Immigrant business owner booted out of NZ

Print

Thu, 21 Apr 2011 7:00p.m.

Martyn Payne

Martyn Payne

Six years ago Martyn Payne moved to New Zealand. He came on an entrepreneur's visa, had money and was keen to spend it here.

He says he's put about $700,000 into his business. He chose Kapiro in the far north, bought a rundown garage and turned it into a thriving business, employing locals.

He brought with him his young son, and later his daughter and grandchildren followed, but now, six years on, Mr Payne's being deported.

"The man came to tell me I’ve got to leave - he did give me a couple of weeks, but he did say, 'You will be able to visit in six months - but sponsored by someone.' It does feel like I’m being treated like a criminal," says Mr Payne.

"That leaves a very bad taste in my mouth."

His son has already left, and his daughter has no choice but to stay. She has children here now, and will run the family business on her own.

She's not sure how she will cope – she says she can't even change a spark plug.

Mr Payne is the fix it man, the guy the community relies on, and he is being taken away from his most important role - head of his family. But why?

A medical examination six years ago revealed Mr Payne had a heart issue. Immigration believes he might require healthcare in the future, and it's not prepared to pay, so Mr Payne is being deported.

He had an operation in England and passed the test.

“The operation was a success - I got a letter from the specialist saying I was fully recovered,” Mr Payne said.

But four years later the Department of Immigration requested another medical

"They asked me to have another test. I had a fibrillation, which means the heart beat is irregular, which means I have to have a jump start."

He disagreed with the findings, and went to a doctor who specialises in heart disease. Dr Brendon Wong said although Mr Payne has a dilated impaired heart muscle, he is coping well.

Mr Payne says he's prepared to pay for follow-up tests, but there is no evidence he will need heart surgery in the future.

Despite the support of thousands of locals it seems Mr Payne has lost the battle to stay. He flies out of the country on Saturday leaving behind everything he owns - more importantly his daughter and seven grandchildren.

It will be six months before he is able to even return for a visit.

Local MPs John Carter and Shane Jones have lobbied Minister Kate Wilkinson on Mr Payne's behalf with no success.

His community staunchly stands behind him.

"Every customer comes in saying, 'How is it going?', and it's like you almost need a script. You know that they care… It's like one big, huge family," Mr Payne said.

It's a family that will be torn apart this weekend, but all the while the man from Sussex, looking for a life in Kapiro, can still share a joke or two.

"I've had three offers of marriage - its absolutely true! I said a) I’m already married and b) it doesn't work like that. The local iwi at Te Tii offered to take me into their family… I didn't think it would take any sway with Immigration - but humbling to say the least."

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

05 Jun 2011 06:16p.m.

Tim wrote:

My family is also in NZ on a "Long Term Business VISA" but I ran into health problems just after we arrived a couple of years ago. Because it was cancer, they want me to be clear for 5 years before we become residents. I am clear but need to wait another 3 years. This, in turn, threatens my 17 -year-old son's medical studies at university because without residency, we would have to pay the prohibitive overseas student fees. It seems to me that health issues should not come into the Long Term Business VISA. (Is it like this in other countries?) Could we not fight for a policy change? What is the best way to lobby for change? Has anyone considered some sort of petition - maybe by email? There must be enough public opinion to get things changed in a democracy, isn't there?

10 May 2011 10:46p.m.

Peepo wrote:

how come people with criminal records are allowed with hardly any problems, and a man that has only been an asset is being kicked out. He is supporting himself and giving people work, not like others that come here and go on benefits - that is whats draining NZ, not the hard working people, but the people who are on benefits without a valid reason. (although there are many who have a valid reason, i think there are more that dont)

10 May 2011 03:12p.m.

TA wrote:

This makes me so sad .. this guy came here over 6 years ago and has invested hundreads of thousands of dollars in our country and his community and has clearly made a difference. Rural communities struggle as it is and you take away an employment pipeline like this if this daughter is unable to continue the business alone. When we have growing numbers of people on benefit who have no intention of ever working you would think we would support good honest hardworking guys like this it just doesn't make sense to me and doesnt make me proud to be a new zealander. Decisions like this just make it harder to attract the skilled migrants we need in this country why would they sell up in the uk move here if there is a risk they could be booted out six years down the line? common sense should prevail but quite often its sad to see the politicians just dig their heels in and never admit they have stuffed up. lets hope someone sees sense and sorts this mess out.

09 May 2011 04:52p.m.

hilda ogden wrote:

come on nz lets sack kate wilkinson the national mp that is a heartless selfish person.
she won't get our votes as we will be voting labour ,a caring party.

09 May 2011 09:04a.m.

john Hartley wrote:

Its disgusting that Martin comes here in good faith and builds up a business that was run down invests in new equipment pays tax GST over 6 years and is then booted out of the country. This does not make me proud to be a Newzealander. Take another look at this Immigration you have it wrong !!

08 May 2011 04:47p.m.

Adrian wrote:

This is not the first instance of this sort of thing happening. I have heard of many people, British, American, Canadian and South African that come over to NZ, bring their money and skill only to be shown the door at massive cost to themselves. My advise to any friends and family that ask me about moving to NZ....dont bother. Go straight for Australia, if better value for your investment. NZ is just not worth the effort. My only regrets about coming to NZ, was that I didn't take up the offer to go to Australia in the first place

06 May 2011 10:51a.m.

Bob Johnson wrote:

I for one am very disappointed with the New Zealand Minister of Immigration for appearing very weak when your interviewer tried to obtain comment about poor Martyn Paynes situation being booted out the country for no fault of his own, she is unable to defend her departments actions. Looks to me John Key needs to have a word in her ear-, the money over run by Government seems somewhat a joke with recent over spending in the millions. Money is also being given from our purse to support a so called radicle who identifies himself with Bin Laden. Martyn Payne , I for one feel deeply for you and trust Kate Wilkinson wakes up to what Kiwis are deeply upset about! Thanks again 3 News without you we would not know what is happening with Government policy.

05 May 2011 10:29p.m.

Philip Seccombe wrote:

Hi Nicola, Just read your post, not sure if you will ever see this but this f****in sucks! This is utter bulls**** and I feel so sorry for you! This is just not right! He's moved here, he's paying taxes, he's brought 8 people here who will be paying taxes and we thank him by sending him back where he came from!? He's not sitting on the dole and being a bum living off tax payer money, he's making money and we're just going to throw him away!? WTF!! This ain't right

05 May 2011 07:33p.m.

Vineet Nirmal wrote:

hay hay hay what you guys are doing.. Requesting Immigration New Zealand... I treat them a real terrorist. They have no shame, no emotions & no humanity. I am truly with Mr. Martyn Payne and his family.

28 Apr 2011 07:58p.m.

Gary and Sarah Cox wrote:

Dear New zealand,
I am embarrassed and ashamed that you have not looked at the Paynes case as people rather than a number.There has do be room in the INZ to look at individual cases. I pay taxes for a lot of people that do not a lot, claim benefit, and drain the system. Im sure even if Martin had to have some medical treatment at the expense of the tax payer, no one would mind as he has already contributed to NZ and would continue to do so, if he was able to stay. I am a customer and a neighbour of the Kapiro Garage, the business is friendly and has great service. Martyn Payne should be able to stay and continue to contribute to NZ as he has done for the last six years.