• Full Story

Key scorned over teapot tape

Print

Fri, 27 Jan 2012 8:36a.m.

PM John Key (file AAP)

PM John Key (file AAP)

Opposition leaders are heaping scorn on Prime Minister John Key for continuing to refuse permission for the infamous "teapot tape" to be reported.

The recording of his election campaign conversation with ACT's John Banks was posted on YouTube on Thursday.

It was secretly recorded by a freelance cameraman during the media stunt at an Auckland cafe when Mr Key met Mr Banks to endorse him as National's favoured candidate.

It caused an uproar at the time and Mr Key called in the police, who are still investigating.

Radio New Zealand says it sought Mr Key's permission to broadcast the tape but he refused.

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters, who had a transcript of the tape during the campaign, says Mr Key's attitude is ridiculous and he's challenging RNZ to broadcast it.

Mr Peters has always maintained it isn't illegal to report what's on the tape or broadcast it, but the police say it is and mainstream media are holding off.

The poor quality recording on YouTube didn't reveal anything that wasn't known at the time and confirmed that Mr Key said NZ First's elderly supporters were "dying off".

Mr Key on Thursday apologised for that - even though he won't agree to his remarks being broadcast.

"This is making us look like a banana republic," Mr Peters said on Friday.

"For goodness sake, Mr Key staged a media stunt and there were reporters looking at him through the window."

Labour leader David Shearer says the whole thing is a joke and Mr Key shouldn't have called in the police in the first place.

NZN

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

29 Jan 2012 09:24p.m.

Boyd wrote:

Funny the National supporters dfending Key to the death. Had it been a meeting between..say...David Shearer and Hone Harawira would they have wnted those two able politicians to have their privacy? Of course not how silly of me to suggest that!! John Key can put through urgency a survellince bill but when it comes to something (In Nat supporters words) "unimportant" He wastes taxpayers money with a stupid police investigation.

29 Jan 2012 04:38p.m.

Cathy wrote:

Because blogs from 'Kiwi' and 'Banana Republic' are identical, we must assume they must be the same person. Then probably we should also write off contributions from 'Chargone' who likes to repeat the same blog in case the first one didn't get posted. When we next exclude trish and IAN, because of their openly biased and meaningless contributions, the comments overall indicate the so called 'Tea Tapes' are nothing worth considering further. ................................................................................................................................... Hopefully the Labour losers from the last election can accept the National did win the election, swallow their lost pride, and move on.

29 Jan 2012 04:38p.m.

Cathy wrote:

Because blogs from 'Kiwi' and 'Banana Republic' are identical, we must assume they must be the same person. Then probably we should also write off contributions from 'Chargone' who likes to repeat the same blog in case the first one didn't get posted. When we next exclude trish and IAN, because of their openly biased and meaningless contributions, the comments overall indicate the so called 'Tea Tapes' are nothing worth considering further. ................................................................................................................................... Hopefully the Labour losers from the last election can accept the National did win the election, swallow their lost pride, and move on.

27 Jan 2012 10:53p.m.

Banana Republic wrote:

The government has the right to install spy cameras in people's bedrooms but the people do not have the right to know what two wealthy, middle-aged or older, unscruplous politicians were talking about. If this is not Banana Republic then what is?

27 Jan 2012 05:54p.m.

Chargone wrote:

I'd say the ability for TV3 etc to say 'the polls say national will win!' and have a quater of the bloody elegable electors decide the whole thing's a done deal and NOT VOTE is a bigger issue in terms of making NZ look pathetic, actually... bigger issue in terms of Actually Being pathetic too. odds of John Key being prime minister now had that not happened are very low. (personally I'd like a conservative/green party coalition... incredibly improbable... they'd need to get the votes and then actually come to a viable working agreement... but it would be a huge improvement over the constant national/labour see-saw we've had since God knows when....)

27 Jan 2012 05:54p.m.

Chargone wrote:

I'd say the ability for TV3 etc to say 'the polls say national will win!' and have a quater of the bloody elegable electors decide the whole thing's a done deal and NOT VOTE is a bigger issue in terms of making NZ look pathetic, actually... bigger issue in terms of Actually Being pathetic too. odds of John Key being prime minister now had that not happened are very low. (personally I'd like a conservative/green party coalition... incredibly improbable... they'd need to get the votes and then actually come to a viable working agreement... but it would be a huge improvement over the constant national/labour see-saw we've had since God knows when....)

27 Jan 2012 05:32p.m.

Kiwi wrote:

The government has the right to install spy cameras in people's bedrooms but the people do not have the right to know what two wealthy, middle-aged or older, unscruplous politicians were talking about. If this is not Banana Republic then what is?

27 Jan 2012 01:51p.m.

jeanne wrote:

The only thing making NZ look like a banana republic is Winston Peters banging on with his pathetic protestations, and the gullible media reporting his every utterance.

27 Jan 2012 12:49p.m.

IAN wrote:

Forget the tapes [ old crap ] - Key is becoming a smooth master at "SPIN",if not outright lies.Listen to what he is saying carefully from now on!

27 Jan 2012 12:39p.m.

Paora wrote:

Sore losers like 'Clarke' arise out of their cess pits to spread their despotic doom and gloom through non-issues like the tea cup incident. Get over it 'Clarke' and move on to more important things. I would like to think it is possible for you to actually contribute something valuable, but going on your history of anti Key blogs, I'm not holding my breath.