3News » Home
Full Story

Is 5c too much to pay for a plastic bag?

9 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA

Fri, 04 Sep 2009 12:00a.m.
Consumer resistance to paying for plastic bags has spread north, with New World and Four Square supermarkets in the upper North Island today removing a 5c charge.

The move follows the axing of the same fee at the same supermarkets in the lower North Island three days ago.

It comes just four weeks after the stores, which are part of the Foodstuffs chain, introduced the levy in an attempt to get people to reduce their reliance on plastic bags.

Foodstuffs Auckland's general manager of retail sales and performance, Murray Jordan, said the charge had been removed in response to customer feedback.

"Our customers have spoken and we have listened," he said.

"Our owner operators, who know their customers, have been receiving a lot of feedback on the floor and this feedback has been confirmed by a customer survey."

Mr Jordan said there had been an "exceptional increase" in people using reusable bags and Foodstuffs would continue to put measures in place that recognised those customers.

However, the 5c levy is remaining at New World and Four Square supermarkets in the South Island.

Foodstuffs South Island's general manager for retail operations, Alan Malcolmson, said there had been great support from customers and plastic bag use had dropped 60 percent over the past month.

As a result of the fee, $50,000 would be donated to five South Island environmental projects identified by the Department of Conservation.

"This is just the first of what we envisage will be ongoing support for environmental projects," Mr Malcolmson said.

"It's a win-win for the environment - bags being saved and projects benefiting."

Mr Malcolmson said a levy introduced in Ireland in 2002 had cut plastic bag usage by 90 per cent, while Coles in Australia had indicated they were about to start charging as well.

NZPA
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [9]

Otaraia
10 Sep 2009 6:17p.m.

Personally I believe the supermarkets should be offering a discount if you bring your own bags not charging a penalty price.

The money saved goes directly to their bottom line. I confess to being very sceptical that the supoermarkets will donate any money saved to charity.

MH
07 Sep 2009 5:37a.m.

Hi Guys, currently €.22c for a plastic bag in Ireland (.44c nzd).Just buy a reusable bag as we all do over here. It's better for the environment. Shops also do brown paper bags for free if you haven't brought your reusable option.

Brainy guy
04 Sep 2009 6:43p.m.

I take it none of you shop at Pak n save?

Stef
04 Sep 2009 3:21p.m.

Hey guys, This is a worthy debate, but I think the supermarket chains have gone about this slightly the wrong way. How about the idea of introducing a positive reinforcement for bringing re-usable bags to the store? Here in the US, one major chain offers a raffle ticket every time you do this. The prize is a $200 grocery voucher, I think. A punitive measure for using the supermarket's bags sends the wrong message. Although, at least consumers can be grateful they can still get a bag at all, not like in some European countries (such as Germany)!

Kai
04 Sep 2009 1:19p.m.

If they want to save the environment, they should offer a disposable paper bag option. If I would be asked I would prefer them. But it's not about environment, it's about making money, no matter if it goes to the shop or to to any (N)GO.

Dear Hey John
04 Sep 2009 12:59p.m.

Which Supermarket chain did you say you worked for? At the end of the day, the customer will decide where they want to spend their hard earned money.

Hey John
04 Sep 2009 12:41p.m.

You do realise companies exist to make a profit, right? And you do realise that the proceeds from sales of bags go to environmental causes, not the company's coffers, right? No, you don't? It shows in your ill-informed rant.

Oli
04 Sep 2009 12:35p.m.

Well, get real NZ!!! This has been standard practice in Europe for years and it costs Euro.10 / bag. Nobody grumbles and there isn't the mess.
Credit cards the same...it's the customer that wants to pay with a card....not the retailer unless the retailer can claim the cost back. In MOST of the the work CASH IS still KING.

John
04 Sep 2009 12:14p.m.

Why should the customer be paying for bags in the first place? It certainly does not cost 5 cents a bag to manufacture, and if it is, a green issue then make the bags from biodegradable material. I see this as another example of big business tagging their customers with what is clearly a business cost. It will be very interesting to see consumers responses when business try to pass on business related credit card charges to their customers. Don’t forget each cardholder pays an annual fee to the institution that issued the card, those same institutions charge retail outlets a fee as well, and now the retailers want to pass this on to the card user! I think it would be great to see a large move back to cash. I for one will be moving that way.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - What changes would you make to MMP?
The Govt and lobby groups are urging people to have their say on
Comments (4)