Opinion: Key’s vote will decide gay marriage bill

Print

Fri, 27 Jul 2012 9:52a.m.

"Put simply, lots of the National MPs will do whatever Key does," Patrick says.

"Put simply, lots of the National MPs will do whatever Key does," Patrick says.

Opinion by Political Reporter Patrick Gower

Whether John Key says "I do" or "I don't" to same-sex marriage will decide whether or not the bill passes.

The Prime Minister's conscience is just one vote of 121 votes, but will be a critical lead to other National MPs.

As we saw yesterday, many of them would prefer to run than answer questions about gay marriage.

At the moment, Key's position is he will support the bill past its first reading. We don't know yet if he will vote against it at the third and final stage - like he did with Civil Unions. In that case, Key said he was acting on the wishes of his Helensville electorate.

So Key's "I'll support it to its first reading" is miles away from Obama's "I think same-sex couples should be able to get married".

Even if Key agrees with Obama, he may yet decide to go with the wishes of his conservative Helensville electorate and vote against same-sex marriage.

Key's branding and political power are so strong that if he backed out, a lot of the "undecided" National MPs would be empowered to as well.

On the flip side, if Key goes for it, they will be empowered to do the same.

Put simply: lots of the National MPs will do whatever Key does.

At the moment the numbers are pretty close. Key himself has acknowledged it's a conservative Parliament.

It would just take the rump of the National Party, John Banks, the NZ First guys and a few conservative Labour MPs to vote the bill down.

On the other hand, Key and National may want to look liberal; the party has just taken up the idea of same-sex adoption. Going for the bill could help Key in the centre-ground.

And that, of course, would open up room on the right for, guess who? The Conservatives leader Colin Craig.

National need a governing partner don't they?

By making a play for same-sex marriage, Key could just open the way for the partner he needs in 2014.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

30/11/2012 8:30:46 p.m.

terry wrote:

DB you wait till they get closer to the election with national down to 41 or 42 the media will have to make sure the conservitive paty the nz teleban will get elected torop up key .any christian party wants force people by law to do the moral things the bible teaches are a bunch of theologicly its the hight of legallisim. and its people must convert because they want to not becouse some state religious patys says so .its going back to the dark ages under paapal rule and the wicked evil popes of the time .the press will bring you the religious party if they have to to save key dont worry about that they are already talking about it ,

29/07/2012 6:17:17 p.m.

Marie ericksen wrote:

Key should vote with his concience rather than trying to please people

28/07/2012 8:33:37 p.m.

DB wrote:

Can you please stop talking about Colin Craig and the Conservative Party like he is a legitimate political player. He is a conservative christian in disguise of a political leader. He has no place forcing his religious views on the running of our country. His views are based solely on religious grounds, not moral ones, and certainly not in the interest of representation of the people of our country.

27/07/2012 10:47:19 a.m.

C wrote:

I trust Key will look to his Conservative counterparts - Harper in Canada, who has overseen legalized same-sex marriage since 2007, and Cameron in Britain, who said "Conservatives believe in the ties that bind us. Society is stronger when we make vows to each other and we support each other. I don’t support gay marriage in spite of being a conservative. I support gay marriage because I am a conservative".

Patrick Gower's Entries

Previous123Next