3News » Home
Full Story

Key labels scientists' climate change demands 'too ambitious'

17 comments | Post Comment Email Print Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Tue, 18 Aug 2009 6:25p.m.
By Samantha Hayes

Greenpeace are upping the pressure on Prime Minister John Key with a hand-delivered message on climate change - and it is his hand they are using.

Wearing a blue cast, like the one Mr Key had earlier this year, Greenpeace ambassadors Lucy Lawless and Keisha Castle-Hughes have been out gathering campaign signatures.

Mr Key recently said Castle-Hughes should "stick to acting", but apologised at the weekend. Wearing a blue cast, Castle-Hughes said Mr Key should now be signing world leaders up to her cause.

"Earlier in the year when John Key broke his arm he turned it into quite a positive thing, and that's what we're doing," says Castle-Hughes.

Mr Key broke his arm leaving a stage. Now Greenpeace fear he is stumbling again - this time on the world stage.

Last week the Government announced a 10-to-20 percent target reduction of carbon emissions from 1990 levels by 2020. But Greenpeace argue that is not even on the bottom rung of what climate scientists say is needed - they want 40 percent.

"I heard that at the meeting when New Zealand announced its target - people would clap for other countries - there was silence," says climate scientist Jim Salinger.

"The people in New Zealand have gotta speak up," says Lawless.

There was nothing quiet about Lawless though, from the flame-coloured hair fresh from the Spartacus set, to the Warrior Princess challenge.

"The world leaders are going to be there, he's representing us, what do we want him to say?" she asks.

Mr Key told 3 News he has got the message, but his decision is already cast in more than plaster.

"I won't be signing on myself," he says. "I've made it quite clear that New Zealand can achieve a 10, maybe 20 percent reduction by 2020, but I think 40 percent is way too ambitious."

He has however apologised to Castle-Hughes for that "stick to acting" comment.

"It was nice to have a chat and I apologised if she took any offence, and she made it quite clear that she hadn't."

"He did apologise and it was totally fine, because there were no hard feelings," says Castle-Hughes. "I looked at it quite positively and it gave me an opportunity to talk about the campaign again."

A campaign that will climax in Copenhagen in a few months time when Mr Key joins other world leaders to decide life after the Kyoto Protocol.

Greenpeace says that if the US and Europe take an ambitious stance on climate change, then New Zealand will have to fall into line to protect our trade and clean and green image.

Until then the star campaigners plan to pursue Mr Key relentlessly with their ever-growing cast.

3 News

Comments [17]

Rebecca Sharp
27 Aug 2009 12:48p.m.

Jim....
I can't get my head around the fact that humans believe they are superior to other forms of life on this planet. The world is very unbalanced and I worry about the future. We must live with more respect for animals and mankind alike. If the millions of us are wrong worrying about climate change then I will be very glad and relieved indeed. But don't you think we better at least be safe than sorry? I don't want the world to reach the point of regret about climate change because then it will be too late.
I don't believe money has anything to do with the need to look afer this planet and we must do it now.
I personally live as green a life as I can.
I use clean renewable energy (meridian).
My family eat oganically (fair trade where possible)which is better for our health, the environment and famer workers health.
I buy as much recycled clothing and products that I can to meet our needs.
I only use eco friendly cleaning and laundry producys (some I make myself).
I walk to where I need to go as much as I can and and my partner carpools to work most days.
I use eco-friendly paper.I use reuseable shopping bags.
Our wedding next year is also eco- friendly.
I am an active member of greenpeace.
Maybe you should have a go at being kinder to the environment too.

Jim
27 Aug 2009 10:42a.m.

Rebecca
It appears that you have not understood the reason for any food shortages etc... We have 6billion people on this planet now, to where as at the beginning of the 20th century we were lucky to have 600 million. Do idealistic greenies think that food is endless as our population sores toward 10billion within the next 20 years?
We need to have industries to feed, clothe and house the masses, unless the true aim of the green brigade is to send us back into the pre- Egyptian times when we were hunting on the plains with Hyenas and Lions etc...
The human race is unable to go back to those days.
Take a look at these greens in the picture, they are flying, driving etc and telling us not to. How many of them use modes of transport, live in plush apartments, have expensive clothing (all needing heavy industry to make) while they hypocritically tell us we are bad.
It is the old do as I say and not as I do, duhhh!!!

saty
26 Aug 2009 10:07p.m.

impending doomsday....why should newzealand cut its emissions by 40% when other countries such as china pollute heavily ...if we cut out emissions we are the losers financially and china keeps polluting ...good fun

Rebecca Sharp
26 Aug 2009 7:22p.m.

I am sick to death of you people who think that you can carry on anyway you like, abusing our only earth and not caring about the consequences! Elephants are already suffering and dying because our our ignorant behaviour. Climate change is already here. There is less rain falling on the african plains and its falling less frequently. Which means less food is growing for the magnificent animals to eat. So they are being forced to find food wherever they can. They are eating humans crops (alot more are taking up wild areas than ever before, I might add) and these innocent animals are being cruelly spared and they die horrible, awful, sad deaths.This is everyones problem. And this is only one tiny part of the climate change problem that is very real. I ask you, what state do you want your children and grandchildren to inherit our earth in?????????

Jim
25 Aug 2009 8:34a.m.

Well said Trevor

Trevor
24 Aug 2009 4:24p.m.

Has anyone acutally thought about what 40% reduction means? If we all cut back our breathing, eating, travel by 40% even that wouldn't be enough because alot of greenhouse gases naturaly are released by the land, are you going to try and cut this back by 40% as well? We could cover up 40% of nz with lots of touploins. What about the sea clouds formed by water vapour (a well known dominant grrenhouse gas) are you going to try and cut this back by how much? Anybody who supports this trash is looney and should at least show us by leading the way! Lets face it, the larger your carbon footprint, the greater your quality of life, and the last people interested in cutting their carbon footprint will be all the one's currently promoting it. Yeah right Lucy, all the jetsetting you do round the world in one year is greater than 2500 of us that choose to stay home, are you doing your bit and leading the way. Get real.

Min
23 Aug 2009 1:54p.m.

C'mon guys! lets stop with the name calling and insults and get on with the real issue here! I'm glad that Key has at least decided on some form of emmissions cut, but I think NZ can do much better then this. On a personal level, I find that being eco-friendly saves me heaps of money and keeps me healthy too(cycling to work, growing own veges, using less power etc) Sure we can't save the world, but at least Aotearoa can do our bit to make it a little less polluted and a little more clean.

cyril
20 Aug 2009 3:37p.m.

They tell me Al Gore stands to make hundreds of millions of dollars if carbon credits are bought in. He is also supposed to be one of the biggest individual cotributers to global warming on the planet. If he was trying to save the planet not fill his pocket book he would be cutting his own carbon emissions.

Jim
20 Aug 2009 8:55a.m.

Helen, Geoff & Michael - WHY? Anyone who signs that referendum should put their actions where their mouth is and leave their comfortable homes and go hunting and gathering in the wild with Mr Gore & Co.!!!

Helen
20 Aug 2009 4:22a.m.

Michael the url is http://www.signon.org.nz/

Post a comment

Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:


3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - Steven Joyce
Comments (0)

How do you rate Steven Joyce?

John Key clearly rates his Transport Minister Steven Joyce - but how well do you think he has performed since National came to power....