• Full Story

Kiwi parents give smacking a 'time out'

Print

Sat, 25 Jul 2009 12:00a.m.

Fewer New Zealand parents smack their children today than in past decades, according to results of a poll released today.

A non-binding citizens-initiated referendum on whether smacking should remain a criminal offence is due to held from next Friday to August 21.

A Weekend Herald-DigiPoll poll of 200 parents of four-year-olds found that 9 percent of mothers and 8 percent of fathers smacked their children at least one a week.

The figures were significantly down from those contained in four surveys by Waikato University psychologists Jane and James Ritchie from 1963 to 1997.

The Ritchies found that about half of all parents of four-year-olds through those 3-1/2 decades smacked their children at least once a week.

The Digipoll results also show that two-thirds of both mothers and fathers still smack occasionally, despite the law change two years ago banning the use of force against children for the purpose of correction.

However, the number who never smacked, which remained below 10 percent in the Ritchies' studies, had jumped to 39 per cent of mothers and 33 per cent of fathers.

The poll also found that 78.5 per cent of the parents questioned planned to vote in the referendum, with 14 percent saying they wouldn't be taking part and the rest unsure.

Of those planning to vote, an overwhelming 85.4 percent said they would vote "no" to the question: "Should a smack as part of good parental correction be a criminal offence in New Zealand?"

Only 10.8 per cent indicated they would vote "yes".

Green MP Sue Bradford, who promoted the 2007 law change, said the fall in the smacking rate was positive.

"I think that's a fantastic sign of hope for the future of our nation that there has been such a dramatic shift in the last 12 years," she told the Herald.

But Family First New Zealand national director Bob McCoskrie, who is urging a "no" vote at the referendum, said the poll showed that many parents were continuing to flout the law.

"Parents are ignoring the law because they simply don't agree with it and because it is so confusing," he said.

"But what is most significant in this latest poll is that even parents who choose not to smack are opposed to it being criminalised."

NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

04 Aug 2009 02:09p.m.

larnie wrote:

ya i have this to say . i have child youth and family on my back over d.v and voteing for this would'nt be any good for me even when they find your name down as saying yes you should. what would that do to me in getting my chid back that go against me in the court of lawyer woul'nt it. that what thier jobs are there for. so voteing for me would be not so good. Have the govement people takin that in to view. think not.

30 Jul 2009 08:03p.m.

Karen & Evan wrote:

NZ parents should maintain the right to discipline and correct their children in love. At times this may include a smack on the bottom or hand as a means of correction, but not given in a state of anger. The goal is to amend bad behaviour with the appropriate correction. There is a big difference between child abuse, which is wrong, and loving correction which helps raise a well adjusted NZ citizen.

28 Jul 2009 07:09a.m.

Glenn wrote:

And isn't it evident by the behaviour of our youth today!