Judge proposes changes to help mental health sufferers

Print

Thu, 19 Nov 2009 6:06p.m.

Principal Family Court Judge, Peter Boshier

Principal Family Court Judge, Peter Boshier

By Charlotte Tonkin

The head of the Family Court says alarming numbers of people who go through the court commit suicide, and until the court system communicates better with mental health organisations - more will take their own lives and the lives of others.

Principal Family Court Judge, Peter Boshier says the number of suicides by people involved in Family Court cases is heartbreaking.

“Quite often we get told someone is so upset and distraught they feel like killing themselves, at the moment there's not a lot we do about it,” he says.

Over 12 months, Judge Boshier says there were four homicide deaths and 18 deaths which were suspected suicides.

Of the 18 suspected suicides, 41 percent had been involved in family violence proceedings.

Addressing a group at the front line of family violence, Judge Boshier said he wants New Zealand to follow Australia’s lead and have a mental health awareness scheme within the Family Court.

The new practice would mean the court could refer vulnerable people directly to mental health agencies.

Each year, family violence costs New Zealand $63 million.

Head of Women's Refuge Heather Henare says she is not convinced the proposed protocols are the way to fill the gaps in the system.

“How are we going to convince the Ministry of Health to then put in another system or layer of people,’ she says.

“Maybe it's about training the people we have on mental health assessment.”

Judge Boshier says the necessary links between the courts and mental health organisations could be put in place immediately, but it's being thwarted by a lack of open communication.

“We have this mentality here, often because of supposed privacy that we don't talk to each other,” he says.

“So we have various cases in which a number of agencies all know something but they don't tell others.”

Judge Boshier warns that every day of inaction will lead to fatal consequences.

3 News
 

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

12 May 2011 10:55p.m.

paul zentveld wrote:

thanks julie,because of the gutless talking inaction of family court judges the mother took off ignored the court order .with papers served the judge said i had done nothing wrong the mother a drama queen .this hurt her so muchshe done a runner .my daughter chloe grew up without her dad i paid all my child support .now mygirl hates me for not being there for her .so sad .i luv my girl 150%,always have but she not listening thank you invercargill family court for not doing your job .you should think of the childs rights firstly were was my girls .none and the govts departments hiding under the imformation act ,so cool ,thank you all so much ,and this is the system ,so good.too late now shes 18 0212123665.

23 Jan 2010 02:08a.m.

Julie wrote:

Childrens lawyers are a joke. I got my child(9yrs)all the Family Court brochures on what to expect and a dvd. She was to be asked her feelings on the lifting of a protection order from her father that she doesn't know. THe lawyer JP arrived at my home and was rude and obnoxious. She took my daughter for a walk, took cellphone calls and no notes. She briefly covered the Protection Order issue and launched into my child meeting her father. My child was very upset about this and on arriving back asked was that my lawyer or my fathers. We complained immediately to the court, my child said she would never speak to her again and hasn't because she lied in her report and 9 months later the court has ignored my child, JP is still being paid, for what I don't know as she has not had the ability to discuss her concerns with a lawyer. She asked to see the judge and he refused her. Now the Judge has said he will lift the order and he's expecting JP to tell her why it's a good idea.
These people have no regard for the feelings of the child that they purport to have the best interests of at heart.
The judge was sarcastic and abusive and now if I want the court transcript or Judges notes to prove it, I have to give HIM a reason. Yep this is Justice.

23 Nov 2009 12:36a.m.

Jan.. wrote:

I don't have many lawyers, but my own law people where I achieved and maintained most of my learning and knowledge from..
It would be a very dissapointed error if our country lawyers and judges were or are the master piece number one target in terrorisim..
Our country is in a big mess, what is Mr. Key is going to do about the safety and health of our people and our country..
The people of the country needs some explanations and answer from our Priminster to why all these crimes seemed to be an on-going thing without solving the problem..

20 Nov 2009 09:15a.m.

Tracy wrote:

Judge Boshier should have a good look at the process within the family court and the lawyers who are at the coal face of it. Lawyers rape families of everything they own which is hardly anything anyway then represent them in bankruptcy proceedings. They drag out proceedings for their own money purposes and rip our legal aid system off. They allow clients to "hop" between lawyers to delay proceedings. They lie to Judges because after all a Judge can only act on what lawyers say. Children's lawyers are a joke - they do not genuinely care about the children. They continually subject children to abuse through the family court, they have the power to stop CYFS from carrying out investigations of child abuse and they file false reports to the court to deceive the judges into thinking their services are required for years and years. Three months maximum for all cases to be done and dusted so people can get on with their lives rather than relive the abuse they have left. Judge Boshier would find real value in setting up a focus group consisting of real people that have survived proceedings or still going through proceedings. I know of one case where it took a woman three years to get a protection order through the family court. I was told by lawyers that family court wont help or make people responsible for their bad and abusive behaviour so if lawyers believe that what hope is their for families.