3News » Home
Full Story

Mum believes 'healthy food' made baby sick

27 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Artificial additives like msg are present in almost every processed thing we eat

Artificial additives like msg are present in almost every processed thing we eat

video
Thu, 09 Apr 2009 12:00a.m.

The sizzling sound of saturated fat. Wedges are being cooked in beef tallow and served up at a primary school.

“The push generally has been towards healthier options, salads and promoting whole grain breads and low fat product, so I'm sure there is some resistance towards frying the food for Bluestone in the beef fat,” said Cate Sutherland, catering manager at Timaru Boys High School and Bluestone Primary School.

And there has been some turn around in tuck shop ideology but it’s not just about saturated fat - it's about preservative free food.

“I've long thought about the additional things in foods - the chemicals and the hormones and preservatives, things that are put in to add colour and increase the lifespan of shelf goods and yeah I did see that they could potentially be causing some harm so I was happy to follow through with it, said Sutherland.

Sutherland is following through with the theory cooked up by mum Rachel Tomkinson.

“For a long time we've been taught that saturated fat’s especially a bad for us but I believe whole heartedly that that’s definitely wrong. Back in the old days grandma used to have dripping sandwiches, didn't hurt them they didn't have cancer like they do today,” said Tomkinson.

Rachel Tomkinson is the last person you'd expect to be an advocate for saturated fat.

She's a nurse and personal trainer - obsessed for years with diet foods.

These days her obsession is with preservatives

“Msg or mono sodium glutamate or more sad goo – it’s easier that way and basically goo has been around for 100 years and it’s excitotoxin and it tricks our brain for us to want to keep eating more and it throws us out of balance,” said Tomkinson.

Artificial additives like msg are present in almost every processed thing we eat...disguised under a multitude of names.

Rachel believes that it was her msg full diet that gave her breast-fed daughter chronic eczema and multiple allergies.

“Until I eliminated those foods and introduced funnily enough what healed Jenna were the things we're not supposed to have which is saturated fats such as dripping cream butter all those things and she came right,” said Tomkinson.

It was a radical shift in thinking for a health professional.

But the proof says Rachel was in the pudding, apple crumble.

“Saturated fats give food flavour and they keep you content - so when the flavour went out of food with the fats they had to put something else in to make it palatable and to taste good so hence why the glutamate industry went 'boof,' skyrocketed with the processed foods industries because the goo came in to replace the fat,” said Tomkinson.

And could the cost of that...be our health?

Liam Bain was born with severe allergies and was following a strictly gluten and lactose free diet when he got sick six months ago.

Doctors were at a loss.

Then Melissa Bain read Rachel’s book and overhauled his diet

“And that was really scary. I’m not underestimating the fear was huge to re-introduce wheat, which we weren't meant to be giving him but organic wheat in its purest form to put a child to bed we were really scared and no reaction – nil,” said Tomkinson.

Four restaurants have also adopted Rachel’s saturated fat - preservative free food on their menus

“It totally makes sense when you think about it it’s like what Mum and Dad used to feed us isn't it?” said Debs Wilson from Pukeko café and deli.

CampbellLIVE

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [27]

Larry
23 Aug 2009 4:39a.m.

Tony, this is absurd. Cholesterol causes Heart Disease? Boo!!! Since when did the liver produce something that causes disease? High Cholesterol is not by diet, it is by cholesterol not being used. Saturated fat and cholesterol are not related. One is a fat and the other is a sterol. About nitrites in red meat... Avoid the factory farm meats - they're the ones that are likely to have these. Show me a randomized controlled study (not a epidemiological study) that shows that sat fat causes heart disease.

Bob
10 Aug 2009 9:32a.m.

Here's a later interview with Rachel on Jimmy Moor's show.

"How Saturated Fats Saved My Baby Jenna"

http://www.thelivinlowcarbshow.com/shownotes/678/rachel-tomkinson-how-saturated-fats-saved-baby-jenna-episode-276/

Tina
08 May 2009 9:23a.m.

