3News » Home
Full Story

Minimum wage increase a 'slap in the face'

40 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Unite member Joe Carolan has labelled the increase a "slap in the face"

Unite member Joe Carolan has labelled the increase a "slap in the face"

video
Wed, 27 Jan 2010 6:38p.m.

By Duncan Garner

The Government has given the country’s lowest paid workers a rise – but unions and advocates say the 25c an hour increase to the minimum wage is "pathetic" and "an insult".

The minimum wage will change to $12.75 an hour, up from $12.50, giving workers an extra $10 per week – costing employers $52 million across the board.

Critics have been quick to criticise, and once PAYE tax and new ACC levies are deducted, the rise barely equates to $6 per week.

As a cleaner at Parliament, Lugi Fa’amausili is paid $12.55 an hour – 5c above the current minimum wage. The increase to the minimum wage will see her earning an additional 20c an hour.

“So what?”she asks. “It’s shocking, and I’m not very happy about it.”

Ms Fa’amausili is one of more than 100,000 workers on the minimum wage. The additional 25c an hour barely covers the cost of inflation, but the Government says any higher and their jobs may be lost.

“We’re taking a cautious approach – we’re concerned on the impact of jobs, both in terms of creation of jobs, retention of jobs, and perhaps even reduction of working hours,” says Labour Minister Kate Wilkinson.

Within hours of the announcement, unions and low-paid workers started reacting. Earlier this afternoon a protest took place outside the Auckland Chamber of Commerce.

“Twenty-five cents an hour for the lowest paid workers is not going to solve the problem of the working poor in New Zealand,” says Joe Carolan of Unite.

“It’s a real slap in the face and a cheap shot.”

The Government is not arguing with the figures.Ms Wilkinson says it is a “modest” increase.

“We’ve done that to maintain that relatively with the CPI," she says.

“It’s really mean and miserable,” says Labour party MP Trevor Mallard. “It probably means about $6 in the hand for the average low-paid worker – and that’s just not fair. It’s hardly worth having.”

Ms Fa’amausili says the increase means very little.

“I’m not happy about it, because I know it’s not enough to support my family,” she says.

National’s record on the minimum wage is poor, and even today the party admitted officials recommended a number of larger increases – but National opted to go with the smallest one of just 25c.

There is no shortage of critics tonight who claim this shows National cares little for low-paid workers.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [40]

chris
08 Feb 2011 9:20a.m.

Raising minimum wage (MW) just hurts everybody but especially low wage earners in the long run. If MW jumps to $15 then those people who have been working for a couple of years and have earned and increase to $15 would then be on MW. They then should get a rise so they are then earning same as their supervisors, they get a rise and so on and so on. The business owners are left with two choices, lay off staff or raise prises. You end up with higher unemployment, higher prises and more people on minimum wage with even less spending power. The answer is not raising MW but up skilling yourself so you become more valuable to your employer.

Alex
14 Feb 2010 3:43p.m.

If you are not a student and on minimum wage it is not the governments fault. if you want to earn more then work for it. to compare NZ wages with AUS is wrong. I lived in WA in 2006 was earning AU$1500(after tax) a week. and had no more money then i do now earning NZ$500(after tax). living costs are just so much more expencive. meat and vegtables where the same price that we pay now. we have it easy in NZ. it always urks me when i hear people complaining about 50c-$1 pay rises.

will
06 Feb 2010 7:22p.m.

Working in NZ is a joke! We pay through the nose for everything! We get treated like rubbish by our employers. We have no common sense in our dollar, we don't value it!We allow companies to ruin us financially,telephone companies for example-big ones. Enough is enough-change the rules or we leave and work overseas anyone if common sense finds somewhere better to earn nowadays. Australia is only across the ditch.

darth
30 Jan 2010 12:24a.m.

what really erks me is its the big buisiness that pay mimimum wages! companies paying F?'k all to people doing the sh+t jobs, its so unfair, i worked for spotless with my partner we had to start work at 2 in the morning cleaning a supermarket for minimum wage. Caregivers get paid minimum wages, having to deal with verbal and physical abuse, cleaning feaces off everthing imaginable, lifting overweight abusive elderly into showers, straining there backs, they are taking care of elderly being paid $12.50, is that fair???? hell no!!!! If you live for a week on minimum wage you'll soon realise how much it sux!!

