Jury struggles to convict Burton for attempted murder

Print

Thu, 12 Nov 2009 5:54p.m.

Graeme Burton

Graeme Burton

By Michael Morrah

One of the country's most notorious murderers has been found guilty of trying again, this time inside Paremoremo jail.

Graeme Burton used a steel rod to stab a Headhunters gang associate, who almost died in the attack – but the jury clearly wrestled with its decision.

Burton has more than 100 previous convictions, and police say the 38-year-old had nothing to lose when he attacked a fellow inmate.

His victim was Dwayne Marsh, who was in the same wing as Burton in the country's highest security prison.

CCTV footage of the attack showed Burton hobbling down a landing on his artificial leg, chasing Marsh and then stabbing him seven times with a sharpened metal rod.

It is thought Burton made the weapon from part of a medical trolley.

Crown prosecutor Deb Bell told the court that one of the blows to Marsh's chest was two to three centimetres deep. The steel rod went through his ribs and pierced his heart. She says Burton had intended to not just harm Marsh, but to kill him.

But the jury clearly struggled to convict Burton, taking more than 12 hours to deliver a verdict.

Burton was jailed for the murder of Wainuiomata man Karl Kuchenbecker, who he shot while on parole for another murder. Burton also injured two mountain bikers during his rampage. He was only stopped when police shot him in the leg.

"I don't think we've seen the worst of Burton yet," says Garth McVicar of lobby group the Sensible Sentencing Trust.

Despite his violent background, Burton's lawyer says his client has been pleasant to deal with.

"He's perfectly lucid and rational, and has been one of the easiest clients to deal with, I suppose," says Peter Tomlinson. "I didn't know what he was like before, so I'm not surprised."

Burton got 26 years for Kuchenbecker's murder and he will again be placed before a judge for sentencing next month.

3 News
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

21 Feb 2010 03:27p.m.

luke wrote:

Dwayne Marsh is not a murderer. But Graeme Burton is. I think Burton is just entertaining himself, laughing at the rest of this country. He considers us all to be working for him and he is right. We pay for his leg, his food, his shelter and how does he repay this... He makes us pay for heart surgeons to fix up another inmates heart. There are honest hardworking tax paying citizens waiting on health system waiting lists. He needs to be seriously restricted and given the bare minimum (No leg & no freedom).

13 Nov 2009 10:07a.m.

no name wrote:

If Burton had any self control the day he killed Karl and had actually killed his intended victim on that day - instead of an innocent person in the wrong place at the wrong time - trust me, most of Wainuiomata and Hutt Valley would have been jumping for joy.

13 Nov 2009 12:50a.m.

cannibal wrote:

yo cyril...im glad youre not in charge of making our laws you heartless moron. piss off to another country if you dont like the way we do things...that would be doing our country more of a favour tough guy.

12 Nov 2009 11:56p.m.

annon. wrote:

Take away his plastic leg. Why the hell should he have it? He's taken away the lives of others. He thinks he's a man. He's a caged monkey. He's going to find himself in few years time to be unable to hop away fast enough. He'll be someones bitch then.

12 Nov 2009 10:36p.m.

cyril wrote:

He has always been lucid and rational. How do you think he got out on parol. He would have done the country a favor if he had killed Marsh. Ot doesnt matter whether he is found guilty or not as the law cant do any more to him unless they bring in the death penalty and that wint happen in this soft ass country.