japanese Hot Spring resort the head chef would offer me different kinds of food but didnt mind if i turned him down and my host family i stayed with in school was the same.

katrina
28 May 2010 03:06p.m.

Brian it is a matter of principle. How can they say they are catching it for research purposes then openly advertise it for sale to eat? They are just lying.
Where is the evidence of their research. Where is their documentation?
How can they say they need to protect their culture when they also say they started eating it post World war 2 that is too recent to be cultural.
What a crock.
Boycott Japanese products - no more sushi

david
28 May 2010 02:40p.m.

You should have tried it, I have and it's great.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Blogs