darth
30 Jan 2010 12:23a.m.

what really erks me is its the big buisiness that pay mimimum wages! companies paying F?'k all to people doing the sh+t jobs, its so unfair, i worked for spotless with my partner we had to start work at 2 in the morning cleaning a supermarket for minimum wage. Caregivers get paid minimum wages, having to deal with verbal and physical abuse, cleaning feaces off everthing imaginable, lifting overweight abusive elderly into showers, straining there backs, they are taking care of elderly being paid $12.50, is that fair???? hell no!!!! If you live for a week on minimum wage you'll soon realise how much it sux!!

Glenn
29 Jan 2010 5:34p.m.

And where will the money come from for the min wage increase. The Bosses arent going to take it out of their profits. They'll increase their prices. We'll all be paying more for everything. So why should people who have worked hard and earned their pay rise have to be payed the same as these bum who just want something for nothing. They should just learn to budget better or get a new job that pays better. Dont drag the rest down so you can be no better off.

Simon
29 Jan 2010 12:15a.m.

Andrew, not sure we had any option to join the E U, the POM'S did not really want to join but by 1976 they were a basket case anyway, world bank had to bail them out.

The point is NZ cannot continue the way it is and expect to have a 1st world life style or income.

The reason I despair is that Kiwis do not aspire to suceed in anything but sport.

I am a wealthy man, I do not need to stay in NZ but I choose to.

Creation of wealth is despised in NZ, not encouraged.

I think this comes from our English heritage which appears to have a balanced attitude to life, a chip on both shoulders.

Without wealth creation NZ is condemned to a subsistence life style.

Until we mature as a nation like the States or Australia, change our chip on the shoulder attitude to those suceed in business, encourage them to stay and invest here instead of taking their wealth overseas we have a major problem.

Sure u will have noticed that most sports stars leave these shores very quickly for greater wealth as soon as they rise to top level.

Is not unique to business leaders.

This will not happen whilst we have a left wing media and an MMP govt system which encourages Govt to do nothing but what is popular for the masses.

I care because it frustrates me that we could do so much better, however at the age of 60, after 40 years observation of NZ I have seen nothing that encourages me that public attitude and govt policies are likely to change.

Al I see is a steady irreversible slide to 3rd world nation hood.

I see nothing in what the latest do nothing National govt are doing which wil change this and Labour are the only alternative.

All both ever do is buy a bigger bucket to bail out the life boat, neither have any real answers.

One day there will be no life boat to bail out.

Andrew
28 Jan 2010 9:11p.m.

Simon, I also seem to recall only the US, Canada and Sweden doing better than us. Our economic demise actually began around 1967 when we ought to have applied to join the EC with Britain. This option was never publically raised then or at any time since. Call it a victory of geography over history. Now the only realistic long-term option is union with Australia. It just might work.

Simon
28 Jan 2010 6:46p.m.

Andrew I agree, it was a long winded blog but is is fact.

I have many positive things I could say but it would be

pointless, they have all been said by many in reports to

both labour and national.

However Kiwis don't want to hear what is required to turn this country around and govts are too gutless to act.

In 1960 we rated 3rd in lifestyle and wealth in the OECD

In the late 70ties a Kiwi dollar was worth US $1.40

20 years ago Aust and Kiwi incomes were the same.

Aust has growth each year of 3-4%, Asian countries 6-10%

Year on year we struggle for 2%

We will just continue to fall behind, it is not rocket

science.

Andrew u will say it doesn't matter but it is the reason we have a wage of $12.75hr

Kiwis should not complain,we get what we deserve.

S.K
28 Jan 2010 3:15p.m.

It must be nice to live the upper class life Cherie of which im sure you are but not many people are so fortunate as others like yourself. Get off your so called almighty horse and smell the roses mate. middle class and above that will always be up there because National and people like think your above anything pity and you wouldnt be up there if wasnt for the ordinary working class man who slaves his ass off to get the job done. Get over yourself.........

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - Was the force used at the Dotcom mansion excessive?
On January 20th, two helicopters and 76 police officers arrived a
Comments (187)