Tony you asked for some evidence on the virtues of saturated fats in regards to healing our bodies:
• My daughter would be up most of the night in excruciating pain with severe stomach cramping. When I began to trial our traditional food diet I gave my daughter some coconut oil and low and behold WITHIN A MINUTE she would do a terrific blow off and then she would immediately settle herself back to sleep. Before we would be up and down throughout the night until she managed to pass wind. If I had no other saturated fat to offer her I reluctantly offered dripping and she hated the taste but she ate all of it because she KNEW that she needed it.
• She will ask for a little more saturated fat when she isn’t feeling well. Just like chicken soup for a cold - saturated fat increases our immunity.
• Saturated fat cures the discomfort of several days’ constipation. Excrements are softer and painless to pass. She passes them with no bowel bleeding and pain as before.
• Children instinctively crave fat. They need it to grow and my daughter has just completed two large growth spurts! Mentally she is sharper than ever! My daughter on her extreme food exclusion diet ate mostly meat favouring the meat juices, skin and fat portions the most.
• When I reintroduced the biggest allergy food – egg, I was told that she would react badly to this. I tried just a tiny amount three times within the same week. The third time too much – remember my accumulation hypothesis, and her face puffed up, she went pale and very cold. Out of panic I gave her a spoon of butter. I took a photo and thirty minutes later I captured another displaying hardly any trace of her previous severe reaction. She didn’t have her usual diarrhoea symptoms. No antihistamines here!
• When my daughter is hyperactive, a spoonful of butter calms and settles her within fifteen minutes. No sedatives here like we used to use to get her calm!
• Miraculously we can tolerate butter but not dairy.


Tina
07 May 2009 11:45p.m.

My family’s health is testament to the truth of over-processed, over-pasteurised, and over-chemicalised foods. There is no such thing as allergies! Allergies are a scapegoat for a much bigger problem. Chemicals in foods are toxic poisons that accumulate in our bodies until our immunity is eventually affected. Get rid of the poisons, not the so-called allergic foods in their natural state, and the symptoms resolve themselves quickly. Resume eating the foods containing chemical triggers and the symptoms begin again.

My two-and-a-half year old cognitively gifted daughter developed 65 “so-called” allergies and showed early tendencies for ADHD/Autism? All she could eat was beef, chicken and lamb. We spent $250 per month on natural and pharmaceutical drugs per month approved by five medical professionals to try and help manage her discomfort.

She suffered from painful stomach cramps, diarrhoea, constipation, vomiting, she often walked into walls so I expect that she was dizzy, and had difficulty swallowing often choking on food. She ate bland foods sized for a child half her age very slowly. She could not eat raw fruits and vegetables so she consumed canned baby food suitable for a four month old to eat. Two months prior to changing her diet she could finally eat whole canned fruit pieces. My daughter would also have unusual chills and fevers – hot or ice cold to touch on the outside yet the complete opposite if your took her temperature. She had eczema, the inability to sleep well (at one-and-half years old she had an average sleep of 8-10 hours of interrupted rest per 24 hours!), and she struggled to add body weight and fat stores on her body. Yes these are the symptoms for allergies but Google symptoms of poisoning and you find exactly the same thing!

As the Father of Medicine stated once – “Let food be our medicine and medicine be our food!”




david
23 Apr 2009 7:31p.m.

This just seems like someone's bizarre opinion on the "evils" of healthy food, masquerading as a news item. I listened in vain for any mention of scientific trials or evidence and it was a week late for April Fool, so I just assumed that Campbell Live has become a dumping ground for the sort of far-fetched, titillating trivia that most serious news organizations filter out with their "spam" button. Couldn't this sort of "news" be run during the middle of the day, when it's likely to better received by viewers with dripping running down their chins? Or does Campbell want to run a story on the farmer who rubs cow-dung onto his head cause he swears it's good for his hair? So, come on Tv3, decide whether you want serious, credible stories or whether you want to complete your descent into the seventh circle of tabloid television. Because you can't do both!

Tony
22 Apr 2009 9:10p.m.

Rachel,
Just a few things you should know about saturated fat, which I forgot to mention. The body makes all the saturated fat it needs, so if you have enough calories you will never become deficient in saturated fat. Also not all saturated fat is equal.
Myristic acid C:14 considered the worst of the bunch and is high in butter. Stearic acid C:18 gets converted to oleic acid in the liver, and oleic acid is less harmful. However, stearic acid is potently thrombogenic, which is ideal for strokes and heart attacks.

But if I was going to recommend a source of saturated fat to anyone, I would say eat dark
chocolate which is high in saturated fat, but also has loads of flavanoids. At least dark
chocolate has been shown in clinical studies to reduce mortality, which no one has been
able to show with butter/lard. So what's wrong with dark chocolate?

The marathon runner used to eat mainly fish'n chips, which used to be cooked in mostly
palm oil. Palm oil is one of the more stable cooking oils, and is I believe one recommended
by WestonAPrice. It certainly didn't help him much, and it certainly isn't helping the
orangutans of Indonesia either who are losing their habitat.

I don't have a problem with what you think works for you. But your message could actually do other people alot of damage. If someone out there saw this media report and starts eating saturated fat and dies of a stroke in 10 years, how would you ever know? That is why scientific studies matter, because they are the only tool we have for predicting the effects of certain diets.

The headline is also not a very helpful community health message "healthy food made child sick". Many people will interpret this as a licence to eat junk high energy foods. Did you know NZers eat 3500Kcal a day, with a high daily intake of fat? This is not only a health problem, but is unsustainable. We would need an extra earth if the world's population ate this many calories daily.

Rachel Tomkinson
22 Apr 2009 6:41p.m.

Hi Tony, just to also let you know it has been nice having a wee debate with you, but I am now signing off. Take care......Cheers Rachel :)

Rachel Tomkinson
21 Apr 2009 8:19p.m.

Dear Tony, Jenna`s eczema was severe, as well as her having 24 food allergies and was commonly vomiting and suffered from diarrohea. Life was miserable for her and very concerning for us as parents to watch your baby constantly scratch herself until she was a bleeding mess, and then putting up with the oozy puss and smell was absolutely dreadful. Until you yourself are in this predicament YOU will never understand!
You obviously have not been reading my answers very well, as it wasn`t the fat that was the whole story that healed Jenna, it wasn`t until I removed the "GOO" (hidden excitotoxins, such as MSG, HVP and Aspartic Acid) from our diets that we were healed. I was following YOUR healthier so-called diet that is recommended by the heart foundation, but it wasn`t working, as a lot of these foods also contained GOO! I introduced the saturated fats again to give food flavour, and in my opinion many healthy vitamins and minerals. When the saturated fats were removed the GLUTAMATE industries took over big time, to give food flavour and shelf life.
If you think your food is so right I then offer to you to re-introduce these foods back to my daughter (including marmite)and then film it for proof, why don`t you ask TV3?
Sulphur dioxide is harmful as well as many other chemicals, such as GOO in the accumulative effect.
People who have low cholesterol think they are safe from heart disease, the way its portrayed. Its not specific enough....
Your marathon runner eg is very interesting as do you know if he just ate saturated fats or was it more likely trans fats, found in most "unhealthy" foods, as well as many excitotoxins?
By the way I am not batting for any side, I just know YOUR side didn`t work for us. I know you believe what you do and I believe what I do, there will be no changing that, no matter how many "scientific" studies you show me. As they say the proof is in the pudding :)

Tony
21 Apr 2009 12:34a.m.

Rachel,

I have answers to your questions. I can understand why the eczema issue might have swayed you to try something different. But you should know that my colleague developed an idiopathic eczema. But guess what? It went away. Not only that he changed nothing in his diet. If you were to convince me that saturated fat was what made the difference, take the fat away for a few weeks, if the eczema comes back, then I will leave you in peace. It is
standard practice in checking food allergies to challenge the patient with the food to see
if the symptoms come back. It does no harm to do this.

With regard sulphur, the issue is too much of it is a problem, not just for the bowel. It
increases acidity, with the effect of calcium leaching out of bones. A simple home expt with a
pH meter is to have high protein/sulphur meals and check your daily urine pH. It will go acid below 6. Go on nothing but plants for a few days, urine goes close to pH7.

People with low cholesterol still have heart attacks because their LDL becomes oxidised, but its a question of age standardised rates. Also, high cholesterol is still fuel for atherosclerosis and does not mean you are less likely to develop LDL oxidation. A famous NZ marathon runner died of a heart attack at 42, thinking he was bullet proof and he ate mostly fat, and had no family history. I think that you are batting for the wrong team, as there is alot more to nutrition than what WestonAPrice say on the subject. The important evidence to consider is disease/mortality data in epidemiological studies, something nowhere near WAPrice radar. They prefer to believe meaningless animal studies.

Also, my B12 is 453pmol/l, and red cell folate is 1012nmol/l. What other B vitamins should I be worried about?

Rachel Tomkinson
19 Apr 2009 9:20p.m.

Tony :) its great you have brought this to light re Sulphur Dioxide. So are you saying that natural foods like red meat, liver, poultry, pork and eggs are causing bowel problems from this study? Wow, looks like another study to scare the consumer to avoid these type of foods. Soon there won`t be anything natural for us left to eat, as it looks like our natural food is the enemy in our modern diseases.
Just recently we have been informed to eat eggs again, because they are not going to hurt our heart, but rather looks like now they could hurt our bowel, is it any wonder the consumer is confused?
Maybe just like there are natural occurring trans fats in saturated fats, that then there are also natural occurring byproducts re sulphur dioxide once these foods are cooked. I just think that the mother nature ones are ok for our bods, but I would rather stay clear of the man made synthetic ones, as they can never copy it quite as good as mother nature.
By the way I am also awaiting your answer on why people who have low cholesterol still die of heart disease?
Have a great week :)

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion